Australian ban; Egar illegal

Status
Not open for further replies.

e-pipeman

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 16, 2008
5,430
5,594
Brown Edge, England
The history of liberty is a history of the limitation of government power, not the increase of it. -Woodrow Wilson

We need less authority, more anarchy.

Sadly we sit by and allow our Government to pass legislation that insidiously chips away at freedoms we have gained over centuries. We used to elect people to represent us, but now they dictate to us. With regard to legislation it would perhaps be better to start enforcing the laws already on the statute book rather than forever generating new laws that will never be enforced for reasons of economics. Rant over.:)
 

cucurucho

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
I do not know if the following document dated Oct 2008 has been discussed in this forum.

Pages 126-143 give a "record of reasons" for the decisions on the electronic cigarette by the Therapeutic Goods Administration:

www(dot)tga(dot)gov(dot)au/ndpsc/record/rr200810(dot)pdf

Substitute "(dot)"with "." as I cannot post links yet in this forum.

Or just google for "rr200810.pdf"

Thanks for posting this, it's a very interesting read indeed.

I'm mostly annoyed that this discussion wasn't up for public debate.

One point that I think could have helped our plight:
The attractiveness of e-smoking to a non smoker would be largely offset by the upfront cost of purchasing a device with cartridges, compared to the cost of pack of cigarettes. Any non smoker who would turn to using the device would just as likely turn to using tobacco products in the absence of personal vaporisers from the market.
 

alwhis

Full Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 20, 2008
15
1
Kansas, USA
I am new here. But after reading these posts I feel a real kinship with the people here on the forum. Although speaking in a very general sense, I believe there is rebellious nature to smokers in general, as well as those that drink. I know I have NEVER felt apart of normal society in general. That goes back to my first real thoughts on this matter in High School. I am a baby boomer now, and when I look back and compare society in my days and the present day, the differences are plain, at least for me, to see.

Perhaps as it becomes more socially unacceptable, it also appears that we become outcasts of the state we belong to. Which I believe is the real reason behind all this. We therefore can be identified.

Unless and until we ALL think alike, and we ALL begin to act alike, the powers to be will not be satisfied. We can and are being controlled, and this I believe is ALL governments ultimate goal.

I could go on, but don't what to blemish my standing so soon with talk of a rebellious streak in me a mile long. :)
 

deewal

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 30, 2008
692
3
78
In a house.
We need clinical trials, research, tests, anything that proves it's better than smoking and can be used as a low risk medicine. That all takes time, inclination and investment, none of which seem to be joining up at the moment.

I blame that directly on the Manufacturer's of E-Cigs and Liquid.
It is their Product. If they wan't to sell it without issue then they should be doing all of these things. Their apparent refusal to do this makes even me suspicious and nervous and i'm pro E-Cigs.
It's not as if the Technology to do this is not available and if i was an Anti i would immediately ask to see this proof of the claims made by the Manufacturer's.
Mankind is capable of sending Probes into Deep Space, have telescopes that can see Billions of years back into the Cosmos, can Split the Atom amongst other thing.
I don't see how proving the safety of E-Cigs can be such an enormous task.

Oh and @ alwhis:
We can and are being controlled, and this I believe is ALL governments ultimate goal.
Of course it is and it is almost in place in the UK.
Watch the Movie "Children of Men". It is chilling in it's accuracy of the UK as it could be because we are almost there now and the Movie is set in 2020.
 

TropicalBob

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 13, 2008
5,623
65
Port Charlotte, FL USA
Over on the snus forum that I frequent, there has been an ongoing discussion of e-cigs. And someone noted this that I believe is true: If e-cigs had come from Big Pharma or Big Tobacco, they would have been welcomed and accepted. But they come from China and we know NOTHING about their contents that can be said with assurance. This is untenable and that's why action is considered necessary to either ban or regulate them.

I remember a poster last January, Perfectionist, who said if the e-cig had come from Apple as the I-cig, it would be accepted and would sell billions worldwide without any protest. But Apple didn't give us melamine, either.

Its today's situation that can't continue. And it worsens daily with modern-day carnival barkers drawing in the sheep to fleece at mall kiosks.

"It's the new miracle of technology, my friends, a cigarette-like device that will free you from the Demon Weed. No tobacco. No fire. No limits! Smoke it anywhere. It's healthy too. You'll quit nasty cigarettes without cravings, without irritating others, all the while adding years to your life.

"Listen up now. This fabulous product can be yours, not for $500, not for $300, not even for $200, but for only $159. And if you act now, we'll throw in, absolutely free, an extra pack of cartridges with unknown contents. Step right up, ladies and gentlemen. Don't push now. There's plenty for everyone ..."


With e-smoking friends like that promoting us, we don't need enemies.
 
Welcome back O e-cig forum !!! the fight is still on !!
another article appeared on E-cigarettes being sold online | News | News.com.auE-cigarettes being sold online | News | News.com.au and I have submitted a comment plus an invitation to the editors to follow up with both myself and Dr Laugesen ....
It also appears importation of NON nicotine vaping supplies is ok via customs .... dont lose the faith !!!
( Oh and as an aside, during the break I have secured supplies of pharmaceutical grade glycerol and propylene glycol if any aussies need em for watering down purposes !!! )
 

dc2k08

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 21, 2008
1,765
40
.ie
www.e-cignews.com
Nice to see the health minister concerned about the children.

"This looks like another insidious, manipulative attempt to hook people on smoking", "I'd be very concerned about any attempts to promote smoking, especially to young people."


Were you ever able to find out Trumpy whether it's definitely not permissible to purchase nicotine liquid from outside of Oz for personal use?
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately DC importation of nicotine in any form without Government dispensation or permission is an offence.... sigh... the "personal use" applies in NZ but not here... it needs to have an amendment to the poisons register akin to the one made for cigarettes, and I dont see that happening without some major moving and shaking ... still trying tho !!
 
This inane linking by the Govt to smoking gets right up my bum !!!
e-cigs arent smoking dammit !!!!!
And I have NEVER seen ANY marketing of e-cigs aimed towards children, or non-smokers... its more ill-informed ( and possibly deviously crafted ) propaganda to support the Govts stance
GRrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr I am getting mightily ...... now LOL
 
Last edited:
here is my comment to the editor of that article dated 19.1.2009

" I am a e-cigarette user, I chose to stop smoking the 4000 chemicals and over 60 carcinogens that our Government legally allows me to purchase in a corner store. After considerable research I chose to replace tobacco products with a blend of propylene glycol, water,a very small amount of alcohol, food grade flavourings and pure nicotine. THIS is what is in the liquid in e-cigs!!! All of the ingredients are food grade or better. E-cigarettes have to my knowledge have NEVER been marketed towards those who don't already smoke...this is HARM REDUCTION OF THE FIRST ORDER. I would strongly recommend all readers look at the Health NZ site which has extensively tested these products ( The only Govt who has) and have declared them a far safer alternative to tobacco and in fact recommend that tobacco be banned and replaced by e-cigarettes ( see Untitled Document ) and download their extensive testing at http://healthnz.co.nz/RuyanCartridgeReport21-Oct-08.pdf for the FACTS on e-cigarettes... I invite the editors and publishers as well as anyone interested of this article to contact me as I have done extensive research on these items and remain firmly convinced it is NOT in the public interest to ban them whatsoever !!!
I feel it is a shameless act of the government to ban these , based on misinformation and the need to foster a "nanny " state upon us
Not to mention the fact they haven't formalised a taxing framework as yet , so they knee jerked and banned it by using a loophole in legislation and making the nicotine a schedule 7 poison.... funny how you can still buy it in a taxable form though ( cigarettes )???
This ban was foisted without public consultation, and turned me into a criminal overnight, businesses were shut down with 14 hours notice,.... I will continue to "vape" knowing it is far far safer for me and those around me...
SHAME ON YOU , when tax dollars over-rides public health and interest ! "
 
Last edited:

Tetsab

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 10, 2008
187
35
East Sussex, UK
Trumpy - good to see you back, mate. Keep up the good fight. I'd never thought of Aus having the same kind of nannying legislators as we do here in the UK. You'd have to be a damn well-off teenager to afford to buy a starter kit + supplies (as well as prepared to wait for 'em to arrive) rather than trotting off to a shop and buying a pack of analogues, or getting someone to buy them for you.

Think you should jump all over eBay too - get them to understand there is NO, repeat NO tobacco in an e-cig. As a result it cannot infringe their regs relating to tobacco products. Surely it should be in the same position as rolling papers and filters, which are certainly freely available on eBay in Blighty.

Oh, it's so good to be back. <memo to self - don't forget to go and offer polite thanks to the other forums who've given us refuge, solace and info>

:cool: :D :cool:
 

dc2k08

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 21, 2008
1,765
40
.ie
www.e-cignews.com
your right, it is completely inane that she might consider these a ploy to hook people on smoking and that she is worried for the children at the cost of those already hooked who have found a possible worthy replacement.

If she wanted to do her job correctly she would offer a grant to a university to test the liquid's safety (from tobacco taxes), fund a study to see if they work as a cessation device and and not just come out with some cliché boilerplate response. I better see her initiating every single recommendation put forward at the FCTC in Durban last year if that's the line she's taking on these. Otherwise I'll brand her a hypocrite.
 
Last edited:

SpaceCadet

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 10, 2009
336
0
Scotland
I'm a big fan of the Australian TV show Border Security (aka Nothing To Declare on the Living channel), and I've noticed how incredibly nanny-ish Australia can be! Yeah, searching for ...... hidden in people's luggage (or stomachs) is fair enough, but the range of stuff that is quarantined 'to protect Australia's environment' is a bit over the top in my opinion. I saw one episode recently where they quarantined and treated an ancient antique box 'cos it had some kind of woodworm damage, claiming that Australia's forests would be decimated if the box were released to its new owner untreated.

Pleased to see though that nearby NZ is being far more tolerant concerning the e-cigs.
 

Tetsab

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 10, 2008
187
35
East Sussex, UK
Oddly, the timber thing is actually quite logical and there are good reasons for it. As the continent has been isolated physically from the rest of the world's landmasses, their native forests etc would have no defences against imported diseases and pests. Plant disease and so forth isn't very sexy for news items but can be devastating.

Don't know if you're old enough Cadet, but do you remember we used to have something called elm trees in the UK? They're nearly as rare as hens teeth now. Colorado beetle attacking potatoes? If not, just consider what rabbits have done in Australia - a major pest with no natural predators to control them. And once they're in, how do you get them out of such a vast landmass? I don't recollect any rabies scares here for some years, but just imagine bird flu and foot-and-mouth precautions x about 1,000.

From what I've heard, this antique box was pretty lucky - apparently it isn't unusual for untreated wood products to be literally incinerated on the dock.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread