Banished to the smokers' section

Status
Not open for further replies.

ClippinWings

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 12, 2011
1,641
1,889
The OC
My employer requires you to be in a designated smoking area, and classifies vaping as a tobacco product. They are going tobacco free at the end of the year. :( Currently I have to sit in a vehicle with a min. of 3 other smokers to get my vape on. We used to be able to smoke outside but they figure it is healthier if we smoke inside a small confined space now. Corporate logic!

That may be illegal.

I'm no expert, buy I'm pretty sure that's not ok.

I mean, sure they can make you go outside... But I think the confined space would be illegal without proper ventilation.

Sent from my mobile, using Tapatalk... so ignore the typos. ;)
 
Last edited:

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
That may be illegal.

I'm no expert, buy I'm pretty sure that's not ok.

I mean, sure they can make you go outside... But I think the confined space would be illegal without proper ventilation.

Sent from my mobile, using Tapatalk... so ignore the typos. ;)

The other option is to not vape while at work.
 

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
You could get your doctor to give you a letter stating that you have acute allergies to cigarette smoke. Under the ADA they would need to provide you a safe area to vape.

Are electronic cigarettes medical devices? No. No one has a right to vape on property that they don't own. The compound I work at is completely tobacco free- e-cigs prohibited as well. Not on the property, not in our vehicles and not within site of the property. Are the rules extreme? Maybe. Are they legal? Yes. They own the property and I am an employee. If I don't like the rules, I am free to work elsewhere. I can wait until I take my long break, so I can leave the property. If I can't go several hours without a vape, maybe it is time to rethink vaping.
 

Abbell

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 30, 2013
365
271
53
Kansas City, MO
That may be illegal.

I'm no expert, buy I'm pretty sure that's not ok.

I mean, sure they can make you go outside... But I think the confined space would be illegal without proper ventilation.

Sent from my mobile, using Tapatalk... so ignore the typos. ;)


It depends on what state you work in... the "laws" vary. For example; MO and KS are right to work states and that means if you don't like the rules you can quit at any time. They can demand you have to stand on your head once an hour and as long as you agreed to that when you were hired there is no legal recourse other than civil... and even that could be argued. Don't believe? Here is a real example; A friend went into work for his 9am shift. They told him they changed the schedule and he works at 4pm. He was ...... and called the labor relations board for the state. End result... he went to work at 4p because there was no recourse.

As long as you agree to work for an employer and have no medical reason to use a nicotine replacement therapy then you are S.O.L..

Even with a "medical" excuse the employer is only required to make a reasonable accommodation.

It is the end result of smokers being permitted to smoke everywhere... even in hospitals. This is an argument we will not win. There is to much of a social backlash. It does not matter how many tests prove the validity of our point. People are often not allowed to chew tobacco in the office... no secondhand smoke there, it is simply a lost argument.

Yes, there will be exceptions. But, those exceptions also bring the ones who want to be contrary out. Maybe we will be allowed to be closer to the building than real smokers... maybe we could argue that being forced to be near smokers is bad for our health.

This is about to hit a critical mass in the US. There will be some types of rules. Big Tobacco will try to take control. Be prepared for the worst case scenario and be appreciative if it does not happen.... but don't be surprised if it does.


Side note: I can build a stealth vaporizer and mix that would allow me to vape almost anywhere unnoticed. I do something similar at soccer practice for my son.

The disadvantage of becoming more mainstream is that we are no longer easily ignored. Remember WHY we vape and focus on that. We don't vape to have the coolest mod, we don't vape to blow a mile long stream of vapor that blots out the sun. We vape because smoking was killing us.
 

Doc Diego

Full Member
Jul 3, 2013
33
30
51
Jackson, MI, USA
If I can't go several hours without a vape, maybe it is time to rethink vaping.


That's precisely why I vape. I'd gladly give up vaping if I thought I could pull it off; but the reality is that I'd be right back to a PAD. Straight up, we're inhaling stuff not normally found in the atmosphere so the obvious healthiest choice is to do neither. Reality is many of us can't, despite multiple desperate attempts to give up smoking. So I choose THR, which all the supposed studies seem to singularly ignore; my options seem to be smoke or vape, quitting altogether apparently isn't viable. I'd like to see the ANTZ compare the output of an analog vs an ecig in a GCMS and tell me with a straight face that my ecig is the wrong choice.

Vaping is considered tobacco use where I work, but I understand the policy of designated areas only. While I'm office, it is primarily a retail environment and customers wouldn't understand employees vaping and blowing clouds of vapor as professional even if they did understand ecigs.

Sent from my microwave oven.
 

Roncgizmo

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 14, 2013
149
83
Nj
As I sit outside writing this post on my lunch break, enjoying my delicious blackberry vape, I can't help but wonder why my employer has banned ecigs from their four office buildings, requiring vapers to go outside to the smokers' area.
As part of my position, I travel in between each building. I've gotten to know the smokers that inhabit said area pretty well and have discovered that most of them spend at least ten minutes every hour away from their desks getting their nic fix. More than a few of them have switched to vaping and are all upset that they have to go outside, away from their desks and work, to engage in their newfound habit (I count myself among them).
I think it's incredibly shortsighted of our employer to confine vapers to the smoking area. They missed an incredible opportunity to increase productivity just because vaping "looks like smoking."
I realize employers are well within their rights to set rules and that employees, should they continue to be employed there, should follow them. It just seems rather discriminatory to lump us all in together, smokers and vapers alike.
Is this commonplace in an office setting? Any experiences to the contrary?

You're in NY. They ban everything. Black plastic rifles are more dangerous then this same rifle with a wood stock on it.
You also came this close to having a 32oz soda banned. And you can also blame NJ for putting ecigs in the same category
as analogs. Cuomo and Bloomberg hate being one upped by NJ.
 

ClippinWings

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 12, 2011
1,641
1,889
The OC
I spose, a company can do anything they like. I would imagine if they allow vaping in work areas, someone is gonna have their feeling hurt. Analog smokers would want that same right.

And they'd have it... They could vape in work areas too.

Sent from my mobile, using Tapatalk... so ignore the typos. ;)
 

ut1205

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 9, 2013
518
633
Chattanooga, Tn, USA
Another company I worked for banned smoking anywhere in the building even the shop where odors were so foul you couldn't even smell the cig smoke but allowed chewing, dipping, and spitting anywhere in the building. We smokers complained but were told the decision had been made but their door was always open to our resignations.

Previous posters are correct. If you own the place you can make any rule you want especially when it comes to tobacco.
 

amp79423

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 16, 2013
275
233
Lubbock, TX, USA
I treat vaping much like I did smoking, won't do it in restaurants or other non smoking places that it would attract attention. That said, I have my own office and when I feel the need I shut the door and vape. I've also been known to take a stealth puff or two off my eroll from time to time and my guilty pleasure is blowing a big cloud at the no smoking sign in my building's elevator when I'm on it alone.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free
 

RosaJ

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 30, 2012
2,014
3,034
The Woodlands, TX, USA
I treat vaping much like I did smoking, won't do it in restaurants or other non smoking places that it would attract attention. That said, I have my own office and when I feel the need I shut the door and vape. I've also been known to take a stealth puff or two off my eroll from time to time and my guilty pleasure is blowing a big cloud at the no smoking sign in my building's elevator when I'm on it alone.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free

You know most elevators have cameras in them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread