BMontgomery - the whole bedtime process may take a while to break her of bad habits. You and Beth will have to be stronger will than she is.
She's figured out what works to stall bedtime. Stand your ground. There will be tears. Hopefully hers and not yours. Trust me, when it comes to bed time around here, I was ruthless. Include her in the discussion of how bedtime will work. If she's part of the discussion you can throw it back on her when she whines - but Livi, you agreed we'd only have 2 stories. (Offer 1 when doing the "plan" and see if she negotiates for another.)
We did story time in their beds. It got them where they needed to be. (in bed) and set the scene for quiet time.
Make a poster - (This is what we did)
bath (DH normally was in charge of baths)
pj's on (check)
brush teeth (check)
drink (check)
story (we had a 2 story limit - because we were putting 3 kids to bed at one point)
prayers (yep - they were simple - God Bless Mommy & Daddy, Grandma's & Grandpa's, Brothers, Friends & all God's creatures. And help me grow up happy, healthy strong and wise. Amen ) Seriously, that was their bedtime prayer word for word. It covered all the bases - so when they tried to extend it (and yes, she will and add the puppy next door and the baby bunnies under the deck...etc - covers the bases)
After prayers we were done. If they got out of bed, no Dora or dessert or snack or whatever the next day. whatever would traumatize them the most. It's the one time punishment wasn't immediate in our house hold. Normally if you broke a rule or did something wrong, punishment followed immediately because they had to be able to tie what they did wrong with the consequence.
It took a week or so for it to sink in that we meant it (with #1) We'd just keep walking him back to bed. Say goodnight and leave. I even threatened to put a baby gate on his door (we did with his youngest brother - the monkey was quiet! and sneaky!)
Bedtime was sacred. DH & I needed our time to wind down and talk etc.
She's figured out what works to stall bedtime. Stand your ground. There will be tears. Hopefully hers and not yours. Trust me, when it comes to bed time around here, I was ruthless. Include her in the discussion of how bedtime will work. If she's part of the discussion you can throw it back on her when she whines - but Livi, you agreed we'd only have 2 stories. (Offer 1 when doing the "plan" and see if she negotiates for another.)
We did story time in their beds. It got them where they needed to be. (in bed) and set the scene for quiet time.
Make a poster - (This is what we did)
bath (DH normally was in charge of baths)
pj's on (check)
brush teeth (check)
drink (check)
story (we had a 2 story limit - because we were putting 3 kids to bed at one point)
prayers (yep - they were simple - God Bless Mommy & Daddy, Grandma's & Grandpa's, Brothers, Friends & all God's creatures. And help me grow up happy, healthy strong and wise. Amen ) Seriously, that was their bedtime prayer word for word. It covered all the bases - so when they tried to extend it (and yes, she will and add the puppy next door and the baby bunnies under the deck...etc - covers the bases)
After prayers we were done. If they got out of bed, no Dora or dessert or snack or whatever the next day. whatever would traumatize them the most. It's the one time punishment wasn't immediate in our house hold. Normally if you broke a rule or did something wrong, punishment followed immediately because they had to be able to tie what they did wrong with the consequence.
It took a week or so for it to sink in that we meant it (with #1) We'd just keep walking him back to bed. Say goodnight and leave. I even threatened to put a baby gate on his door (we did with his youngest brother - the monkey was quiet! and sneaky!)
Bedtime was sacred. DH & I needed our time to wind down and talk etc.
Now, he'd rather get sent to the principal than sit in class. He's perfectly content to sit in the corner in the office and do nothing. 
Wow, I need to get out more. 