I feel very similar to you..I remember thinking to myself one day, "if they would just come up with a fake cigarette that was healthier I stop smoking"..and THAN...I saw it on TV, I was so excited!
Anyways, even if it is healthier, I still have that burdon of an addiction (an idol). I try to hope that GOD can see it as me trying to do better. (treat your body as a temple) but it's still probably not what he wants for us. (Niether is ice cream or french fries though)
Im so torn, but I've been vaping for 4 months and I havn't had an analog for 3 days now b/c Im really determined and positive Im done for good.. If for some reason vaping doesn't work out I will NEVER go back to smoking analogs again..
What God sees is what is in your heart. Remember, he is a merciful God and thank you Jesus, he is a God of grace.
If what is in your heart is to take really good care of his temple, he sees that you vaping instead of smoking is a step forward in the right direction. Always remember that by God's mercy and grace, we always move from Glory to Glory, forward and never backwards. Vaping for many of us here, is a step forward.
As far as vaping being an "idol", opinions can and will differ among the bretheren. I once thought the same thing but after really thinking about it, I came to a different conclusion. My take on it is that God said "You shall have no other Gods/Idols before me". The magic word here is the word
"Before".
Do you leave your Church in the middle of service to go outside and have a vape? Do you stop praying in the middle of your prayer time to have a vape? Do you not tithe or donate money to your church so that you can have money for your vaping habit? Do you put your e-cig and vaping "before" God? If you answered "NO" to the questions above, then it is in my opinion that your/our vaping habit does not fall into the "idol" category.
However, if you answered yes to any of the above questions, then in my opinion, I feel that it does fall into the "idol" category.
People will argue the point using other products that many of us are addicted to like for example: Coffee. Or how about in Church durring praise and worship you never sing along, you never raise your hands up onto the Lord, let alone applaud for God or even stand up. But yet, in a live rock concert or watching American Idol on TV, you sing along, you raise your hands and applaud. It is a valid argument.
What is important here is what is in your heart. Bible says "A man is what is in his heart".
God is always looking to see what is inside one's heart. If he is first in your heart and no other (or anything) is first, then I can say in faith that you have no other idols before God.
May God give you the strength to stay away from analogs. You need to pray for it.
Remember, God says "You have not because you ask not"
God Bless,
Max