I found a good e liquid tobacco & menthol
@Moon mountain an online company it's pretty good tobacco & menthol the best i've found so far.
In that case, then maybe you should stick with the seller & flavor. Never break what doesn't need fixing, at least until you find something better.
During my teen years or really over half of my life of analog consumption, preferred the Kool brand. Was the strongest menthol available at that time, yet had to stop. These began to made me cough bad & switching menthol analog brands didn't help.
I did try some menthol e-juices, a couple from Mt Baker, but weren't what I expected, one bottle tasted strong of pine needles, the other more like peppermint candy. Not what an analog would taste like for sure. Tried another from Vapor Beast, forgot the exact flavor, again tasted like pine needles, with some type of chemical in the background.
Contacted customer service for a refund & they told me they didn't do refunds, instead was advised to take the 60ml bottle, remove the cap/dripper in one & allow to stand in a dark, cool area for a week. I was thinking of words that I cant repeat here, but done what was asked anyway. While it did help take the chemical taste away, the pine needles were still there & strong.
Personally, I believe some of these suppliers buys these batches in lots & has their name in placed on the bottles, as Vapor Beast (at the time) operated out of Florida & the ejuice was made for them in China. That would be the end of my quest for Menthol. If I decide to try again, will get the extract & make my own. At some point in your vaping journey, you'll likely have the desire to make your own & Nicotine River has some of the best flavors in the US. Some of these were at one time sold by E.JUICES.COM, yet within the last year stopped selling DIY mixing flavors.
The other cool thing about DIY is that once stocked with supplies (flavoring, nic, VG & PG), can make a single 60ml bottle for a fraction of the price paid online anywhere.
My main piece of advice if taking that route is going easy on the flavoring at first. If too strong, will have to pour some into another bottle & top off with VG & maybe some PG. It's much easier to add a bit more flavor versus working a too strong batch out. Once I make mine, will shake well, allow to stand with cap on for 2 days, shake again & ready to vape. This is why when making a new flavor, still use my Kangertech SubTank Mini, or even a ProTank 2 or 3, will initially do a 30ml batch & tweak until I get it right.
As the old saying goes, if you want to get the job done right, do it yourself.
Cat