Is vaping really cheaper than smoking

Status
Not open for further replies.

Myk

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2009
4,889
10,658
IL, USA
This is interesting for me...I vaped an entire summer four years ago but wound up in the hospital also; it appears something in analogues other than the nic keeps my hyperthyroidism in check, and I became so hyper my heart rate was running away. This is why I fell off the wagon the first time...

Amazed about the money issue here...over TEN DOLLARS a pack here now in Mass!! I'd have a hard time spending what I spent on smokes for ecig stuff!!

I think that's a benefit of smoking I hadn't heard of before.

There's more to IBD than nicotine. When I first switched I was getting plenty of nicotine. After being diagnosed I worked my way up to 18mg, I could handle about 3 puffs a day of 18mg when I started.
It's hard to get accurate information because of ANTZ propaganda but I think smoking provides a protection for Ulcerative Colitis. That's the only reason I can come up with for people finding out they have it when they quit and some who are unresponsive to meds or nicotine get told to smoke and they go back like they were before.
 

Panth

Full Member
Oct 26, 2013
11
14
Phoenix
Like others here, my startup cost was high. My wife and I both started vaping about a month ago - we had both mate folks at our respective jobs who seemed enthralled with it so we figured we'd try it out. She dropped about $100 on Ego startup kits and juice from a local B&M. (Which I now see could be had online for about 1/3 of that.) A battery died, got replaced, that one died, got replaced, that one broke, got replaced.

Frustrated, she went out and bought us a pair of iTaste vv's, which we've used reliably since then, for another $80 or so. Couple extra tanks added on, another $20ish.

So that was over $200 by about day 4 of our vaping just in hardware.

Oh, and for the first 2 weeks . .no, 3, we had constant problems that we couldn't figure out with clogging/spurting/not working . . .seemed like a TON of maintenance and we were going through new heads like twice a day each. This was actually what caused me to go online to see what was up and I found this place . . .and that it was probably a juice causing the problems. This Cappucino is super dark. Stopped using it and haven't had to replace a head since. So that was another $30-40 blown in coil heads and juice we can't use (plus a lot of stress and headaches constantly dismantling, cleaning, and replacing stuff every 30 mins or so.)

So for awhile there, we were questioning the economic validity of vaping ourselves. Even after we got sorted with the vv's, a $10 pack of heads + juice a day seemed quite a bit.

BUT, from the second we started with our spendier-than-expected capital outlay, and even through all the equipment problems, user error, frustrations, headaches, and everything else . . .neither of us has had an actual smoke. We both really really enjoyed vaping from the second we started, even through the problems, so I was determined to make this work as simply as possible.

Now that I know there are so many online resources for information, hardware, juice, etc., I can see this costing us maybe $40-50/week if that. It's like starting anything new; you need to find your groove, supplies that work for *you* and you usually end up with stuff you didn't really need in the process. Still experimenting with juices - I've found about 3 really solid ones I like from local shops but I see Mt Baker is waaay cheaper and has solid reviews so we'll be trying some of their stuff shortly. That would shave even more off the cost. I've found the kind of tank I like, so experimenting with those shouldn't be necessary.

We smoked a lot. In the neighborhood of 5 packs a day between us for 20 years. At gas station rates where we were in WA that would have been $40+/DAY! Now, we had always bought cheap at reservations so we didn't pay that much, and for the last 5 years or so had been making our own at home, but still that was about $30 for a bag of tobacco and 3 cartons of tubes a couple times a week. So yeah, $60/week was a ton cheaper than $280, and yeah, now that we're set up with the initial outlay vaping will be even cheaper still by a small margin, moreso if we start using cheaper juices (or eventually DIYing that too.)

But there's no tobacco and tubes laying all over. No ashtrays. No butts. No packs, boxes, or wrappers. No smell. No stained fingers or teeth or walls. No burnholes in clothes. You know . .I never really realized just how much of a mess smoking makes until we quit lol.

Oh, and there's the whole thing where I haven't coughed in a month, my cold lasted 2 days instead of 2 weeks, and we're not killing ourselves. So even if we weren't saving money over our cheapo DIY smokes, we'd still keep on it.


tl;dr: Yeah, vaping is cheaper even compared to homemade smokes. "Collecting" is another matter entirely and will cost whatever you want to spend.
 

coco.bun

Full Member
Verified Member
Considering a pack of cigarettes are nearing, if not already, $10, once you buy the hardware the difference in running cost is probably minimal... aside of the health issue (that seem to be unproven for long term effects), vaping also benefits from convinience too (like being able to just flick the button and vape and not have to worry about shifting gears when driving, putting down the cigarette for a second and worry about burning something, etc).
 

CABBA

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 28, 2013
377
383
Canada
I smoked for 35 years but it never was a hobby for me. I changed cigarette brands a couple of times but that did not involve an increase in smoking cost. I never bought a humidor, I never grew and cured my own tobacco. I never graduated to premium cigars. I never rolled my own. I never spent more money than I needed to maintain my cigarette habit for those 35 years. All I wanted to was to keep smoking and buying those cartons at the gas station every week.

So, if smoking for 35 years was not a hobby, why should vaping be a hobby?

The fact is I already have several hobbies. Boating and restoration of classic wooden boats is my most expensive hobby. I did that that when I was smoking and do it now that I'm vaping, too. The only difference is that I have more money available for the boating hobby now then when I smoked.

There is a huge amount of marketing power expended to keep people keep buying the latest and shiniest PVs with the coolest electronics and the most fashionable flavors. I really don't care about that. This is my hobby and yes, it's a DIY hobby...

MDuck6acrop.jpg

hob·by
ˈhäbē
noun
1. an activity done regularly in one's leisure time for pleasure.
"her hobbies are reading and gardening"
synonyms: pastime, leisure activity, leisure pursuit; More

So yes some people do consider vaping a hobby. If your hobby is taking pictures of old boats that's fine. To each their own.
 

Vicshalls

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 3, 2013
1,828
3,306
Houston, TX
Mt biggest deal now is liquid. I have enough I am sure but only like 2 I like for all the time. I just want to be able to let it steep so it will be even better. Still going through Vapors tounge. Hope one day it will be gone for good and these liquids I have might be better once that happenes. I am finding that this is turning into a hobby which is good and bad. I want a vv mod but at the same time I would rather just spend the money and get a provari and not waist money on others that may not last. Then I end up spending more money in the long run. Thing is right now I don't have the money for one. So really not sure how much more expensive this will become. Lol
 

Saintwho

Full Member
Nov 1, 2013
5
2
San Diego
Been vaping for about 5 or 6 months, gone through a few of the ego's... I always break them... among other problems with the cheap tanks and what not. Started smoking for a month because of the hassle I was having... but I really wanted to quit smoking so there is that. I broke down... kind of and bought an Itaste SVD, found a juice I like(dry blend) and just bought 120ml of it. I used to buy the 30ml bottles they would last me about a week and a half-2 weeks. 3 egos(40$) accessories(50$), 100 bucks for the SVD set, 40 bucks for the juice and got the SVD 2 months ago. Hadn't bought a pack of smokes since, but 5 bucks a day X 150days = 750 bucks. With all my egos and everything I am still very far in the "ahead" column.
 

Daryl Glen

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 23, 2013
326
245
Titusville, FL, USA
www.youtube.com
My wife and I both smoked, but quit almost two years ago. In looking over our budget from the past year, we spent $1,100 on vaping gear/juice, etc.
If we would have both still been smoking, we normally spent about $4,400 on smoking. On top of that, she got a discounted rate on cartons from where she works....so if we would have paid retail on them, it would have been well past $5k a year for the both of us.
I cringe to think about it now....can't believe I was so blind!
 

toddrhodes

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 15, 2012
592
632
45
United States
Short term costs? For me it's a wash but that's because I've been buying new stuff to try and don't have any access to sell my old stuff yet :) But, if you look at the long term costs and factor in potential healthcare costs you may save as a result of going away from analog cigarettes? I feel like vaping will come out *considerably* cheaper in the end.
 

joePec

Full Member
Supporting Member
Right on! yeah... if I bust out the scientific calculator, I'm probably not that far ahead strictly financially speaking... However:
1. I've got a fun hobby I enjoy that isn't going to kill me.
2. I've gifted both new and handmedown equipment to people I care about and am somewhat responsible for 5 people quitting analogs
3. If you're going to be the "shiny new stuff" ....., vaping equipment really is a bargain! I mean... it's not like blowing 3 grand on stereo equipment!
4. VERY IMPORTANT - People here on ECF are freaking NICE and HELPFUL and INFORMATIVE and never condecending to newbies!

Let's face it - buying cigs was never FUN. It was necessary and mundane and predictable. Vaping (even when you buy some new juice that sounded great... but tasted like you were smoking grandmas underwear drawer..) is fun! It's fun to shop for/order/try out/rebuild things...
I have to say, I wasted a lot of money stumbling my way thru vaping before I was led to this site. I had tried cig-like ecigs previously and just ditched them due to the unpredictability of the quality. My buddy gifted me a box of cast-off equipment and a handful of juices.. and even after being cig-FREE for a year, I still use one of the flavors he initially gave me. I DIY my juice and it costs me about $3.50 for 30ml - not bad at all. Now that I've narrowed down to VV eGo 1300 mah bats and a Zmax for home with Kanger Evods and a Pro Tank 2 for the Zmax, I'm pretty well happy with my shiny stuff... Except what the HELL is that cool ... PV that looks like a freaking nickel plated pistol and comes in a freaking case???? LOL that's kind of bad ....
Oh, and I've gotten two people off smokes with handmedown equipment.... So I feel really good about that and consider that as money saved in a virtual way. I've given my mom 2 egos, an evod, c4s, and my cigalike set, some juice and lots of cartos for cigalike. Given a 650 batt to a coworker who had only one since I had mods and other egos, and currently my last 3 egos are out on loan to another coworker.
I will probably always have an ego that never gets used hanging around in case of emergency or someone needing to borrow or try it out. Good karma!
 

swim

Full Member
Verified Member
Nov 3, 2013
43
9
The Blue Planet
Right on! yeah... if I bust out the scientific calculator, I'm probably not that far ahead strictly financially speaking... However:
1. I've got a fun hobby I enjoy that isn't going to kill me.
2. I've gifted both new and handmedown equipment to people I care about and am somewhat responsible for 5 people quitting analogs
3. If you're going to be the "shiny new stuff" ....., vaping equipment really is a bargain! I mean... it's not like blowing 3 grand on stereo equipment! 4. VERY IMPORTANT - People here on ECF are freaking NICE and HELPFUL and INFORMATIVE and never condecending to newbies!

Let's face it - buying cigs was never FUN. It was necessary and mundane and predictable. Vaping (even when you buy some new juice that sounded great... but tasted like you were smoking grandmas underwear drawer..) is fun! It's fun to shop for/order/try out/rebuild things... I have to say, I wasted a lot of money stumbling my way thru vaping before I was led to this site. I had tried cig-like ecigs previously and just ditched them due to the unpredictability of the quality. My buddy gifted me a box of cast-off equipment and a handful of juices.. and even after being cig-FREE for a year, I still use one of the flavors he initially gave me. I DIY my juice and it costs me about $3.50 for 30ml - not bad at all. Now that I've narrowed down to VV eGo 1300 mah bats and a Zmax for home with Kanger Evods and a Pro Tank 2 for the Zmax, I'm pretty well happy with my shiny stuff... Except what the HELL is that cool ... PV that looks like a freaking nickel plated pistol and comes in a freaking case???? LOL that's kind of bad ....
fully agree with you :) vaping is alot of fun even when your smoking grandmas underwear drawer :vapor:
 

devauto

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 13, 2013
1,373
774
NoVA
I stopped smoking for obvious health risks and began vaping hoping it would be a safe cheaper alternative to smoking and quickly realized its not at least in my case, is the same true for you guys and gals?

It wasn't in the beginning, with buying all the starter kits, upgrades, mods, supplies, etc., but it is in the long run. It took me about 3 months to equalize with smoking costs, and now I'm ahead of the game, and saving quite a bit. I am a pretty thrifty shopper though, so YMMV!
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
as you can see in my signature i have not smoked 4880 analogs or 244 packs since i the day i got my e-cig. in my area analogs (Camel's) are about $7.50 per pack some areas in the city might charge up to $9.00 per pack of Camels. but lets just say 244 packs at $7.50 each comes out at $1830. i have looked at all my orders from sites i use the most. there might be a thing or two i forgot about but i have spent about $900 on e-cigs stuff. in about a year and half. and i did buy lots of my friends stuff as well because they don't have a credit card or it was a gift. i DIY my juice and rebuild my own coils. 15 ml of juice cost me about $4 including the child proof dropper bottle. and coils cost under 0.50 to make.. so yes i do save a bit of money.. even though i gave stuff away. making your own juice is awesome! always the right flavor and strength. and when you build your own coils your devices hit like a dream. but more importantly its hard to put a price on your health. we know smoking analogs is really bad for you, e-cigs are probably a lot better but we cant say they are 100% risk free, because we just don't have long term data yet.

hi happy dave,
are you in minnesota or sconny?(sconny=wisconson)
thats identical to my price break down.

snows coming regards,
mike
 

NickSteel

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 4, 2012
410
334
Napa, California
I'm probably not the usual vaper. It will be a year for us in a couple weeks. I use a MVP. Prorated over a year, the MVP/Protank should cost less than $5.00/mo. I'm satisfied with Fasttech liquid, so 50ml costs about $4.00 x 1.5 or $6.00 per month. So, about $11.00 per month. I only vape to avoid smoking. Hard to be cheaper than that!

Between my wife, a niece and I, the savings have been obviously significant.
:toast:
 
Last edited:

VelezCaroco

Full Member
Sep 26, 2013
9
2
Portugal
Problem is to find the right gear and the right juice until then you will spend a lot more on vaping then on cigarettes.

When you get there vaping can be so cheap that it will seem almost that you are vaping for free as long as you:

1. Buy only what you need.
2. DYI your liquid
3. Rebuild your coils and wicks

If you are not into rebuilding or DYI it can still be a lot cheaper then smoking and let's not forget a lot healthier also.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread