After trying a couple of tobacco juices when I first switched from gas station ecigs, I found them to taste like chewing on unburned tobacco.
Lucky enough I found unflavored nic base right after that and have never looked back. It is an amazing vape. I WAS one of those looking for as close to a cig as possible. This is it.
I get it in 24 mg 70% VG or higher. I recently reduced to 12 mg by doubling it with VG.
Not to mention the stuff is almost free - like $45 a LITER

.
But even if it cost as much as the most expensive juice, it would still be my AD, ED and night vape.
I have heard tell of people saying it tasted like pepper or something or sweet? If you tried it and thought it tasted like pepper or was sweet, you probably got it from somewhere I don't know and / or got it in high PG content.
I have only vaped Wizard Labs. But I do have two unopened liters from My Freedom Smokes in the freezer too