It would be easier for you to try the njoy than for me to pik & choose one of the companies you listed, then if you think its not good as -- (you will think its good I hope

) -- I would also bet the proprietary njoy recipe is a net but it doesn't clog my atomizers-- one positive I'm liking about it. If you think I still need to, which I will in the future purchase the extracts anyway(thanks for heads up) if you think I need to purchase because njoy subpar = dang awesome...
I make my own well aged nets in pg.. I have really well seasoned pipes that I used my fav house mix in and one for capt black days.. I used the tamper and made a pile put that in vials of pg and let it steep... They are fantastic pipe nets but the NJOY is a cigar dunhillish cuban flavor and it is amazing IMO..
So not only will I be comparing NJOY, I will be comparing my own nets to your posted nets. woot... My diy net tobacco extracts are better than NJOY, I am not a cigar fan, only on the golf course, but in the cigar category its spectacular..
One thing I have tooooo much e juice now, just made a huge 1000ml +numerous flavors order from the wizard/nude already had over 500ml, so gimme a few months time I won't forget.. I wish I would have thought about buying nets from recommendation last week but always disappointed in the gunking regardless of flavor.. I use ss mesh, allergic to cotton wicking, so ya it clogs my ss mesh porosity and cakes with ashtray flavor, I have to change out a good non shorting wick and that is horrendous lol..
No deal but cutting the deck to play... Report back in a few, maybe sooner than later, very tempting..
BTW quite a few of us diy'ers have sought the njoy recipe clone to no avail, charged from flavoring of the njoy kings, was pleasantly surprised they finally made a juice and was pleased it is better than the disposable..