Well, I can say for sure now, I just filled a tank with the Organic from GeJ:
Vendor: GoodeJuice
Juice: Organic Tobacco #1
Thoughts: I don't like this one *quite* as much as I like vaperite's organic NET, in terms of flavor, but the "cleanness" of this juice makes up for that. It had a somewhat strong perfume quality at first, kind or like vaperite's tuscany, but that seems to have faded somewhat. The flavor is more complex, and a little "dirtier" than VR's organic but is also less subtle. TH is strong, but not too harsh, though definitely harsher than the VR organic. It probably tastes and feels the most like an actual cigarette of any juice I've yet tried. Though it does have that perfume quality, and I rarely liked that in an actual cigarette. If the perfuminess fades more, I think it will leave a nice earthy quality that may make me like it even more.
After just finishing (and heartily enjoying) my first tank-full, the GeJ Perique is probably my favorite for the moment.
Both the organic #1 and the perique from GeJ have a strong "top note" that the vaperite juices lack, which I do kind of like, especially the sour note of the Perique. It's more bitter/earthy in the organic. The separate flavors definitely merge a lot (and the top note vanishes) about half way through the tank. I'm thinking that the GeJ liquids are fresher than vaperites. Todd has always sent me juices that were at least a couple weeks old (he puts the creation dates on the bottles) so I'll bet that the GeJ liquids will benefit more from steeping.
So I'd say that vaperite and GeJ are definitely in the same league as far as their pure-tobacco liquids go. They both have excellent tobacco flavor, and nothing else.
I can totally concur that the GeJ liquids are much gentler on wicks and coils, and do not discolor as much from being heated as vaperite's juices do. At first I thought they were thinner, but I was wrong, they're about the same thickness, but the GeJ liquids do seem to wick better, as I can vape at a higher voltage without drying out the wick.
I'm looking forward to trying a few more from GeJ. Though more than that I'm looking forward to my soon-to-be-placed order from HHV.