Totally agree, but I also think it has gone past the point of no return... To go through this whole thread and extract all of the reviews (formal or informal) would be a monumental task. The best solution so far is for people to describe what they are looking for, and then recommendations will come forth. The tighter the description, the smaller the list will be, hehe. I think Thucydides asked a little while back for some recommendations and he got a short list of some possible options to try. Things like juices you have tried and liked, as well as descriptions of what you like, for instance sweet vs. cigar or flavored vs. unflavored, etc... Are great starting points.
Fair enough. I am looking for a pipe tobacco that has a wonderful, pipe smell/flavor. I bought some Perique from GeJ and really liked it. It had a nice sweet taste on the exhale and has me really excited to try other rich pipe tobaccos.
I have tried a carolina tobacco from MyFreedomSmokes and it was completely unvapeable. I threw out the cartomizer I used, because nothing could get rid of the ashtray taste.
I haven't tried any other vendors for pipe NETs because I got lost somewhere around post 2000 and just can't keep up. (Sorry

). I bought the Perique as a random purchase along with some other GeJ flavors I like to have around ( NET Menthol eJuice, Emerald Square Menthol). I should have bought the big bottle because it's something I really like.
When I think of a pipe tobacco I would like, it would be rich, slightly sweet and have a pretty good taste. The GeJ perique may be a little lightish on flavor... but it's very good. I do 15-20 minute sessions with my HH.357 and the Perique when I tire of sweeter, flavors.
So any reviews or recommendations for something that would be pipe-like and nicely filtered like GeJ would be very much appreciated.