Puzzles, Games, Hobbies can lower Nicotine Cravings

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kemosabe

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Sep 21, 2011
6,147
7,632
Roe Dylin

DrMA

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 26, 2013
2,989
9,887
Seattle area
In essence, it seems to me a bunch of bored academics got together and wasted a bunch of research money setting up a ridiculously complicated experiment to demonstrate that adults like co-operative computer games. Instead they could've just asked any MMORPG manufacturer about their user demographic and saved a bunch of time and money. Hear that Harkin? Adults like video games too, just like they like flavors.

Otherwise, the result that rewarding activities, such as spending time with loved ones or playing challenging computer games can alleviate nicotine withdrawal symptoms sounds plausible, but it is not a new idea. In fact, the authors themselves do a decent job reviewing similar research in the introduction. I might find use for this publication if I ever need to make a science-based argument to support my need to purchase a new hobby item or video game :p

In the final analysis, though, to suggest that a video game could be an effective replacement for smoking is nothing more than ivory tower ridiculousness; right up there with the pretense that NRT works or that "a substantial number of [smokers quit] without clinical assistance," as the authors claim. Why would any of us play video games to replace smoking, when we can now vape to replace smoking, while playing video games :D?
 

csardaz

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
May 29, 2014
169
147
Pennsylvania
The headlines seem misleading. The key thing was the 'self-expanding' ( self expression ) in a one-on-one cooperation activity with an already very familiar partner. Interesting, but very specific. Solo puzzles? Cooperation with larger groups? With people you don't know as well? I, for one smoked more than usual during those activities and during competitive games vs wife and girlfriends. Hard to remember how much I may have smoked during cooperation in such a limited context.
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
In essence, it seems to me a bunch of bored academics got together and wasted a bunch of research money setting up a ridiculously complicated experiment to demonstrate that adults like co-operative computer games. Instead they could've just asked any MMORPG manufacturer about their user demographic and saved a bunch of time and money. Hear that Harkin? Adults like video games too, just like they like flavors.

Otherwise, the result that rewarding activities, such as spending time with loved ones or playing challenging computer games can alleviate nicotine withdrawal symptoms sounds plausible, but it is not a new idea. In fact, the authors themselves do a decent job reviewing similar research in the introduction. I might find use for this publication if I ever need to make a science-based argument to support my need to purchase a new hobby item or video game :p

In the final analysis, though, to suggest that a video game could be an effective replacement for smoking is nothing more than ivory tower ridiculousness; right up there with the pretense that NRT works or that "a substantial number of [smokers quit] without clinical assistance," as the authors claim. Why would any of us play video games to replace smoking, when we can now vape to replace smoking, while playing video games :D?

Thanks for the laughs!

Or they could have read some Sherlock Holmes while vaping an e-pipe :facepalm: :laugh:
 

sonicdsl

Wandering life's highway
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 11, 2011
17,744
19,245
In essence, it seems to me a bunch of bored academics got together and wasted a bunch of research money setting up a ridiculously complicated experiment to demonstrate that adults like co-operative computer games. Instead they could've just asked any MMORPG manufacturer about their user demographic and saved a bunch of time and money. Hear that Harkin? Adults like video games too, just like they like flavors.

Otherwise, the result that rewarding activities, such as spending time with loved ones or playing challenging computer games can alleviate nicotine withdrawal symptoms sounds plausible, but it is not a new idea. In fact, the authors themselves do a decent job reviewing similar research in the introduction. I might find use for this publication if I ever need to make a science-based argument to support my need to purchase a new hobby item or video game :p

In the final analysis, though, to suggest that a video game could be an effective replacement for smoking is nothing more than ivory tower ridiculousness; right up there with the pretense that NRT works or that "a substantial number of [smokers quit] without clinical assistance," as the authors claim. Why would any of us play video games to replace smoking, when we can now vape to replace smoking, while playing video games :D?

That (Bolded) is what I do now! :D

The headlines seem misleading. The key thing was the 'self-expanding' ( self expression ) in a one-on-one cooperation activity with an already very familiar partner. Interesting, but very specific. Solo puzzles? Cooperation with larger groups? With people you don't know as well? I, for one smoked more than usual during those activities and during competitive games vs wife and girlfriends. Hard to remember how much I may have smoked during cooperation in such a limited context.

Exactly my experience (bolded)!
 

dragonpuff

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
In essence, it seems to me a bunch of bored academics got together and wasted a bunch of research money setting up a ridiculously complicated experiment to demonstrate that adults like co-operative computer games. Instead they could've just asked any MMORPG manufacturer about their user demographic and saved a bunch of time and money. Hear that Harkin? Adults like video games too, just like they like flavors.

:lol: :lol: :lol:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread