Any decent sub for Madagascar Vanilla?
Yes, there are several to choose from.
Ok so, you don't have SSA Madagascar Vanilla.
Do you have FA Madagascar (Vanilla Classic)? If you do that would be a perfect sub at 1.5% - 2%. It's not as strong as the SSA hence the higher %'s.
The FA and SSA are very different tasting Madagascar vanilla flavors from each other. The FA is more of a generic vanilla. The SSA is a truer Madagascar vanilla.
I'm not at home so I can't look at all my vanilla's. But...
From memory (and help from the web

) I have the following vanillas:
VTA Vanilla Classic 1% would work nicely.
INW Shisha Vanilla 1% is a brighter vanilla but would work.
SSA Borneo Vanilla 1% would bring in a very bright vanilla note.
FA Vanilla Tahity 1% is a very bright vanilla and would bring in both a light cherry note and a slight almond note.
Holy Vanilla v1 or v2 1% would make it bright.
FW French Vanilla 1% would stand out and change the profile.
FLV Vanilla Bean 0.75% might work.
FA Bourbon Vanilla 1% would add a darker more earthy tasting vanilla.
Same with TPA/TFA Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla (it is a very different tasting vanilla compared to FA Bourbon Vanilla).
INW Vanilla Bourbon TDM would be very earthy.
INW Vanilla Classic TDM 1% might work (emphasis on might).
The last two INW vanillas are an acquired taste and tricky to mix with!
One more…
INW Vanilla Cream 1% would work and add a little more creaminess.
Hope that helps.
