The "200w" questionare!

Status
Not open for further replies.

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,705
TN
The Xtar VC line and Efest LUC Line have digital displays and display battery charge level in numbers, ie 3.6v or 4.2v just like the Nitecore D2 and D4 models do.

/Edit
click the link in my Signature, it links to a blog post I have done breaking down a lot of the batteries for different wattage applications as well as chargers, and other reputable, authorized battery retailers that sell batteries and chargers, Illumn being one of the 5 I recommend.
Xtar VP line also has those options.

Tapatyped
 

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,705
TN
So here's the purchase:

-Koopor Plus
-Smok TFV4 Mini
- 2x Samsung 25r
- Xtar VC2
- Xtar adapter (>.>)

I guess as a final question, does the VC2 marry batteries correctly and show battery voltage level well enough to keep an eye on the marrying? It is literally all I could afford in the XTAR range. Any reason I should cancel?
Vp2 comes with the adapter.

Dunno if that makes it cheaper than the vc2 plus adapter or not.

Tapatyped
 

Submarine123

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 17, 2015
150
84
40
So I think this question will help me a lot:

So from doing the math, if I were to buy the Smok 0.16ohm Octuple Fused Clapton Coil, it is very reasonable that it would truly take all of the recommended 150w to power all that. The 4-Coil as it is takes about 80-100w in most folks opinion.

0.16ohm, 150w, simply a lot of wire to heat. That's 30.62 amps.

Now, when batteries are dualed, do the 20a ratings combine to make a pure 40a? If so, seems fine.

BUT what happens as the battery looses charge? Do the amps stay as capable if the battery is low?
 

gpjoe

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 30, 2013
2,595
4,950
Up North
No, the current is not combined in a series mod - the amount of current drawn is the same through both batteries. When the batteries are in parallel half of the current flows through each - so the max safe current is effectively doubled.

In a series box, for example, lets say the batteries are 4 volts each for a total of 8 volts. With a load of 1 ohm, the same 8 amps flows through both batteries.

In a parallel box the voltage would be 4 volts. The same 1 ohm load would draw 4 amps - with each battery providing 2 amps.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DaveP

Submarine123

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 17, 2015
150
84
40
So wait, what is the Koopor Plus then, parallel or series? Will I be running it safe?

I'm really worried sick about this as I just bought a couple 20a 25r's after dancing around on this thread for days and I'm going to be a little tee'd if I find out I can't run safely (or even at all) higher than 60-80w on this mod with the particular coils Smok make (most are indeed like 0.16-0.3ohm). I didn't buy this thing to vape on a Kanger Subtank with it.

-_-
 

Boden

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Sep 7, 2012
5,516
28,164
Lexington KY
So wait, what is the Koopor Plus then, parallel or series? Will I be running it safe?

I'm really worried sick about this as I just bought a couple 20a 25r's after dancing around on this thread for days and I'm going to be a little tee'd if I find out I can't run safely (or even at all) higher than 60-80w on this mod with the particular coils Smok make (most are indeed like 0.16-0.3ohm). I didn't buy this thing to vape on a Kanger Subtank with it.

-_-
Here is what you need to know to figure it out for yourself.

V x A = W or W / V = A

Example: A brand new 20A battery at a cutoff voltage of 3.2V can give: 3.2V x 20A = 64W

Two in series would be 6.4V x 20A = 128W
Two in parallel would be 3.2V x 40A = 128W

You know the CDR of your batteries.
All you need to do is find the cutoff voltage of the mod and insert it into the above equation.

Reminder: Every cycle takes a bit of life out of the battery, over ~150 cycles a 25R becomes a 10A battery so replace your batteries as necessary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MMW

suprtrkr

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 22, 2014
10,410
15,048
Cowtown, USA. Where the West begins.
So as a Christmas gift to myself, I'm upgrading my sad, old Kanger GayBOX, Sub(par)Tank Na-"NO", EFART battery, Chinese Surprise battery, and most likely my TurtleFire 2-bay charger.

Puns.

Anyway, I have a ton of questions as I am adamant about looking into the research and staying safe. I've already looked at all the blogs and threads you can find on here but still, there's nothing like good old final questions.

MOD:

It's a choice between the Koopor Plus and Wismec 200RX.

Because they're each like $40 roughly if you know where to look.

Question:

Say I used batteries of the exact same caliber for both mods, two in the Koopor and three in the RX200, would the battery life in the RX200 be extended enough to make a huge difference? Any thoughts?

MOD SAFETY:

Let's face it, the RX200 has a blow-up story, and several reports of the LCD getting very hot at around 120w+, and what some builders say is weak wiring. God knows, as this is really one of the first cheap, mass produced triple battery mods.

Question:

Is it really safe? Hoping to hear from the real Mr. Gadgets on this one.

MOD FEATURES:

Both mods are said to have safety features galore, but so do guns.

Question:

Which mod between the two specifically has the best safety features? Personally, I trust SMOK a little more, as not only has one of the Wismecs blown up, but the Wismec chip is by Joyetech, in which their mods are causing their SubOhm tanks to shoot out fire left and right appearantly, because of some sort of mystery chip issue.

BUT I need thoughts.

BATTERIES:

So I've gathered that simply put, ordering a Sony VCT5 from Illumination may just be the absolute only authentic 18650 battery on the planet and that everything else is a sheer gamble. Who knows but I can't find much else in terms of answers.

Question:

For both mods, which I'll be running the TFV4 Mini at 80-140w (I have no doubt the wattage will be going high with that new Octuple Fused Clapton Coil), are the VTC5's the best bet? Anything else?

BATTERY SAFETY:

So both mods do 200w, which is indeed puzzling as really, 2 batteries probably wouldn't manage to pack over 50amps best-case scenario, and 3... 75 at best?

Question:

For those that REALLY know batteries like an expert, is it really even safe to run 200w's on 3 batteries? Much less 2? How in the world does the Koopor do it? 100w per battery... my EFEST doesn't run anything over 35w most of the time. What gives?

CHARGER:

I can get a good deal on a Nitecore D4.

Question:

I've heard that the NiteCore D4 charges different bays based on what mood it's in, basically. Since marrying the batteries is key, wouldn't this divorce them?

Any chargers that are better suited and/or required?

TANK:

TFV4 Mini.

Question:

Has anyone had any problems AT ALL with this version of the tank spitting, leaking, or getting scalding and/or o-rings melting?

Thanks for bearing with these questions! I think this will help a ton of folks stepping into this 200w arena!
I have no experience with either mod, so I can't help you choose. I participate in another thread where they love the Wismec part and have posted no problems. They use some tall watts, too.

If you will order from Orbtronic, Illumn or RTDVapor, you will get authentic batteries, no matter what kind you buy. I probably would not select VTC5s for either mod. It's a solid 20 amp battery, but so are others, and they have better mAh capacity. The Samsung 25Rs or the LG HE2s or HE4s are all 20 amp batteries with 2500 mAh. The LG HG2 is 20 amp, 3000mAh for better battery life, as is the AW IMR 3000 mAh part. For the thickest safety margin with decent life, try the Sony VTC4s. The VTC4 is also a 20 amp battery (2100 mAh) but will tolerate 30a without dangerous overheating. They are all I use. There are a couple native 30 amp batteries, but the Sony VTC3 is near impossible to get, and the LG HB6 has miserable life at 1100 mAh. They guys (and gals) in my thread using the RL200s love the 3000 mAh LG HG2s, and report no problems.

It's safe enough to run the machine at 200 watts with 20 amp batteries (although I prefer the VTC4s for better safety). Essentially, the 200 watts is advertising hype. Yeah, they hit 200 watts, but it doesn't do it as continuous duty. The mods pulse the power to keep within the batteries' capability. They are not true 200 watt RMS continuous machines.

I use an I4 charger, and it will charge two batteries at 750mah but, if you put in a third, it charges all 3 at 375 mAh. It does reduce charge by individual bay for the last 10% or so of charge. The closer it gets to 4.2 volts, the slower it charges. I don't think that would divorce batteries.

I have no experience with that tank. But if you can build coils and want one that will take anything the RL200 will throw, take a look at the Indulgence MT.
 

Submarine123

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 17, 2015
150
84
40
Got the two batteries and Xstar charger in.

The two 25r batteries from illumin are sort of badly wrapped - the wrap is almost coming into contact with the flattop, both are very crooked.

A question about both.

The VC2 instructions say that when charge is absolutely complete, the screen blinks every 10 seconds. Mine doesn't do that, it just says "full" by charge. The instructions say this too, but word it as though it's still touching up on the battery until the screen truly blinks. Any idea?

And with the two new batteries, am I supposed to charge them, check them on the charger for a second to be safe, or use completely as is?
 

suprtrkr

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 22, 2014
10,410
15,048
Cowtown, USA. Where the West begins.
Got the two batteries and Xstar charger in.

The two 25r batteries from illumin are sort of badly wrapped - the wrap is almost coming into contact with the flattop, both are very crooked.

A question about both.

The VC2 instructions say that when charge is absolutely complete, the screen blinks every 10 seconds. Mine doesn't do that, it just says "full" by charge. The instructions say this too, but word it as though it's still touching up on the battery until the screen truly blinks. Any idea?

And with the two new batteries, am I supposed to charge them, check them on the charger for a second to be safe, or use completely as is?
I am surprised to hear you say the batteries are badly wrapped. Both of them? It seems odd. I've never seen one not wrapped right, and Illumn is a solid vendor. Can you post a pic? I don't actually know about the screen blinking when the charge is absolutely full, and I can't check; my Xtar is at my gal's house for use over there. Here I have a nitecore part. If memory serves-- I have a VC4-- my screen never blinked about full charge. Rather, the VC4 has an LED above the battery slot which changes colors at full charge. The only thing I can suggest is look at the screen for the charging current. It is supposed to shut off once the battery is full, so it ought to say full and current should be zero. Finally, new batteries should always be brought to full charge before use.
 

Submarine123

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 17, 2015
150
84
40
Well, its the VC2 and it only has what I guess is a guage for what amps are going into the charger (it's always at 5amps even with no batteries) and a guage per battery to say what the voltage of the battery. When the battery gets to 4.2 it stays at 4.2 for awhile (still charging as the Mah's keep counting and then it finally blinks "full"). I just hope it isnt overcharging.
 
Buy Now - Pegasus Vapor Academy

I think I'm going to give these guys a shot. The reviewer in the video above seemed to test all these out and it seems like a company that's super honest and actually admit every single thing exactly as it seems to be, simply re-wrapping the way it should be done (why can't EFEST just do this!?!?)

Only question is for these mods, is what "Type" of battery to get. There's one rated for 100w-150w, one for around 150w-200w, and one even down in the 70w range.

When it comes to tanks like the TFV4, the coils range from needing 30w all the way to 160w. Will the more powerful types fire low watts just as safely? What in the world do I get?

And on the Koopor, there's what seems to be a delay (seems severe) and reports that the fire-up setting is insane, that even at the lowest setting it will blast a coil at 100w's or higher no matter what for the first bit - that'd ruin a coil for sure but I don't know if I'm understanding that right.

Oh and about the charger again it seems with the NiteCore that every other bay charges at a different rate? Any info on that and if it hurts anything?


NiteCore charger full review. Does not seem to hurt anything that they are not all charged simultaneously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: inspects

Caterpiller

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 3, 2015
722
901
Malaysia
....

Reminder: Every cycle takes a bit of life out of the battery, over ~150 cycles a 25R becomes a 10A battery so replace your batteries as necessary .

I've now got 12 HE4's, and while I try to keep them as matched pairs, it is becoming harder to remember which pairs are older then others.

Is there a way to test for the CDR amp drop as they age?
 

suprtrkr

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 22, 2014
10,410
15,048
Cowtown, USA. Where the West begins.
Well, its the VC2 and it only has what I guess is a guage for what amps are going into the charger (it's always at 5amps even with no batteries) and a guage per battery to say what the voltage of the battery. When the battery gets to 4.2 it stays at 4.2 for awhile (still charging as the Mah's keep counting and then it finally blinks "full"). I just hope it isnt overcharging.
Almost certainly not. That Xtar is a good charger. If it's overcharging, its broken.
 

suprtrkr

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 22, 2014
10,410
15,048
Cowtown, USA. Where the West begins.
I've now got 12 HE4's, and while I try to keep them as matched pairs, it is becoming harder to remember which pairs are older then others.

Is there a way to test for the CDR amp drop as they age?
Not without bench testing the batteries. Ifyour charger indicates total mAh put in the battery during charge, you can estimate it. The less capacity it holds, the less ampacity it will tolerate. If your charger doesn't, the best I can suggest is watch your charge time. As capacity decreases, so should charge time.
 

fitzinthewindow

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2015
116
269
73
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
I too was torn on what to buy between the Koopor Plus, the Fuchai 200W, and the RX200. After extensive research, I chose the RX200. It seems the overall quality far surpasses the other two by all of the reviews I have seen. I went with Sony VTC4's, because safety was my number 1 concern. I also purchased a new 4 bay Nitecore charger, because I wanted to charge all three batteries at the same time on the same charger I have not received it yet, but I am very confident that I made the right choice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread