Status
Not open for further replies.

Bill's Magic Vapor

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 8, 2013
4,493
11,078
USA
So is the cotton candy enough? I know I don't mind the flavor of that. Do I still need the one called sweetener, or should I just stick with the one that I know I don't find objectionable?

I often use them interchangeably, though they are different flavors. As enhancement flavorings (secondary/tertiary), they both work marvelously. In a juice like my ADV cinnamon Danish, for example, I'll use 10% cotton candy with 10% cinnamon Danish plus 3 - 6% Bavarian cream. Wonderful. I could not use that much sweetener, so you have to pick your spots. If I wanted the filler of a twinkie, for example, I would use sweetener with sweet cream and vanillas swirl. So, you start to get an idea about where best to use each, by using them in different combinations. That said, accordingly, I think you would like/need to have both on hand. They are very useful.

Rules of thumb are tough in DIY because of individual taste preferences. The first rule, though, for me is always try to use cream, vanilla and sweetener (or cotton candy) in every mix. They will not dominate at 6% or less (each), and all three will flavor enhance your primaries to Nirvana levels. Practice test juices with any primary, with those three, and I'll bet you have a hard time making a bad batch. That was the first rule of thumb I learned/discovered for my likes. Good luck! :toast: :D

:2cool: :vapor:
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
I often use them interchangeably, though they are different flavors. As enhancement flavorings (secondary/tertiary), they both work marvelously. In a juice like my ADV cinnamon Danish, for example, I'll use 10% cotton candy with 10% cinnamon Danish plus 3 - 6% Bavarian cream. Wonderful. I could not use that much sweetener, so you have to pick your spots. If I wanted the filler of a twinkie, for example, I would use sweetener with sweet cream and vanillas swirl. So, you start to get an idea about where best to use each, by using them in different combinations. That said, accordingly, I think you would like/need to have both on hand. They are very useful.

Rules of thumb are tough in DIY because of individual taste preferences. The first rule, though, for me is always try to use cream, vanilla and sweetener (or cotton candy) in every mix. They will not dominate at 6% or less (each), and all three will flavor enhance your primaries to Nirvana levels. Practice test juices with any primary, with those three, and I'll bet you have a hard time making a bad batch. That was the first rule of thumb I learned/discovered for my likes. Good luck! :toast: :D

:2cool: :vapor:

Well, I can say that, at least so far, your one rule of thumb has been working marvelously for me so far. With the exception of my one attempt at Pun'kin Pie, I've not made a bad juice... and that one abomination was due to my overuse of spice... I'll revisit it soon, but for now, I'm quite happy with my peach and my chai juices!
 

baseballmom

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 7, 2013
1,358
2,573
SE PA
sincemylastcigarette.com
I am revisiting white chocolate-candy cane blend, again now that I added sweetener, oh so much better, and I was thinking I had to adjust the candy cane, no I just needed to add sweetener....again another big difference for me. I don't know difference between the cotton candy and sweetener effects on flavoring, all I can unscientifically note is my tastebuds are enjoying the vape MUCH more, even though I normally don't like sweet stuff much food or drink wise, and I honestly really don't, I prefer spicy and sour. I will probably stick with just sweetener at 1% since now recognizing I personally do need, it seems to lift/enhance the flavors somehow.....my opinion only.

Went back and read the citric acid info, will try that next after the holidays..lots of good info on those pages too, especially being I like fruit mixes.

I would have never thought I'd make such a proclamation regarding sweetener, lol, but for me, I get it now, I taste the difference, and taste is subjective, but now wow....a small amount has improved my mixes for me pretty dramatically too. I am honestly looking forward to trying the others even more so now:) I really, really think it was "the missing part" in my recipes all along now. :facepalm:
 

Maurice Pudlo

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 27, 2013
1,601
2,232
United States
:danger:

Alright, some steep it hot, some steep it long, and some steep it for a few hours only.

:matrix:


The last time this debate was had, I believe Classy had to intervene - please, let's just drop it, as we've heard from both sides and will now make our own decisions. Bill's spoken his piece, Maurice, I hope you've spoken yours. You've inspired me to play around with juice that benefits from steeping (eventually, maybe), so you're not falling upon deaf ears.

:banana::rickroll::banana:

There is far more to what I've been saying than steeping of whatever sort effects "some" flavors. I do think the message I'm looking to communicate is being lost. I don't disagree with Bill's methodology in the creation of an e-liquid, far from it actually.

Prior to mixing at all one needs to know a bit of math or how to effectively use any of the calculators out there.

I consider step one in the actual process of DIY to be individual flavor mixes, this gives the mixer an idea of what each flavor is like at a given percentage. Knowing the individual flavors sets the foundation for mixing combinations of flavors. At this point folks get frustrated, maybe because they thought they had amassed the ingredients they would like but found out this was not the case. For others they realize that individual flavors aren't enough, these folks move on to the next step while retaining the knowledge they gained here in step one.

Bill's methodology is essentially step two in the learning process of mixing e-liquids, it takes a bit of knowledge about the flavors the mixer has available to them and provides a method of creating a liquid that works. Working off of the information gained in step one people mix not at random but with a purpose and background of what each flavor can bring to a mix. At this point it really does not matter much at all what percentage of flavoring is used so long as the flavor one is looking for is found, so long as the mixer has taken good care to document their mix all is well in the world. If the mixer is completely satisfied at this point there is no need to do anything else.

My method is not replacing what Bill has put down, it is essentially step three and completely optional, not necessary if you will but complementary in that it uses Bill's methodology as a foundation. It is an additional step that is reserved for those who find their efforts using the previous method need a bit more tweeking to get that last little bit out of something they like but feel could be just a bit better. Sure it takes a bit of additional time, however for those of us who are both looking for that something extra, or maybe simply can't devote the time, or even those who want for whatever reason to use less flavorings, an additional step is needed.

I've not intended to insult anyone, or frustrate their efforts in any way, if so I am sorry.

For those of you who need to get up and running fast, recipes are a great way to get mixes on the table, while your at it learn the individual flavors too. When you want to make your own recipes or modify those you have found don't worry so much about percentages just mix knowing a bit about the flavors you are using.

If you've been frustrated in the past, it happens, just try to look at failures as learning points. Every failure can teach us as much as every success if we allow ourselves to look at it in a positive manner.

So, Bills right for the mix and vape group,
I absolutely agree with you on this Slots, I think I tried to communicate that in the course of my ramblings.

Perhaps that point was missed because I was not nearly as lengthy in my making that point. I hope the above rectifies that in some way.

Maurice
 

AndriaD

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
21,253
50,807
64
LawrencevilleGA
angryvaper.crypticsites.com
Wow...a lot learned last few pages...I've learned more too making my rice crispie treat blend too....about sweetener...about it's importance....about it making a bland, boring, flat recipe into a good recipe....sweetener, I never would have realized it's importance until recently....I've always said I don't have a sweet tooth, I tried not to use to prevent gunky coils, I thought things are or should be sweet enough for my tastes....I will be adding at least some sweetener to my mixes from here on in, why? Cause it completely changed something from "meh" to "heck yeah, this is GOOD!" Now I know, sweetener IS important. I was ready to dump this mix, but decided to add 2 drops of sweetener to my very unimpressive rice crispie, and it honestly saved it....it went from tasting like a bland animal cracker to very close to spot-on tasty rice crispie treat, it surpassed the vendor renditions I've had too! I went back and added 2 drops(not going to remix all I made the other day, I usually don't do drops though) to each of my 10 ml trials, for future mixes, I will just calculate 1% sweetener into recipes. I am starting to think some of the "flatness" in my mixes was probably due to me not adding sweetener, most are good but still missing something, that "something" is whatever sweetener brings to a mix, the sweet seems to boost flavors too I think/imo only...

Heh... when I was a kid, my general approach to everything I put in my mouth was 'put enough sugar, everything tastes good!' I really thought I had mostly outgrown that... but now, with ejuice, I'm finding, maybe not. :D Obviously we don't use sugar, but my experience closely mirrors yours... juices I thought were "eh, ok" turn into "FABULOUS!" with enough sweetener in them.

And I'm still working on that strawberry recipe I posted the other night. I ended up putting more of all the flavors, to make it really yummy. Now I have to figure out an actual *recipe* to account for all the extra flavoring I added. :blush: Maybe a touch of vanilla... to me, bavarian cream is sweet and yummy, but it doesn't really have any "vanilla" that I can taste anyway. So maybe I'll add either some french vanilla creme or some of the CAP vanilla custard v2. Not sure yet.

Andria
 

cliffy15

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
1,401
4,396
Honolulu, HI
So is the cotton candy enough? I know I don't mind the flavor of that. Do I still need the one called sweetener, or should I just stick with the one that I know I don't find objectionable?

Whether or not you need sweetener may also depend on your pg/vg blend. vg is rather sweet and at my preferred ratio (30pg/70vg) the vg adds quite a bit of sweetness to the mix.

As was said before, some flavors are sweeter than others.

Personally, I use cotton candy/EM as a "flavor" that needs to bond to other flavors and use it while mixing. I use sweetener as an "additive" ... meaning I only add it if I feel the overall mix needs to be a bit more sweet.

However, there are big difference between the flavor (which is mostly a sweet smell) and the additive (which is primarily a sweet taste).

edit: I guess what I'm trying to say is that I think you may find the need for either, or both, at different times. I don't use the sweetener very often but the cotton candy/EM gets used a lot. I keep a small bottle of sweetener handy as a tool.I keep a good supply of EM around as it is more of a staple.
 
Last edited:

Bill's Magic Vapor

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 8, 2013
4,493
11,078
USA
Okay... I've got a question. I'm thinking about using the Egg Nog flavor in a juice... considering adding Vanilla Bourbon to it. Question is, does that have an actual bourbon flavor profile? And, what other flavors do you think would compliment the Egg Nog?

Vanilla bourbon does have a flavoring, though not active ingredients, obviously, that would completely mimic alcohol. Egg nog needs to be used sparingly. It can easily overwhelm and kill most juices. I use it my vanilla custard recipe, and it's pretty good. Some of the other popular eggnog's, Cap's comes to mind, is so strong that weeks of steeping is required, just to get the nasty taste out of it. That one recipe taught me about high flavoring mixes vs. steep times. After six weeks, the offending eggnog was finally diluted enough to make the juice vapable. After learning how to make juice, eventually, I stopped adding offending flavorings to my juice, they tasted better instantly, and I didn't have to wait for them to change from bad to good/okay. True story. You can see my back and forths from a couple of years ago on the Stevo's vanilla custard thread, if you like. We were after a Grant's Vanilla Custard match. Eventually, these experiences led to my current thinking about making juices. Much easier for me to match great juice with high flavor mixes. About six months after that experience, a simple vanilla custard recipe using all TFA flavorings did emerge....

So, a little goes a long way, my friend. The TFA eggnog is nowhere near as bad as the Capella's. And, vanilla custard can be made immediately, and quite excellent out of the can, so to speak.

Vanilla Custard

Vanilla Custard - 13%
Sweetener - 6%
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream - 3.5%
Eggnog - 2%
Smooth - 2%
Butter - 2%
Graham Cracker - 1.5%

Surprisingly decent right out of the can. The TFA eggnog does not dominate. One of the more popular juices around the neighborhood. Good luck! :toast:
 
Last edited:

baseballmom

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 7, 2013
1,358
2,573
SE PA
sincemylastcigarette.com
Vanilla and creams, problem is tfa has so many good ones to choose from here...I tried solo, no go for my tastes...Will require a good creamy base...I like the vanilla bean gelato, vanilla swirl, malted milk(yes I do like lol), bavarian cream-regular or dx(dang auto spell!), depending on your stance....combo of these mixed together....


Bill beat me to it, and yeah beware the cap eggnog
 
Last edited:

baseballmom

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 7, 2013
1,358
2,573
SE PA
sincemylastcigarette.com
Heh... when I was a kid, my general approach to everything I put in my mouth was 'put enough sugar, everything tastes good!' I really thought I had mostly outgrown that... but now, with ejuice, I'm finding, maybe not. :D Obviously we don't use sugar, but my experience closely mirrors yours... juices I thought were "eh, ok" turn into "FABULOUS!" with enough sweetener in them.

And I'm still working on that strawberry recipe I posted the other night. I ended up putting more of all the flavors, to make it really yummy. Now I have to figure out an actual *recipe* to account for all the extra flavoring I added. :blush: Maybe a touch of vanilla... to me, bavarian cream is sweet and yummy, but it doesn't really have any "vanilla" that I can taste anyway. So maybe I'll add either some french vanilla creme or some of the CAP vanilla custard v2. Not sure yet.

Andria

You let me know how the blueberry goes too...surprised you haven't thrown that in with some custard too and sweetener of course...I'm chomping at the bit to test my blueberries/vanilla swirl mix now that I threw in sweetener I'm eager to taste, will post recipe if it's tasty.
 

AndriaD

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
21,253
50,807
64
LawrencevilleGA
angryvaper.crypticsites.com
You let me know how the blueberry goes too...surprised you haven't thrown that in with some custard too and sweetener of course...I'm chomping at the bit to test my blueberries/vanilla swirl mix now that I threw in sweetener I'm eager to taste, will post recipe if it's tasty.

Well, I still have some of the sweet-vapes blueberry muffin, so I guess I'm just lazy on the blueberry campaign. :D But you're right, I need to get on that, so I can stop spending $9.95 for 15ml of ejuice! :facepalm: Just got a bit sidetracked by the strawberry, and recollecting that right after blueberry, strawberry is my favorite fruit. :D

Andria
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
Thanks, Bill... I'll give that Vanilla Custard a try this weekend!

Also, thinking about trying to mimic a "Spiked Christmas Eggnog" kinda flavor (hence the reason for asking about the Vanilla Bourbon). I know that it won't add intoxicating effects... not really going for that (LOL that's what Jack Daniel's is for), but would like to replicate that flavor....
 

Bill's Magic Vapor

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 8, 2013
4,493
11,078
USA
Thanks, Bill... I'll give that Vanilla Custard a try this weekend!

Also, thinking about trying to mimic a "Spiked Christmas Eggnog" kinda flavor (hence the reason for asking about the Vanilla Bourbon). I know that it won't add intoxicating effects... not really going for that (LOL that's what Jack Daniel's is for), but would like to replicate that flavor....

Right. Of course without alcohol, you can't replicate it, only, perhaps, get in the neighborhood. As tobacco vapes cannot truly emulate the taste of burning tobacco, alcohol is the same in many respects. You can approach, but never really get there....my point! :toast: :D

:2cool: :vapor:
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
I haven't tried the vanilla bourbon yet,but if they use the same flavor as their kentucky bourbon,then it should be pretty close,the kentucky bourbon has that dead on whiskey taste without the alchohol bite.

Thanks, b.m.! I'll have to add that to cart on my next order... I knew I should have just went ahead and got it when I ordered the egg nog... :facepalm:
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
Right. Of course without alcohol, you can't replicate it, only, perhaps, get in the neighborhood. As tobacco vapes cannot truly emulate the taste of burning tobacco, alcohol is the same in many respects. You can approach, but never really get there....my point! :toast: :D

:2cool: :vapor:

We're on the same page... I'm just trying to get in the ballpark. Maybe I'll play around with it this weekend as well... I'll let y'all know how it goes. :2cool:
 

b.m.

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 30, 2014
6,739
21,015
51
Ohio
Thanks, b.m.! I'll have to add that to cart on my next order... I knew I should have just went ahead and got it when I ordered the egg nog... :facepalm:

Yeah,if your a bourbon drinker,definitely give it a try.It's about as realistic as it gets without crackin open the bottle of booze haha,it even has the same exact smell.
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
Yeah,if your a bourbon drinker,definitely give it a try.It's about as realistic as it gets without crackin open the bottle of booze haha,it even has the same exact smell.

Sounds awesome! You know there are no less than 4 different bourbon bottles in my cabinet.... mostly on ice... sometimes with a splash (at most) of coke... ;)
 

Stosh

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Oct 2, 2010
8,921
16,789
74
Nevada
I haven't tried the vanilla bourbon yet,but if they use the same flavor as their kentucky bourbon,then it should be pretty close,the kentucky bourbon has that dead on whiskey taste without the alchohol bite.

I may be mistaken but I always thought the vanilla (bourbon) was a descriptor to separate the vanilla flavor from say a Madagascar vanilla flavor. The Kentucky bourbon is a very nice copy of the nectar of the Gods produced from corm mash and fire charred barrels.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread