Vape shop sued for over a Million dollars because of exploding battery

Status
Not open for further replies.

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
vaping has actually made me safer, with respect to batteries. I don't know if the same cautions are true of "regular" (alkaline) batteries, but used to, if I was going somewhere that I might take a lot of pictures, I'd just stash a couple extra AAs in the side pocket of my purse -- loose. Nothing bad ever happened, thank GOD, which is why I don't know if alkaline batteries are as volatile as the kind we use, but I certainly don't do that anymore; I now put each AA battery in a small sturdy ziplock (thanks vaping, for providing all those small sturdy ziplocks in vapemail!).

But it's true that most people don't consider batteries to be any special danger; they're so ubiquitous, batteries for this that and the other thing... you get used to the idea of a lot of power in a small pkg, and stop thinking about just how much energy is enclosed in that small pkg, and what might result if all that energy escapes all at once.

Andria

No the safety issues concerning Lithium batteries are NOT the same as the common alkaline batteries at all.

Regular batteries are not as powerfull as lithium batteries otherwise we would just be using regular batteries.

Lithium batteries have safety issues, and they should come with WARNING or CAUTION labels, and that has nothing to do with vaping in particular
 

Bad Ninja

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 26, 2013
6,884
17,225
God's Country
No the safety issues concerning Lithium batteries are NOT the same as the common alkaline batteries at all.

Regular batteries are not as powerfull as lithium batteries otherwise we would just be using regular batteries.

Lithium batteries have safety issues, and they should come with WARNING or CAUTION labels, and that has nothing to do with vaping in particular

What should happen is people should educate themselves before buying li-on cells that store large amounts of power.
Use common sense!
I mean who who'da thunk those things could discharge if shorted?
Let's put the responsibility on the retailer to force feed ya some
Logic!
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
No the safety issues concerning Lithium batteries are NOT the same as the common alkaline batteries at all.

Regular batteries are not as powerfull as lithium batteries otherwise we would just be using regular batteries.

Lithium batteries have safety issues, and they should come with WARNING or CAUTION labels, and that has nothing to do with vaping in particular

What should happen is people should educate themselves before buying li-on cells that store large amounts of power.
Use common sense!
I mean who who'da thunk those things could discharge if shorted?
Let's put the responsibility on the retailer to force feed ya some
Logic!

Why to you want to put the responsibility on a retailer for battery labelling?
 

Paradicio

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 30, 2014
445
386
Altadena, CA
Oh, yeah - i forgot to add that he was also drinking hot McDonald's coffee.

https://www.caoc.org/?pg=facts

Again this goes back to what you can prove. In this instance the woman was able to prove that McDonald's had prior knowledge of the coffee being too hot (in the form of over 700 injury reports), and that McDonald's chose to do nothing....until someone got hurt. In this case "hurt" being 3rd degree burns which required skin grafts.

I am all for warning labels and owner's manuals which contain the appropriate cautions. It's a cost effective way for safety measures to be delivered to the consumer WITH the purchase.

Manufacturers cannot operate under the assumption that consumers will research their product safety on the internet.
 

bc indiana

Full Member
Mar 5, 2015
19
15
dallas, texas
His own ignorance and laziness is to blame. I mean, why does the internet exist at all??? Research at your fingertips, sharing of knowledge, etc.

Many great resources exist, such as this forum. Did he do any research on batteries, brands, trusted retailers, cases, counterfeits??? NO. Plus anyone who lets a salesperson tell them what they should buy is just plain...we'll, you get the point.

Ignorance will always be blamed on external sources. No one takes responsibility for their actions these days. And the press gravitates to those stories. Oh the horror!!
 

bwh79

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 11, 2014
4,600
6,644
46
Oregon
So does McDonalds now have warning signs that their food is fattening? I haven't been in one in years so maybe they do. I didn't notice any warnings on the bag of Reeses peanut butter eggs I just bought. I suppose it should say on it that they are fattening and might cause cavities.

Well, they have nutrition information on the wrappers...
 

rothenbj

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 23, 2009
8,285
7,707
Green Lane, Pa
What really should happen is have people that bring civil cases to court and lose pay the defense lawyers fees and court costs. That would discourage both the client and the lawyer from bringing bogus suits into the courtroom. The client may not take the chance if he could end up losing and taking on a large dept and lawyers working on a contingency basis if he could end up losing anything other than his time.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
we need to let Judge Judy handle this one....

imagining her saying... you had a battery in your pocket with loose metal parts too??? Dont you realize a battery is electrical... and metal can make it spark....
didnt you know about protective battery cases???
I'd be willing to bet that Judge Judy has no idea you shouldn't do that.

In fact, I'd be willing to bet that if I walked down the street asking random people...
Not even one person out of three would know that.

EDIT: I would actually do that if I could figure out how to ask the question without biasing the answer.
 
Last edited:

WattWick

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Feb 16, 2013
3,593
5,429
Cold Norway
I'd be willing to bet that Judge Judy has no idea you shouldn't do that.

In fact, I'd be willing to bet that if I walked down the street asking random people...
Not even one person out of three would know that.

EDIT: I would actually do that if I could figure out how to ask the question without biasing the answer.

It's a tough one. What to do when something as potentially volatile as random lithium ion batteries are readily available to the public. If vapers would stick to decent IMR batteries, we (probably) wouldn't have any cases like this one. One part of me questions why this should be used against us. Another part knows that it certainly will. Yet another - slightly more positive part - asks "is this all they got against us?". If so, our opposition is grasping for straws. Which they unfortunately do very successfully.

What saddens me a bit is that we are disputing negatives rather than advocating positives. Positives leads to acceptance. Negatives make people cry for protection. Quantity matters in the media.

What frustrates me is that the negatives are only loosely tied to 'vaping'. It's the occasional fellow doing something they shouldn't be doing. In one sense - I can't really blame people for not knowing that certain kinds of batteries may be dangerous if abused. What to do when people won't listen - or don't know that they need to learn something. This applies to most aspects of life. We simply can not protect people from themselves.

What makes me slightly angry is that this does not need to be an issue at all... if we could only make people stop using explosive batteries. Or convince the public that this is not vaping. It's a mistake. As they say - you can't fix stupid. Like it or not... all of us are occasionally the stupid one.
 
Last edited:

Bad Ninja

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 26, 2013
6,884
17,225
God's Country
I'd be willing to bet that Judge Judy has no idea you shouldn't do that.

In fact, I'd be willing to bet that if I walked down the street asking random people...
Not even one person out of three would know that.

EDIT: I would actually do that if I could figure out how to ask the question without biasing the answer.


I disagree.
Most people aren't stupid.
Any reasonable person will know that having a pocket full of loose metal can cause a battery to short.
Especially a powerful li-on cell that they have purchased.
Yes, there is ways a tool in the crowd, but I believe that's a small minority of adults.
Most people that thick don't make it to adulthood.
 

Ryedan

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 31, 2012
12,869
19,652
Ontario, Canada
It's a tough one. What to do when something as potentially volatile as random lithium ion batteries are readily available to the public. If vapers would stick to decent IMR batteries, we (probably) wouldn't have any cases like this one. One part of me questions why this should be used against us. Another part knows that it certainly will. Yet another - slightly more positive part - asks "is this all they got against us?". If so, our opposition is grasping for straws. Which they unfortunately do very successfully.

What saddens me a bit is that we are disputing negatives rather than advocating positives. Positives leads to acceptance. Negatives make people cry for protection. Quantity matters in the media.

What frustrates me is that the negatives are only loosely tied to 'vaping'. It's the occasional fellow doing something they shouldn't be doing. In one sense - I can't really blame people for not knowing that certain kinds of batteries may be dangerous if abused. What to do when people won't listen - or don't know that they need to learn something. This applies to most aspects of life. We simply can not protect people from themselves.

What makes me slightly angry is that this does not need to be an issue at all... if we could only make people stop using explosive batteries. Or convince the public that this is not vaping. It's a mistake. As they say - you can't fix stupid. Like it or not... all of us are occasionally the stupid one.

You nailed it Wattwick. Kudos :thumb:
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
It's a tough one. What to do when something as potentially volatile as random lithium ion batteries are readily available to the public. If vapers would stick to decent IMR batteries, we (probably) wouldn't have any cases like this one. One part of me questions why this should be used against us. Another part knows that it certainly will. Yet another - slightly more positive part - asks "is this all they got against us?". If so, our opposition is grasping for straws. Which they unfortunately do very successfully.

What saddens me a bit is that we are disputing negatives rather than advocating positives. Positives leads to acceptance. Negatives make people cry for protection. Quantity matters in the media.

What frustrates me is that the negatives are only loosely tied to 'vaping'. It's the occasional fellow doing something they shouldn't be doing. In one sense - I can't really blame people for not knowing that certain kinds of batteries may be dangerous if abused. What to do when people won't listen - or don't know that they need to learn something. This applies to most aspects of life. We simply can not protect people from themselves.

What makes me slightly angry is that this does not need to be an issue at all... if we could only make people stop using explosive batteries. Or convince the public that this is not vaping. It's a mistake. As they say - you can't fix stupid. Like it or not... all of us are occasionally the stupid one.

I'm not so sure how readily available lithium ion batteries are to the public; do you see them where you get other batteries? I don't.
I can't get them locally where I am; even Radio Shack doesn't have them (although that might not mean much for Radio Shack nowadays); it seems to be a specialty item.

All the talk about Sony vtc that I used to see on this board, I never saw a picture of a battery that actually had "Sony" on the label.

Maybe the guys at Sony just didn't want to have anything to do with what they saw coming with the future of 18650 batteries.


Here's a Samsung though:
1066607-3.jpg

Not sure what the Samsung logo looks like, but at least there's the name on the battery; and assuming it really is a Samsung battery I can have some confidence that the battery does what it's supposed to do.

Here's a supposed "Panasonic"
1233700-2.jpg

but there's no "Panasonic" that I see anywhere on that battery.

I got efest batteries myself, and they have efest name/logo on them.

There seems to be no Duracell, or Energizer lithium battery; that says something.
 

StormFinch

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2010
2,683
4,812
Arkansas
Alkaline batteries do indeed explode, they're just not quite as dramatic as li-ions, and all the major brands have warning on their websites (probably the packaging too) not to put a loose battery in with metal objects. 13 Investigates exploding alkaline batteries - 13 WTHR Indianapolis Do a google of alkaline explosion for more.

Also, the old fateful 9 volt can do significant damage given the chance. A guy in Colorado was foolish enough to toss all his old smoke detector batteries in a sack to recycle later, and left the sack in the garage. According to the fire department two of those batteries contacted each other after something else was placed on the shelf against the sack. The house was gutted.

house_fire.jpg



Now, think about how many people leave alkalines lying around loose in a junk drawer.

As far as commonly sold lithiums, the CR123A found in any camera department springs to mind, and Energizer at the very least has a line of lithium/Iron Disulfide readily available. The li-ions we use make up 66% of Japan's battery sales.

Imho, this is just another example of being babysat by the government for too long. We as a species have lost our sense of self-preservation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread