Vapelicious?

Status
Not open for further replies.

rebgold

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 27, 2013
307
387
57
Wichita, KS
Wow. I started one of the most interesting threads I've read on here just because I wondered what violet tobacco liquid tasted like!
Usually I'm a thread killer but I struck it out of the park on this one, lol.
Too bad I have nothing interesting to add.
Carry on everyone.
Mr Mann, is your avatar your own work?
 

hittman

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Contest Winner!
  • Jul 13, 2009
    61,616
    180,012
    Somewhere between here and there
    It's been awhile.

    I created WTA for one reason: To test a theory.

    The theory came about from the observed fact that the cigarette cravings of some folks weren't being helped by nicotine containing e-liquid, even at frighteningly high nicotine concentrations. "Why not?", I asked myself. As you probably know by now, nicotine is the dominant alkaloid contained in tobacco comprising approximately 95% of the tobacco alkaloid spread.

    My attention kept being pulled to Sweden and their long-standing fondness for Snus. The percentage of the Swedish population who are smokers is very low; I believe the lowest in Europe. Another, "Why?".

    I stuck these facts in my brain and allowed them to ferment awhile. Cigarettes do the trick... Snus does the trick... E-liquid sometimes doesn't do the trick. Then it clicked. Cigarettes and snus both contain the entire tobacco alkaloid spread. E-liquid does not.

    The theory was simply that the non-nicotine tobacco alkaloid spread (5% -vs- 95% nicotine) is being disregarded as "miscellaneous other" while, in fact, it contributes in a sometimes significant manner to the whole addiction process (depending, in no small part, on the individual).

    But how to test the theory? I put my chemistry background to use and figured I would separate the alkaloids from their tobacco matrix. The chemistry to doing this is very basic, but the execution isn't. It's hard to the point of being a pain in the .... I honestly can't remember the quantity of tobacco I worked with the first time around, but I figured I could get a gram or two of alkaloids from 100 grams of tobacco, and I recovered the alkaloids from tobacco precisely in that range.

    For those of you who have never seen the old photos I posted, the alkaloids that I recovered from whole tobacco (whole tobacco alkaloids, as I called them), were an amber to copper colored liquid with a strong odor of nicotine... and in their purified form, quite capable of killing me a good number of times over.

    I diluted these alkaloids down to 30 mg with my favorite PG/VG blend, and dripped a fresh atty at 3.7 volts. The first vape was a wonder. The subtle flavor and throat hit were stunning. The vapor was thick and persistent. I vaped for awhile and then noticed that I was feeling very relaxed.

    So far, so good. Now, I've got to make more and find some folks to test this stuff at 30 mg. So I made more, a lot more. I recruited my three testers. The whole lot of them were nicotine degenerates. "Professionals", as I called them. Two of the three testers practically offered to have my babies. The third, much more a snus user, wasn't as enthusiastic.

    Oven the next while, I offered the WTA to several others such as Hittman, Tropical Bob, and maybe one of two I don't even remember. It was for Tropical Bob that I produced the now mythical 48 mg WTA. This stuff could put a lesser vaper into a coma, not Bob. Still, as I recall, he had to have a "lay down".

    Times passed and a lot of discussion and more theorizing occurred. Honestly, I don't know how many of my ideas and how much of my speculation I would still believe today, I change my mind easily and I've not thought much about WTA lately.

    More time passed and here we are today.

    Holy crap! I thought I was imagining things when I saw you posted. It's great to see you here Dvap. I just have one question. How the heck did you post the word "..." without getting sensored?:laugh: Seriously though, I'd gladly do some testing on some more of that 30mg wta. Your unflavored 30mg is still my favorite.
     

    redrose

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jan 29, 2009
    956
    735
    CT
    I second that, he does not encourage trash talk. However, we are all entitled to our personal opinions- like- i noticed you, red rose, always talk about how you think Ethan's juice is better in this forum. And i'm certainly entitled to my own opinion.

    I think we all appreciate valid points and objective or subjective opinions based on personal experience. You however, have not tried Vapelicious, know nothing about the percentages involved in either bottle product, seem bent on bad-mouthing a company you have no experience with, and want to post about comments that have no basis in fact, ie: "Yes, Jerry said the percentage matches the levels. I read it on a thread the other day, but not sure which one now." and "one guy was even wondering what he should do that his wife passed out from vaping Ethans juice (??)"

    Post away, I have an ignore button.
     

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    Mr.Mann,

    Use my name all you want. If you misuse it too badly, I'll probably say something, but I have no qualms to speak of at the moment.

    Well, I swear to you that before you made this post, I was editing mine so as to relent with using your name! I'm serious, it was a minute before! It's hard cause while there is so much info to quote, it can be easily taken out of context, and like my Paps used to say, "text taken out of context is the pretext to a lie." I wanted to not go there.

    Wow. I started one of the most interesting threads I've read on here just because I wondered what violet tobacco liquid tasted like!
    Usually I'm a thread killer but I struck it out of the park on this one, lol.
    Too bad I have nothing interesting to add.
    Carry on everyone.
    Mr Mann, is your avatar your own work?

    Yep. It is.
     

    PLANofMAN

    Signature Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 9, 2012
    4,147
    8,070
    45
    Woodburn, OR
    I know certain people bring up the "but where's the tests?" question every time WTA is mentioned. Jerry has said that the tests are available to anyone who wants to come to the lab and view them.

    Because of non-disclosure agreements with the tester, he cannot make them publicly available without redacting portions of the test (i.e. who the tester is) because of this, Jerry is reluctant to show them to the community at large because he is concerned that people would think he is deliberately trying to mislead them. I personally think that Jerry is misjudging his audience in this case, but there will always be those who see the worst in people, just as there are those who look at the world through rose tinted glasses.

    Dvap, I'm not sure if you cleared up any misconceptions in this thread with your post, but it's nice to see you drop in. Kind of like if Jesus dropped in on a sermon and said to the congregation, "You know, Ol' John got this part pretty much right when he said..." :D

    I've really enjoyed reading your blogs.
     

    DVap

    Nicotiana Alchemia
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Aug 26, 2009
    1,548
    1,586
    I might follow this one and chime in for a few days then lurk back off into the darkness. Gotta go to work in Germany on Friday anyway and I'll be busy so I'll forget all about this by the time I come back. Heh heh.

    As far as WTA strength goes, my own opinion summarizes like this:

    48 mg WTA: I tried just a bit of this before I sent the rest off to Tropical Bob. This is the vape of the gods, and only the gods or Bob should be vaping this.

    30 mg WTA: Seriously potent stuff.

    24 mg WTA: Strong enough for a man, or a manly woman.

    18 mg WTA: My own sweet spot. The throat hit and flavor is muted, but not too badly.

    12 mg WTA: This one teases. It's like a good side-boob shot. Not the whole show, but enough to say, "Well, that was interesting."

    6 mg WTA: This is the one the {edit} peddler gives you on the street, "First one's free!", after that, you gotta pay.

    edit:

    Rose, I'm occupied by a new job. Left the lab after many years a couple months back. Now I'm on the road most of the time.
     
    Last edited by a moderator:

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    i was not just referring to your statements, mr. mann. i have read others in this forum as well- one guy was even wondering what he should do that his wife passed out from vaping Ethans juice (??)

    As far as your 'trick question'- (sheepish much?) that was an initial scientific experimentation by Dvap- it was not a product for sale, but a scientific experiment - something that most chemists do when testing a substance. Aroma keeps their product levels on par with their mgs and does not have extra high wta... and as you have said, they are trustworthy. i dont need more problems, i want to be healthy and stay cig free. their product does this for me, it takes the edge off- nothing more, nothing less. and.. i always get my orders in a week. thats my choice. if others want to order from Ethan, that is their choice. carry on..

    Oh, I just saw this hiding behind...post! haha

    "sheepish much?" Odd wording. I would try to come up with some clever retort, but I will let your's reflect upon itself.

    Now, as far as you bringing up the scientist experiment vs. selling for profit, that is something that is a good point and one that I knew I left myself open for. Oops. Point to you. However, I think you may have missed my point. I am merely saying that no matter the motivation, I don't think "messing" with the levels is any less insidious if doing it for profit or for research, no? That is just an opinion and not necessarily something that is built upon rock so no need to "carry" anything "on," it would be best to drop it.

    p.s. Someone passed out? Damn! That is something IMO one should only say when having a link to back it up. And even then, that is a bit hardcore, almost like spreading gossip, when not speaking first hand. Who knows, maybe it did happen. But then again, maybe it didn't. Either way, I had that juice and looked up at a ceiling from my bed. Then again, I was on my way to bed anyway. :p
     

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    I might follow this one and chime in for a few days then lurk back off into the darkness. Gotta go to work in Germany on Friday anyway and I'll be busy so I'll forget all about this by the time I come back. Heh heh.

    As far as WTA strength goes, my own opinion summarizes like this:

    48 mg WTA: I tried just a bit of this before I sent the rest off to Tropical Bob. This is the vape of the gods, and only the gods or Bob should be vaping this.

    30 mg WTA: Seriously potent stuff.

    24 mg WTA: Strong enough for a man, or a manly woman.

    18 mg WTA: My own sweet spot. The throat hit and flavor is muted, but not too badly.

    12 mg WTA: This one teases. It's like a good side-boob shot. Not the whole show, but enough to say, "Well, that was interesting."

    6 mg WTA: This is the one the {edit} peddler gives you on the street, "First one's free!", after that, you gotta pay.

    edit:

    Rose, I'm occupied by a new job. Left the lab after many years a couple months back. Now I'm on the road most of the time.

    Thanks for this! Thanks for this!

    There was just a loud clap outside followed by pouring rain. Once again, I am so serious. I finally can say I was there when. Nice.
     
    Last edited by a moderator:

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    Dvap, did those different WTA levels follow the spread? I can remember (I think) reading that someone, if not you, vaping WTA liquid that had no nic. If those different strengths did follow the spread, what did that mean for the nicotine? I guess what I am asking is, if I wanted a juice at 24 mg or even 32 mg nic, what mg would the WTA be for the spread?

    Answered below
     
    Last edited:

    stefania123

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Mar 5, 2013
    478
    542
    Los Angeles
    • Deleted by Unforeseen

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    Not being ECF registered has nothing to do with being "allowed" to have a thread here.

    I am not saying you made it up, I am saying something like that, without a link, is mere gossip, period. For you to be concerned about the community, I would like to think you get that.

    I heard....
     
    Last edited:

    DVap

    Nicotiana Alchemia
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Aug 26, 2009
    1,548
    1,586
    Dvap, did those different WTA levels follow the spread? I can remember (I think) reading that someone, if not you, vaping WTA liquid that had no nic. If those different strengths did follow the spread, what did that mean for the nicotine? I guess what I am asking is, if I wanted a juice at 24 mg or even 32 mg nic, what mg would the WTA be for the spread?

    WTA should follow the spread. Making a liquid with no nicotine would not be WTA as the "W" in "WTA" stands for "Whole". I can't imagine anyone with a liquid containing only the minor alkaloid portion of the alkaloid spread... I know I couldn't make it and I wouldn't want to vape it.

    The 30 mg WTA, which is pretty potent stuff, is 95% (28.5 mg/mL) in nicotine, and 5% (1.5 mg/mL) in all the other alkaloids combined.

    You must not assume that the mg strength of WTA refers to just the minor alkaloids, it refers to the total alkaloid concentration, I.E. nicotine plus all the minor alkaloids. While WTA is mostly nicotine, the 5% other alkaloids is where the magic is.

    edit:

    To add something, one might ask, "Can't you then start with just nicotine and add the 5% other alkaloids to get WTA?". The answer is "No" for two reasons:

    1. When you extract tobacco, you get 95% nicotine and 5% other alkaloids. Very sophisticated techniques could be used to separate the minor alkaloids from the nicotine, but this would be extremely involved and astronomically expensive. Far easier to extract WTA and simply dilute with PG/VG.

    2. When you start messing with the product and changing it, it is no longer WTA. I define WTA as the UNMODIFIED alkaloid spread extracted from whole tobacco. I can do that 'cuz I created the term and I get to define it. ;)
     
    Last edited:

    Mr.Mann

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Dec 30, 2011
    17,401
    40,572
    48
    All over the place
    WTA should follow the spread. Making a liquid with no nicotine would not be WTA as the "W" in "WTA" stands for "Whole". I can't imagine anyone with a liquid containing only the minor alkaloid portion of the alkaloid spread... I know I couldn't make it and I wouldn't want to vape it.

    The 30 mg WTA, which is pretty potent stuff, is 95% (28.5 mg/mL) in nicotine, and 5% (1.5 mg/mL) in all the other alkaloids combined.

    You must not assume that the mg strength of WTA refers to just the minor alkaloids, it refers to the total alkaloid concentration, I.E. nicotine plus all the minor alkaloids. While WTA is mostly nicotine, the 5% other alkaloids is where the magic is.

    edit:

    To add something, one might ask, "Can't you then start with just nicotine and add the 5% other alkaloids to get WTA?". The answer is "No" for two reasons:

    1. When you extract tobacco, you get 95% nicotine and 5% other alkaloids. Very sophisticated techniques could be used to separate the minor alkaloids from the nicotine, but this would be extremely involved and astronomically expensive. Far easier to extract WTA and simply dilute with PG/VG.

    2. When you start messing with the product and changing it, it is no longer WTA. I define WTA as the UNMODIFIED alkaloid spread extracted from whole tobacco. I can do that 'cuz I created the term and I get to define it. ;)

    I knew that! :blush: D'oh. :laugh:

    Okay, so in that respect, when Aroma says that it's the same amount of WTA in 12 mg and so on, then that means it is the same ratio, or spread of WTA as you call it? Okay then, that makes sense. I didn't get what was meant by it's the "same" in 12 mg as in 24 mg--it wouldn't be the same, from what I gather, but I get how that term could be used.

    Now based on that explanation, I can see and understand how anything else does seem to "mess" with it.

    I have no problem being teachable.
     
    Last edited:
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread