During my over 35 years of smoking, I smoked just about everything on the market, from unfiltered (Pal Mals. Lucky Strikes. Camels.etc) to menthol. I also smoked a pipe & still smoke a few cigars a month. I've never found a "match" to anything I smoked before, but I've found many juices that I like FAR BETTER than anything I put a match to (well, most anyway).
Don't limit yourself to trying to match what you liked with tobacco, the sky's the limit with vaping... and after a while, even the smell of a cigarette will turn you off.