Bought nic from 3 vendors. Only one smells "flavorless"

Status
Not open for further replies.

j3illy

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 6, 2013
300
93
MA
It's an organic molecule that oxidizes so a loss in potency is unavoidable. But in a freezer I think it's nothing more than a loss of single digit % after years. I'm still interested in seeing samples tested that are years old tho. It lasts longer in PG tho, and that has a freezing point of around -75, so it's not gonna be frozen in there. I think w/ VG, it's a quicker medium for oxidation to occur. If you ever notice when you shake a high VG solution, there's tons of tiny air bubbles in it, which seems to support that theory.
 

Kurt

Quantum Vapyre
ECF Veteran
Sep 16, 2009
3,433
3,607
Philadelphia
Nic, even very pure nic, can have a smell, and that smell/taste can vary. We are not sure where the smell comes from, since ultra-pure nic (like Alchem which does a distillation after the final extraction) has virtually no smell/taste, but it is my belief that it comes from trace non-nicotine alkaloids that come along to a small extent in the extraction process. I have seen excellent analysis results on nics that have a popcorn, peanut to sharp acrid smell. I actually like those to vape unflavored.

The three companies you mention have good reputations for putting out quality nic. WL especially tends to put out a very consistent product. WL Ice, no longer available it seems, was more odorless and tasteless than their regular nic, but even their regular is very low smell/taste. MFS recently increased their purity and seem to be putting out ultra-pure nic these days. Was not always the case, but then I am considering nic from 2009. MUCH has changed in purity now, across the board. I think trace oxides also have a particular taste, and may be responsible for the tobacco notes that seem to grow in with an aged nic.

I would not worry about argon gas. If they are not shipping in glass, I think Ar is moot, since O2 can slowly get through a plastic container. Once it is opened, the argon is gone, anyway. Freezer store in glass, well sealed, to get the most time out of the nic.

You might find this thread interesting: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/diy-e-liquid/298547-nicotine-comparisons.html
 

MD_Boater

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 6, 2013
583
1,020
Maryland Chesapeake Bay
I've used nic from all of those companies and also just recently ordered from MFS and as you the 100mg NIC did have a distinct odor to it. But when you mix it down to your desired vaping strength (Mine was 14mg 65VG\35PG) there should be no noticeable odor. So what you need to do is mix down the NIC and see if the smell goes away or at least deminishes to bearly detectable. If you still have an unplesent smell contact the vender and ask for a replacement. I've delt with issues with both WL and MFS and they sent out replacements quickly. Theres no need to worry about if the bottle was opened or not they don't require the old stuff be sent back.

You sir, were correct. I whipped up some 6mg butterscotch with the MFS and it does not taste like it smells.

There was absolutely a difference when I first opened them. I'm not going to speculate as to why, as all of them smell the same now. The strongest smelling one does not seem to add any undesired flavor to the juice. I will make up some 12mg this weekend to test, but I think the results will be the same.
 

r77r7r

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Feb 15, 2011
    13,653
    22,632
    Pa,LandOfTaxes
    Nic, even very pure nic, can have a smell, and that smell/taste can vary. We are not sure where the smell comes from, since ultra-pure nic (like Alchem which does a distillation after the final extraction) has virtually no smell/taste, but it is my belief that it comes from trace non-nicotine alkaloids that come along to a small extent in the extraction process. I have seen excellent analysis results on nics that have a popcorn, peanut to sharp acrid smell. I actually like those to vape unflavored.

    The three companies you mention have good reputations for putting out quality nic. WL especially tends to put out a very consistent product. WL Ice, no longer available it seems, was more odorless and tasteless than their regular nic, but even their regular is very low smell/taste. MFS recently increased their purity and seem to be putting out ultra-pure nic these days. Was not always the case, but then I am considering nic from 2009. MUCH has changed in purity now, across the board. I think trace oxides also have a particular taste, and may be responsible for the tobacco notes that seem to grow in with an aged nic.

    I would not worry about argon gas. If they are not shipping in glass, I think Ar is moot, since O2 can slowly get through a plastic container. Once it is opened, the argon is gone, anyway. Freezer store in glass, well sealed, to get the most time out of the nic.

    You might find this thread interesting: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/diy-e-liquid/298547-nicotine-comparisons.html


    It's nice to know that smell and taste doesn't equate to purity. Doesn't make it easier to vape tho.
     

    MD_Boater

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Nov 6, 2013
    583
    1,020
    Maryland Chesapeake Bay
    Okay guys. I used the test kit on all 3 nics. Here are the results:

    MFS 100mg - Tested at 113.5mg
    WL 100mg - Tested at 103.8mg
    NN 100mg - Tested at 90.8mg - I assumed that we screwed up, so we re-tested @ 92.4mg

    We were going to re-test the MFS, but it does smell stronger than the others as I previously mentioned, so I believe that the test is accurate.

    If I mix the NN and MFS together, that would be 102.55mg. I might do this...
     
    Last edited:

    MD_Boater

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Nov 6, 2013
    583
    1,020
    Maryland Chesapeake Bay
    We did... I might put the 3 bottles in a zip lock bag and set it in warm water for a bit, shake, and then restest all 3. If I have time.

    My buddy and I also made up some more juice. He made 10ml / 18mg of Pineapple, I made 10ml / 12mg Watermelon. Both (TFA)came out great at 15% 65/35 PG/VG. We did them in 10ml graduated cylinders. I highly recommend this method. Simply make notes on the recipie chart for the total volume after adding each ingredient. Nic to 1.2ml line, PG to 6.5ml line, VG to 8.8ml line, flavoring to 10ml line, done. Easy as pie. Easier, actually. no waiting for the oven to warm up. ;)
     
    Last edited:

    emus

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jun 9, 2009
    4,804
    2,007
    Just in case anyone else is a juice miser.
    I transfer 100 mg on clean surface.
    I sop up spills w/ clean cotton gauze.
    Put cotton in syringe and squeeze extract the juice; I vape the recovered juice first.
    Sometimes, I extract juice from wicks w/ syringe.

    I syringe mix and don't waste a drop; have dedicated syringes for VG, PG and nic. So far, syringe mixing is close enough for me.

    Aqua clone has driven me a little nuts because I have spilled too much juice fiddling w/ that booger. I don't loose any juice w/ Genny.

    I know it takes a while for VG and PG to become homogeneous; takes a fair amount of shakes to rid the striations. VG and nic may mix much easier. Hopefully I shook the 1L enough before 30 ml transfers.
     

    cags

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jan 27, 2011
    3,908
    4,401
    east TN
    Just in case anyone else is a juice miser.
    I transfer 100 mg on clean surface.
    I sop up spills w/ clean cotton gauze.
    Put cotton in syringe and squeeze extract the juice; I vape the recovered juice first.
    Sometimes, I extract juice from wicks w/ syringe.............

    I transfer my nic to glass bottles. then I put the plastic bottles upside down on a funnel that is in a smaller glass bottle and let it sit a while. last time I did this I got about 20ml extra liquid from 2 250ml bottles :shock:
     

    emus

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jun 9, 2009
    4,804
    2,007
    I transfer my nic to glass bottles. then I put the plastic bottles upside down on a funnel that is in a smaller glass bottle and let it sit a while. last time I did this I got about 20ml extra liquid from 2 250ml bottles :shock:

    After draining 100 mg bottle I rinse w/ PG then vape the PG.
    I quit using funnels and hit the mark...most of the time:)
    No need to treat like gold now but who knows down the road.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread