I'm sure that the supplier conundrum was thoroughly discussed and considered before making the rules. THAT said, I don't know how the rules came to be what they are.
vaping is a VERY nascent industry. It only makes sense, since people who already WERE innovators and entrepreneurs, who took up vaping, that many of those people would innovate and look for opportunity (both financial and altruistic) to improve vaping! Where did the management here hope that new ideas would come from. From NON members? Ridiculous! Wouldn't we hope that those people would come from RIGHT HERE, within our ranks?
I also participate on MANY other hobby forums. On each and every one, folks that are "in the business" are not only allowed, but encouraged to post! In most cases, the forum requires some kind of identifier in their sig that they are ITB, so that others can know that their words might be influenced by their interests. So what?! Those people are often THE most knowledgeable about the subjects at hand. And, in some cases it is a rule that they contribute financially to the forum (not thousands for an amateur fer chrissakes) and in others, it is a suggestion. But we're aduults. If someone making BIG business decides to be cheap and not contribute, they appropriately are not well regarded by the other members who have an interest in the success of that forum.
When we lose people like Roxy, we not only lose all of that experience and cleverness. We also lose the contributions that those who enjoyed their posts make to the OTHER places that they will then go to, to see what that person is up to or saying.
Who wants to accept supplier status on a board like this? All your previous contributions are wiped out? You become hobbled and restrained to your own single thread? This is a policy that needs to be re-thought. I'll go so far as to say that not only does it need to change, but ECF would do VERY well to extend an olive branch to those they've driven away, in the hope that they can lure those people back to this forum. I'm pretty sure that they don't REALLY like going to the land of misfit toys, where they have to join those who have been kicked out of here because they just don't know how to socialize properly with people. But the more we kick out GOOD contributors to THOSE places, the more we improve THOSE places over being what they truly started as. A haven for the ill-mannered and out-of-control.
ECF is a compelling place. Lots of great contributors, and the best vaping content on the web. But we are reducing that with every well meaning, interesting, well spoken and experienced vaper that we boot. It really is time to get a handle on this problem. Telling the emperor he has no clothes shouldn't be cause for beheading. Designing better clothes shouldn't be either. Heavy handed moderation will certainly keep the chickens in line, but it makes for a pretty dull farm.