DO NOT BUY 510LRs

Status
Not open for further replies.

mwa102464

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Oct 14, 2009
14,447
12,564
Outside of the Philadelphia Burbs, NJ & Fla
zbasspro,

David tried to only make a change that was supposed to be for the best, it didnt end up working this way and he is now currently back to the old EM Atty's. So I hope you will and can understand that sometimes things just dont go like planned. David is a stand up guy and he will replace every Atty there is an issue with and make this right for Bob since he placed the order, done deal, thanks for understanding I hope all is cool now
 
Okay that was not David that emailed me, it was Selina. Basically I was told to ship them back, at whose expense was not mentioned. The last correspondence I had with David was one indicating that I have a bad meter. At this point a handful have been sent to an veteran moderator at the site who is familiar with the product. I surely would like to know how ordering directly from the site ensures one that that they are getting the old great 510s?

My last two orders directly from the site would indicate that I am getting nothing remotely close to the old great 510LRs I was 5 months ago. I have to ask you mwa have you ordered any yourself personally in the last 6 weeks since they changed the labeling amongst other things? If so what is your experience with them?

I'm not comfortable with replacements until a problem other than my meter is recognized here. Maybe I'm all wrong here and the one who is checking them out and has been using them forever and not ordered them in several months will be shocked with David's efforts to improve this product for us. I guess we will know in a few days. Until then I bow out, I've shared my experience as well as the communication I've had with CS. I don't know what else needs to be said here, other than maybe the age old saying "if it aint broke don't fix it". boB
 

316lvm

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 5, 2009
1,050
16
southern minnesota
I was involved with this co-op. For EM's sake, I do hope by now that everything has been taken care of.

But I've got to say mwa, I'm am pretty torqued off at the comments you made, especially since you weren't involved in the co-op to begin with, nor were you privy to the emails, pms and other communications involved between boB, Di, David and those of us in the co-op


I don't see it as a huge problem as we all have purchased things that where not to our expectations and without trial there would be no error so maybe they where only trying to improve on what they had. I have purchased many of items from numerous suppliers that I am not using anymore because I have found better and that's just how it is, so I either sold the stuff or its sitting in some drawer somewhere unused, So if next month EM comes out with the hottest product on the market how many wouldn't buy it.


You missed the mark here. The atty's weren't BETTER. And there is/was a SAFETY issue with the attys. People have been telling EM that the attys were crap. Bob was assured that the attys we would be getting were not the defective ones 'cause they got a shipment of new ones that were good. Bob even asked them to check to make sure before sending them out.

For $3 an Atty you could use them for 2 days and its cheaper then analogs, I understand you had higher expectations set for these Attys but sometimes that's how it goes, especially buying sight unseen product from China, I say sell them if you don't like them, and they will sell, and someone will use them, and wait until you see something better and use the money to buy that item.

That's fine and dandy for your spending habits but not mine. My expectations are that when I purchase something, I expect it to be of the same quality as previous purchases not a down graded version. Nor can I afford to toss out $3 every 2 days. BTW, did I mention safety concerns?



EM has taken care of all of us price wise for well over a year now and how many of us have purchased Rivas and other stuff from them cheaper then they could get it any where else and are very happy with that item, I just wouldn't make such a huge deal over some Atty's if it where me, I know others may disagree with me but that's just my spin on this issue, I'm sure I will get attacked for this but no sweat off my shoulder I'm a big boy.

This attitude maybe fine with you, but don't expect others to think likewise. The big deal wasn't over a "few" attys. It was almost the entire order of LR attys. It was the issue of badly made attys. It was the lack of communication from EM's part. It was blaming boB for having a broken multimeter. It was boB not being able to use a multimeter correctly.
The other problem is this was a Co Op purchase, so with that risk in buying that way you really have no gripe at all with EM as you actually didn't purchase directly from them so whomever made the purchase is the one that would need to be calling CS, like the guy who made the Co Op purchase, there is a middle man in this deal who handled this so it is really all on him, if you where shorted Attys that to would be on him not EM. I'm not trying to protect EM here either so that's not the case, I'm just calling it like I see this the way it went down Bob, No hard feeling I hope, I know David pretty well and the rep Di as I have done business with them for quite a while now and I say David would possibly even take care of you if you went about this another way because he does care about his customers very much, I have witnessed it personally as he has always squared away any issue I have ever had. If I could give you one piece of advice it would be this, instead of stomping on EM here on this thread how about you have the guy who actually made the purchase call David and explain the situation and see what he would do for you, maybe you can ship these Attys to there Ohio return center and get new ones sent out if there that Badly made, just a suggestion Bob

Don't even know where to start with this comment. Yes, it was a co-op purchase and yes, I do have a right to complain. Seeing's how we were told that there wouldn't be a problem with bad atty's. And no, it wasn't about a being a few attys short. At no time, until now, has anyone of us interfered with boB handling the issue with EM. So I don't take kindly to the fact that you thought it was one of us buyers that placed a complaint. And yes, you are trying to protect EM here otherwise you wouldn't go on about how wonderful and fantastic they are.


My bad guys I dint see Bob was runing the Co Op I thought he was a buyer in the Co Op, Bob if I can help you out let me know I know David pretty good and have done lots of business with him for quite a while now, he is a pretty understanding guy and I have him on my Skype and can chat with him right now if you would like me to help

You're right - because you weren't involved in this at all. Again, none of us interfered with the situation between boB and EM.


Skish your gong the wrong way on this with me pal, I am only trying to help, and will if I can, I don't believe David Yang lied though, maybe misunderstood but not lied, I will skype him now and chat with him about this and see if I cant lend a helping hand

I don't believe Skish was going the wrong way with this. He just stated the obvious.

OK GUY'S listen I feel your pain OK,,, Here is what I did to solve this issue for you all and I hope you take my advice and this will be resolved definitely OK === Bob David just got your EMail from this morning @ support@eastmall.net he will handle this issue for you all but only Bob must speak with him he wont deal with everyone. Bob he will reply to your EMail now or soon, remember there is a big time difference involved here so always give EM More like 2 Days to reply instead of 1 day. Anyway Bob David will reply and you also email support@eastmall.net and speak with David back and forth and he will replace all of you guys Attys that you want replaced no problem. Trust me David always takes care of any issues guys, sometimes things happen in any business but this owner is hands on when he needs to be so just speak with David Bob and all of this will be handled and some I'm sure. I hope I was able to help you guys with this by getting involved, I usually don't but felt I could help

Why did you feel the need to solve this issue? Is it because you opened mouth and inserted foot? Is it because you got into this? What makes you think that you can interfere but us buyers can't or say jack poop about how this was handled? As far as I knew, boB was handling this with EM.

zbasspro,

David tried to only make a change that was supposed to be for the best, it didnt end up working this way and he is now currently back to the old EM Atty's. So I hope you will and can understand that sometimes things just dont go like planned. David is a stand up guy and he will replace every Atty there is an issue with and make this right for Bob since he placed the order, done deal, thanks for understanding I hope all is cool now

Again, defending EM. What change for the best? David was made aware of the faulty attys and still shipped them. Thank you for pointing out again that boB placed the order with EM. But you seem to have ignored that there were 30 people who placed the order to boB. No matter how you look at it, it still comes to 30 customers whether we placed the order or boB.

Those of us involved with the co-op were made aware of that there might be issues with the LR510 attys. Before he placed the order, he was assured by EM was aware of the faulty attys and that they had recieved a new batch from the manufacturer. EM stated that they wouldn't ship out the faulty attys.
boB asked them to make sure to check the attys before they were shipped to make sure they were good.

He told us that he would check the LR510 when he got them to make sure they were good to go. He even offered to send us replacements if anyone was in dire need of LR510's.

During this entire co-op ordeal boB has been in constant contact with us as well as EM. I've watched get more and more frustrated as his emails to EM kept getting ignored. I've watched as 30 people supported boB through this mess.

I've been a customer of EM for a while now. But after being involved with this co-op, seeing how boB has been treated, the lack of customer service, the knowing of selling faulty attys, the lack of concern for safety issues with the faulty attys and a hundred other things, I will no longer be a customer of EM.

I hope tomorrow brings better news. 'Nite.

 

mwa102464

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Oct 14, 2009
14,447
12,564
Outside of the Philadelphia Burbs, NJ & Fla
Bob this is your Co Op not mine, I would have ran it a bit differently then you had and done some things differently then you did as far as buying and how I dealt with EM, so how about this, I bow out now too since you have said you are on your own deal, and just for kicks and giggle I have personally spent over 5k with eastmall in the last yr and No I didn't place an order for any Attys in the last 6 weeks because I knew there was issues from following the EM thread. I hope I have answered your questions, any further please direct them to EM as I no longer feel comfortable being in the middle of this transaction that isn't mine to begin with and was only trying to help.
 

skish

Full Member
May 15, 2010
30
14
Left Coast (CA & WA)
Been there, done that!!!

Now just the facts Ma’am.

Ordered on Sept 29.
Received out-of-spec units on Oct 5th.

Worked through CS who acknowledged units were not in spec and would replace the units with corrected units upon returning them to their US POC.

I returned the units on Oct 9th (at my expense) and they received them on Oct 12.

In the mean time, to quote an EM representative from another thread from Oct 8th:

"the first a few handred are not exactly the same
but from now on, it will be the same
some people complain the hole on the battery end is too small,
but now they will be the same as the original ones.

all good again"


So after receiving reassurances from both CS and the EM representative that “all good again”, my replacements were shipped out on Oct 15th.

I took delivery on Oct 20 where the results can be found here.


So mwa102464... Did I understand you correctly that you’d be willing to buy some REALLY good atomizers for $5? And should I deliver only half of them, we can agree upfront that it's just a misunderstanding. :facepalm:
 

skish

Full Member
May 15, 2010
30
14
Left Coast (CA & WA)
Bob this is your Co Op not mine, I would have ran it a bit differently then you had and done some things differently then you did as far as buying and how I dealt with EM, so how about this, I bow out now too since you have said you are on your own deal, and just for kicks and giggle I have personally spent over 5k with eastmall in the last yr and No I didn't place an order for any Attys in the last 6 weeks because I knew there was issues from following the EM thread. I hope I have answered your questions, any further please direct them to EM as I no longer feel comfortable being in the middle of this transaction that isn't mine to begin with and was only trying to help.

What an absolute pathetic, arrogant, condescending and self-righteous comment...
 

trickstar

Full Member
Oct 6, 2010
7
0
Oz
I had to make 5 ridiculously short posts in order to add my voice to the unhappy customers in this thread ( I would be surprised if there weren't other lurkers who are in the same boat).

My experience was very similar; bad hardware (LR atties and a cone that does not fit), no communication, when finally they did get in contact I was more than a little bit dissappointed with the response. As customers we should not be paying for EMs research and development. I was resolved to just not purchase from them anymore (and still won't) but I couldn't not add my voice to the unsatisfied customers here. Unfortunately, the only real form of protest is to not buy EM. Frankly, I don't have the time to help them understand the nature of good business.
 

mwa102464

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Oct 14, 2009
14,447
12,564
Outside of the Philadelphia Burbs, NJ & Fla
What an absolute pathetic, arrogant, condescending and self-righteous comment...

And I think it was an absolute pathetic,arrogant,condescending, and self-righteous comment that the leader of the purchase bowed out before I said what I did and its why I said what I did Skish, read the post before where BoB says he bails out. Funny ya know it seems nobody could get anything done and I jumped right on Skype, got to the man, and told him the situation and he tells me, NO PROBLEM I WILL REPLACE THEM ALL FOR BoB, with in minutes I got it done yet you guys couldn't, wouldn't,and refuse to accept that fact that I was only trying to help and did and got it done in less then 5 minutes. The biggest part I will say again in an international business transaction is communication when making a deal, seems I know how to do this and get an international business deal done now doesn't it. It's actually quite simple for me, so for all the ney Sayers and complainers after being attacked once more I stick to my statement now after getting it done but people not accepting that fact I bow out now its not my deal and I was only trying to help you all out and got nothing but even more complaints from a certain few, however I did get some very nice PM's by someone in the group thanking me for helping out and to those people I say your welcome and if you ever need anything PM me as for the attackers don't
 
What you got done was CLAIM to have David email me which in fact was an email from Selina, simply suggesting I, I assume at my own expense, send them back. SO what exactly is David replacing them with? In those five minutes you guys were able to determine the problem, correct it, and have some made to specs?

You state that you would have ran the co op differently than I did. I assume from your comments that you would have charged $5 an atty. You have absolutely no idea how I ran this co op. You have absolutely no idea the communication I have had with EM.

At best you could be considered a "supplier associate" and at worst with your comment as to the amount of money you claim to have spent, and that you would sell them for $5 a supplier.

I'll say this, you're walking a fine line here with your comments. For one, sure anyone can look at the list of the members in the co op, that isn't the exact list. Some members dropped out and others were added, only I and ECF have that list. Secondly, this co op as well as any other was moderator approved and may have several that participated in it.

Lastly, maybe you have been in contact with someone within the group, and that's fine. 90% of them I know on a personal level and we are friends. When it's said and done if EM sends acceptable replacements on the 510LRs I will be lucky to break even. Probably not the way you would have ran it and that's fine. But I'll be darned if I'm going to ship these junk attys out to my friends and hide behind the disclaimer of "co ops are buyer beware" which I darn well could. I respect my friends enough not to do that and that is obviously one of the reasons they respect me.

Ironically no one from EM has weighed in here. Maybe you should just apply to be a supplier associate, seems you already are.

I am listing you in the co op thread at this time and I will ask anyone who is contacted by you to report such to a moderator. You're intentions are very unclear at this point after your statement about selling them for $5 and your obvious association with David.
 

bassthumper

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 4, 2010
684
153
42
TN
I m thoroughly disgusted with EM at this point. Over a month ago I received a batch of 510LRs that varied in resistance very badly. At that point I contacted CS and was told many things other than the truth. I was told my meter was bad. I was told that they had not changed the attys.

Of the 60% that were within specifications the attys themselves lasted about 3 days on average.

I had a co op buy scheduled to take place at that time as well. I went ahead and placed that order on Oct. 1st. I received that order today. Between my 1st contacting EM and now, more problems have arisen, and finally been acknowledged.

The problem is in trying to correct the problem it seems it's is worse. Now only 30% of the attys are within tolerance, and some are as high as 5.5 ohms. It is also obvious by the brass, the holes, the packaging, even down the cellophane wrappers that there has been a complete change in these attys. That change is from of from one of, if not the best preforming 510LR attys on the market, to something worthless.

I will also mention that the cup and bridge depth varies 1/4 inch or more. It's as if they weren't pressed in all the way. I will be taking pictures as well as calibration readings on this.

I have saved every correspondence with every one involved. Even though co ops are buyer beware I feel obligated to try to correct this issue, and I feel as though EM has that same obligation. They were given that opportunity both before, and it was brought to their attention during the order process. Now we will see if plan to correct it after the order, and how exactly they plan on doing that, since it seems they are unable to produce a satisfactory 510 LR atty at this point.

boB
thought you were done with ECF too!?
Isaw you on that "otherforum" whining about how sick you areof everyone here and how you're "done" with ECF.
so, why are here?:facepalm:
 
thought you were done with ECF too!?
Isaw you on that "otherforum" whining about how sick you areof everyone here and how you're "done" with ECF.
so, why are here?:facepalm:

I will not respond to this off topic stuff here other than to say my comments "there" are open to view and not what you claim. Please share your experience with EM and possible solutions and not your stalking experiences, thank you. boB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread