Should ALL reviews be compared to the Provari?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Pinggolfer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 28, 2013
6,890
18,792
The Clemson Tigers State
So the man who hasn't tried a Provari believes all those who do not believe the Provari is the best option for everyone to be haters. Looks like you made your mind up before you posted your question.

You have been anti Provari no matter how you try to appear neutral. Is it the Made in the USA which bothers you the most?
 

Jonathan Tittle

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Sep 7, 2013
1,608
1,003
40
Johnson City, TN, USA
xanderjuice.com
Total BS. So I can't say that a ProVari is better than an MVP2, even though I have owned both, just because the MVP2 has VW? Whatever.

You're free to state your opinion, of course. I don't think anyone is telling you otherwise :).

That being said, if you want to compare mods, compare them by category. To do otherwise is one-sided and shows bias. I don't call it fan-boy, just bias. I have plenty of products I love and show my support for, but I don't get upset if someone else doesn't share my views and doesn't immediately convert. If they don't like it, they don't like it and I'm not going to argue with them as everyone has their own style, taste etc.

For me, the Provari (and all mods where you have to buy multiple tubes separately) are not my cup of tea. I don't care who makes them or how much they cost. Telescoping mods or mods that come with the tubes already are what works for me. If I'm going to spend that much on a mod (i.e. $170-$250), this should be standard. That's not a knock on just the Provari, but *all* mods that fall into that category.

As far as mods go, VV/VW and VV are two different beasts and comparing a mod that is VV-Only to a VV/VW is like comparing performance on a VV/VW to that of a Mechanical. There is no comparison. A VV/VW or VV-Only isn't going to sub-ohm (short of the DNA20 based mods) just as a mech isn't going to give good performance on high-ohm builds (without a kick) because you're running off pure battery voltage.


I honestly think the bickering and arguing over such trivial matters should just stop altogether, but it doesn't seem like they ever will. For me, I don't care who makes it or where it comes from. If it works, it works. Sure, I'd rather support and American company, but if they don't offer what *I* personally want, I'm not going to spend my hard-earned cash on something I won't use.
 

JohnDaddyo

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 6, 2013
312
245
72
Tampa Bay
Is it my fault that I do not see the same level of overwhelming support and agreement for other devices? That is what I base my decision on. You cannot claim this as the number 1 forum and then bash the majority opinions. Obviously, you can. But the 'come backs' I read are more like envy or jealousy and hate, simply to go against the majority. NOT saying everyone. But when someone feels the need to combat a 'like' post with five or six negatives, it 'toned' pure envy to me. Like someone saying, I hate all this praise about Provari!! It read angry to me. More like, OH yea?? Well I'll show ya!! :(
I would guess that NOT the majority of Provari haters but, a shameful percentage hate Provari because it's made in the USA.
Sad. Very sad.

peace?
 

generic mutant

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
1,548
2,052
UK
You have been anti Provari no matter how you try to appear neutral. Is it the Made in the USA which bothers you the most?

I can't speak for Ref, but I have a few brilliant American mods. I have nothing against American made things whatsoever.

I do have something against rabid zealots, for whom the answer to everything is "This thing what I like!"

Provaris have their place, and I considered buying one. Are they the best? It's a ridiculous question. Like what is the best form of motorised transport? A Ducati or a hovercraft?
 

Train2

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 11, 2013
12,273
36,193
CA, USA
The best reviews might compare comparable models, but also provide some kind of analysis of features against some kind of STANDARD.
For instance, it's interesting to say "the VAMO threads doesn't hold up as the ProVari's" - but it's even more useful to tell us the difference in materials, or to demonstrate the issue, or to test a few mods and give statistics.

That's something PBusardo TRIES to do - we get the "oh, this vapes great, and feels good in my hand" stuff - but at least we also get things like the oscilliscope tests, or the carto-puller tests. He's trying to provide FACTS to compare and it's helpful.
 

Train2

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 11, 2013
12,273
36,193
CA, USA
Oooh. I want a Ducatti Hovercraft!

I can't speak for Ref, but I have a few brilliant American mods. I have nothing against American made things whatsoever.

I do have something against rabid zealots, for whom the answer to everything is "This thing what I like!"

Provaris have their place, and I considered buying one. Are they the best? It's a ridiculous question. Like what is the best form of motorised transport? A Ducati or a hovercraft?
 

magman007

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 11, 2013
161
161
39
Sarasota, FL
To an extent, yes.

The Provari is like a bmw m3. Maybe at times it can be outclassed by rival products in certain aspects, but it seems to just do everything well, and enough so that its the bench mark for performance within the industry. While others will strive to beat it, its possible to get tunnel vision when designing a product and fall short on another element of design.

If you're comparing a lower price product with similar performance (lets say new 5.0 mustang to bmw m3) then yes, it should be compared, but you gotta point out what your money is getting you in each case. (mustang will be a lesser interior, and require more tallent to achieve the same levels of performance, MVP does not have replaceable batteries/different chipset etc)

If the bench mark has been set, and competitors are trying to surpass that benchmark, its a good thing, as only better and better devices will be created. If a device truly outclasses the provari in so many ways, then lets face it, everyone will compare everything to it. Provari has the top spot right now, but the competition is fierce, we will have to see what comes along that can match the build quality, reliability, and serviceability of the provari.
 

cadman

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2009
440
1,727
Oklahoma
Great replies! I'm sorry but, the one who says NO in all categories just seemed to hate that a lot of people like Provari. IMHO.I do not own a Provari but, will get one. I call BS as far as calling those who love a proven product Fanboys. That is obviously meant as an insult or, blow off, without considering the facts. BIG YES to compare devices in the same class. I'm sure there are many more reasons but, three huge reasons I hear folks saying is, 1. Customer Service, 2. Built like a tank, 3. Consistent vape.
I have not heard any praises about warranty and customer service with any other devices. Some may have their experiences but, That is not an overwhelming theme. Are you aware, can you believe, that a huge amount of people HATE let's say the Yankees (baseball and USA:blush:) because they of their accomplishments??? I'm talking 'mature' adults! I'll bet there are those who hate the fact Provari is made in the USA also. Just for that horrible reason.
There's a connection in there somewhere, however random!! :)

I'm sorry but, the one who says NO in all categories just seemed to hate that a lot of people like Provari. IMHO.

I own a Provari, in fact it is sitting on my desk with a Zap on it right now. I am able to realize that it has limitations and am not going to limit myself to one device.

I have not heard any praises about warranty and customer service with any other devices. Some may have their experiences but, That is not an overwhelming theme.

You should go to the REO forum, you will find all the praises that you want. Some people don't feel the need to interject their opinion/praises about a device in every thread.

I'll bet there are those who hate the fact Provari is made in the USA also.

I am sure the fact that Provari is made in the U.S.A. has very little to do with anything. A vaper should appreciate a quality device regardless of where it is made.
 

ppeeble

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 9, 2013
1,026
3,231
59
Poole UK
I own dozens different mods, eGo types, VV, VW and mechs.
At home i use the mechs and a dripper because i get excellent flavour and clouds.
Out and about i use my ProVari and a carto tank because it will not fail me.
Up the pub i take eGo's and clearomisers because i often get drunk and leave things in the bar.
I use my VTR and iclear 30's when in company to get a reaction !
I own two Vamo's which i mainly use for ohm checking because the ProVari is too much effort.
(Since i stopped smoking 14 months ago i have continued to spend the same money on e-cigs, hence a LOT of mods)

Each device has its place in my day to day vaping journey and i don't compare them to each other, i use them as appropriate.
I wouldn't pick any one of them over the other because i don't have to.
Off topic...
ProVari haters really perplex me. It's a well made, dependable device that doesn't pretend to be anything it's not. It really is strange to hate on a metal tube with some wires and bits of silicon in it. ProVari's do the job they were made to do and do it well.
I havn't been a fanboi of anything since Mott the Hoople split up i just recognise and appreciate a well made mod.
 

esse

Full Member
Dec 29, 2013
39
15
bay area, ca
Is it my fault that I do not see the same level of overwhelming support and agreement for other devices? That is what I base my decision on. You cannot claim this as the number 1 forum and then bash the majority opinions. Obviously, you can. But the 'come backs' I read are more like envy or jealousy and hate, simply to go against the majority. NOT saying everyone. But when someone feels the need to combat a 'like' post with five or six negatives, it 'toned' pure envy to me. Like someone saying, I hate all this praise about Provari!! It read angry to me. More like, OH yea?? Well I'll show ya!! :(
I would guess that NOT the majority of Provari haters but, a shameful percentage hate Provari because it's made in the USA.
Sad. Very sad.

peace?

seems you didnt understand what the posters were saying, and how really neutral their comments were.. They're saying 'no' because the provari is not:
1. a mechanical
2. a device that can be used with sub ohm coils
3. a small device
4. a device that offers vw

i think that's pretty neutral. additionally, isn't made in the usa typically read as a positive thing around here?
 

dr g

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 12, 2012
3,554
2,406
Paradise
when going into variable wattage territory, you have to also start factoring in other VW devices such as the duke.

is the provari capable of providing a 50 watt vape?

you reach different types of consistency between VV and VW, and some people prefer 1 or the other.

The duke isn't vw ...

Regarding the OP, it's pretty obvious the answer is no. Whether you want to hear that or not.
 
Last edited:

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
I personally believe APV's or mods should be compared by their category: tube mods, box mods, bottom feeders, etc. They should also be further compared by regulated (VV/VW) and un-regulated. Otherwise, you are comparing apples to oranges.

Criteria such as features, build quality, attention to detail, aesthetics and function design, performance via bench testing, subjective value vs cost, warranty length, and a manufacturer's customer service/repairability availability should then be compared among their group category.

PBusardo, IMHO, does the best and most in-depth reviews.

Thank you!

Would not hurt for Discussions that have Sub-forums to be held in those forums either. Per ECF Posting suggestions. We can pick the wrong place. Often the Mods will move them to the proper location.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread