The HoneyvilleVapor RY4 I purchased for review is all-PG, 24mg nic strength, and light-orange in color. It was tested by dripping into a Joye 1.5 ohm LR atty powered by a Hello 016 battery running at 4.0 volts to produce 10 watts.
HoneyvilleVapor RY4 is a perfectly serviceable entry in the RY4 field. Of course, "serviceable" doesn't get an RY4 very far on this list. The competition is too strong.
One great thing about RY4s is that when they're good, they're often very, very good, and sometimes even superlative, but when they're bad, they're still usually pretty decent. I've found only a couple of RY4s that taste so weird that I can't or won't vape them. Honeyville RY4 is definitely vapable.
The tobacco is foremost here, followed by the caramel, with the vanilla more hinted at than stated. The overall taste is a little sweeter than average. That would be fine if I liked the tobacco, but that's where I run into a problem. I don't know for sure what tobacco base Honeyvville uses, but I'd bet that it's FlavourArt. Many vendors use FA tobacco flavorings, FSUSA being a prominent example. I own many of FlavourArt's extensive line of tobacco concentrates, but they sit unused in my DIY cabinet, since they all share a "signature" FA tobacco side-taste. Unfortunately, that FlavourArt signature was never a taste I liked much, and now, as more vendors use natural tobacco extracts to create wonderful tobacco juices, the synthetic artificiality of FA leaps out at me more strongly (and unpleasantly). Whatever the source, the odd tobacco flavor in HV RY4 is a little hard for me to get past.
I'd like this juice better if the caramel were more prominent, the vanilla richer, and the tobacco more subtle, because "hiding" that second-rate tobacco side-flavor would improve the blend for me. Oh well, that's not my call.
My call is to rate HV RY4 in my Personal Rankings, and the lack of a good tobacco base condemns it to #26, just above Halo Tribeca, another juice with a signature flavor I find less than wonderful.
The other thing to be said about HoneyvilleVapor---this time in praise---is that they've run at least two incredible sales, one when their site began, and another recently, offering 5ml bottles of liquid for 39¢! I bought 40mls of Honeyville's RY4 for about $4 shipped, which is darn near unbelievable. Now if I can only find someone to take it off my hands
(I will, however, keep my 40mls of their Caramel Macchiato---which is wonderful.)
So, in closing, Honeyville is a great vendor with some good liquids, but a not-so-terrific RY4, at least to my picky palate. As always, YMMV.