I thought I gave a pretty fair description and comparison. Commie also has had both and gave an honest opinion. Wabbit has both and described his/her(?) use for each. Doots has owned both and gave an honest opinion. WattWick might not have either, but rightly pointed out that the advertizing on the side is something a lot of folks don't appreciate on any device. _more_ has had both... etc etc.
As far as these threads go, I think this one has been more civil than the rest.
I have to say, I believe that this particular thread doesn't deserve such a harsh assessment. And, in fact, the majority of participants are generally helpful folks.
You are right 6. Many of the responses on this thread were not offensive nor rude and my comment was conceived as being too harsh. Apparently my use of the peace sign did not help convey my message in a more fun playful manner as I had hoped.