That's a lie.
Along with sensationalized dollar amounts that, when taken as a whole, aren't as bad as they'd have you believe.
Read my later posts as well. The whole "Smokers are a drain on the economy" lie is getting old.
I read your initial post and I don't see it as a lie.
According to the CDC the direct costs of medical care for smokers is 170 billion dollars annually.
Your going on that alone but lost production is important too.. lost wages due to illness is made up through various welfare programs, especially long term illness... although even ignoring that, what is taken in through tobacco taxes is not half of the direct care costs.
The CDC cites what states are taking in as just over 27 million, and while they don't state what the federal government is taking in, I'd say we can safely double what they took in in 2010 which was 15.5 billion.. that's just the last i saw an actual dollar amount anyway..
That gives us a rough intake of 60 billion where the outgoing is more than double, nearly triple that.
The problem with the government is that this is a problem when they rely on that revenue to cover (some) Medicare and Medicaid costs.. if everyone quits smoking they will not have those revenues to cover the first 10 years of everyone being quit and many still needing medical care.
Does this describe our nation's debt and problems over health care expenditure going out that we cannot afford... absolutely not. Smokers at most are 16% of the population and not all of them come down with smoking related illness.
Our healthcare crisis in this country is the fact our government is forking out trillions in end of life care (the last 6 months of life is where most healthcare cost is)... but that's a whole 'nother story.
However, just because that is happening and a problem doesn't mean that there isn't cost involved for smokers, nor does it mean it's a cost the government feels able to shoulder. We can't really, we can't shoulder all of this as a nation.
I can understand the some the government wants to take in, but they have to be able to realize that at some point they will necessarily stop taking those revenues in, and that it's a good thing in the long run.
The problem is that our government is in the now business and isn't looking toward the future.