Would these be legal ecigs?

[v1John]

If NY and then everyone bans electronic cigarettes, what would happen if the manufacturers started putting a real leaf of tobacco inside the cartos and cartridges? Would that make them legal?

For example, the ban does not ban tobacco cigarettes, so couldn't I simply buy a carto or cartridge with one tobacco leaf inside of it? If they ban it then because it wouldn't produce monoxide and over 50 carcinogens, they could always be sold attached to a super mini short hollow battery case about one inch long, which is where people would light it up from. Of course, once home, we are free to remove the leaf and the hollow tube attached to the carto, if we we chose not to inhale combustible monoxide and carcinogens.

Basically this would have to force ecigs to be classified as government protected tobacco products, because they would really be tobacco products, wouldn't it?

 

[the86d]

What about how much these would be taxed?

 

[BongoBob]

or just fill blank cartridges with tobacco leaves and have the seller distribute filler in the package..

 

[v1John]

I didn't think about tax. I guess there may be a $7 tax per 20. So if I bought 2, the tax would be 70 cents?

(wishful thinking perhaps)

At least they would be legal, they would really literally contain one leaf of tobacco in them, and lawmakers and the FDA would be able to literally put a lighter on the end of the tube and breathe it.

Only the vapers would know how to mod them easily after legal purchase.

 

[v1John]

or just fill blank cartridges with tobacco leaves and have the seller distribute filler in the package..

Yes, but I use cartos, please help me with a carto solution too. I wouldn't mind buying a carto that has a leaf rolled up in the wind tunnel. The FDA would be able to smoke it and I would be able to mod it.

 

[the86d]

It WOULD be a tobacco product...

 

[BradSmith]

What about how much these would be taxed?

Loose tobaco is taxed by the pound so it would be very little.

 

[v1John]

Someone who vapes please patent this immediately!!
What if it saves us vapers ?!?!


(just half-joking; but the fact is that they would instantly fall under the widely protected tobacco products, all drug device bans would be rendered trash)

 

[the86d]

Maybe the best idea yet!

 

[E_Michael]

I heard about the ban and I think your idea is fantastic. Actually that would put the e cigarettes under the tobacco law, right?

 

[v1John]

I heard about the ban and I think your idea is fantastic. Actually that would put the e cigarettes under the tobacco law, right?

Exactly, which is what ECF or CASAA or many vapers wanted, if I remember correctly (iirc). (To be classified as tobacco products)

 

[BuzzKill]

fill it with HERBS and call it a personal Herbal vaporizer , problem solved .
No tobacco , No E-cig , No Law

remember it's NOT a .... it is a Water Pipe !

 

[me who]

If NY and then everyone bans electronic cigarettes, what would happen if the manufacturers started putting a real leaf of tobacco inside the cartos and cartridges? Would that make them legal?

Oh like the mini rose in the glass tube sold at many gas stations. Hmm, could work.

 

[v1John]

hahahaha

sort of exactly, yes, but If we need them to be tobacco products, well...there you have it

 

[Israfil]

What? but....i buy these for the rose inside..... are you trying to tell me the rose isnt for putting in my hair?

 

[jeanblackwood]

If NY and then everyone bans electronic cigarettes, what would happen if the manufacturers started putting a real leaf of tobacco inside the cartos and cartridges? Would that make them legal?

For example, the ban does not ban tobacco cigarettes, so couldn't I simply buy a carto or cartridge with one tobacco leaf inside of it? If they ban it then because it wouldn't produce monoxide and over 50 carcinogens, they could always be sold attached to a super mini short hollow battery case about one inch long, which is where people would light it up from. Of course, once home, we are free to remove the leaf and the hollow tube attached to the carto, if we we chose not to inhale combustible monoxide and carcinogens.

Basically this would have to force ecigs to be classified as government protected tobacco products, because they would really be tobacco products, wouldn't it?

But then you have to wonder if they would be subject to the same regulations and taxes , which is the main reason why I switched . I couldn't afford cigarettes any more .

 

[v1John]

What? but....i buy these for the rose inside..... are you trying to tell me the rose isnt for putting in my hair?

Well, in the event of an emergency, you probably could.

 

[Vapour~Girl]

Well, in the event of an emergency, you probably could.

ignorant and english xD what the heckity is that?

 

[v1John]

ignorant and english xD what the heckity is that?

The flower? ..or which one?

 

[voltaire]

ignorant and english xD what the heckity is that?

The glass vial that holds the flower that is commonly sold in convenience stores (mostly in the wrong parts of town) is used by crack addicts as a pipe. The same stores also seem to sell a lot of single pieces of steel wool/mesh also used for this nefarious purpose.