...
I’ll start, I rely solely on my diy, which I rate as good or better than commercial. I haven’t mastered cloning every juice I’d like to, but I’m confident I could, in time.
You could probably Count on One Hand the number of bottles of retail e-Liquids I have bought in the last 7 Years. And those were just because I was in a B&M and I wanted them to give me DIY Ideas.
I would place my DIY e-Liquids against Any Retail e-Liquid.
As to making Clones of Complex Retail e-Liquids...
Well, that can be a Trial in Patience and Perseverance. And can get down to just How Close you want a Clone to be.
If you want something in the Ballpark, that can usually be done Relatively quickly. If you are Not Satisfied with close, and has to be almost Identical, that can take Time. And Many (Many) Workups.
But if you Quest is for a Perfect, Can't Tell the Difference in a Blind Taste Test, Perfect 1-to-1 Clone, that can be Hard. Very Hard. And it can Test your Will and Determination.
Here is something I posted awhile back about embarking on an Exact 1-to-1 Clone Odyssey ...
When I switched to e-Cigarettes, I was lucky to find an ADV pretty much right off the start. Tasty Vapor's TastyFinger.
And since I was kinda into DIY already, by adding Flavorings or Sweetener to make Retail e-Liquids Stronger and or Sweeter, I decided to Clone TastyFinger. I mean... How Hard could it possibly Be?
LOL.
I spend 1/2 of 2010 and most of 2011 doing Dozens and Dozens and Dozens (and Dozens) of work-ups. It was Maddening. And became a Borderline Compulsion. I had full box of 3-x-5 Cards with Recipes and Cryptic Batch Codes like 17F or 21AB written on Blue Painters Tape on too many 30ml Glass Bottles to count.
I would get Soooo Cloooose at times. So Very Agonizingly Close. Only to Add or Subtract a Flavoring or Change a Percentage which would then push it away from where it should be.
I Finally Got It. It was a Absolute 1:1 Clone. And a Very Complex Multi-Flavor Recipe.
My Advise is if you want to Clone a Complex Retail e-Liquid is to have Realistic Goals. Because you might be able to get it Close relatively quickly. But going the Last Mile can be Murder.
BTW - Even if I told someone the Individual Flavors needed to Clone TastyFinger (which I won't), without their respective Percentages, you would only be about 40% Closer to making it.
The Percentages are what can make the Last Mile so Tough.
Reverse Engineering a commercial E-Liquid