Hey guys, after dipping in and out over the last few weeks I've finally finished reading through this entire thread and tried to note down just about every tobacco that got a favourable mention. I'm sure there are some I've missed (or misquoted) but I hope you don't mind me posting the list as I'm thinking it might help others on here if they want a quick overview:
American Patriot (Missouri Meerschaum)
American Spirit Perique ( This surprised the hell out of me. Truly exceptional. )
American Spirit pouch tobacco.
Ashton Artisan
basma leafs from ebay
CAO Eileen's Dream
CAO Moontrance
Cornell & Diehl "Bayou Night"
Cornell & Diehl "Billy Bud"
Cornell & Diehl "Mississippi Mud"
Cornell & Diehl "Old Joe Krantz"
Cornell & Diehl "Orion's Arrow"
Cornell & Diehl "Sunset Harbor Flake" -(moderate flavor, requires aging)
Cornell & Diehl "Super Balkan"
Cornell & Diehl Autumn Evening
Cornell & Diehl Habana Daydream #420
Cornell & Diehl Izmir Turkish
Cornell & Diehl Pennington Gap
Cornell & Diehl: Haunted Bookshop
Daughters & Ryan "Picayune"
Davidoff Flake Medallions
Diesel Delirium
Dominican Glory Maduro
Drew Estate Acid Cold Infusion
Drew Estates "Acid Blondie" (for it's spicy cigar taste)
Drew Estates 7th Avenue Blonde
Drew Estates ACID "Opulence 3"
Dunhill "Elizabethan Mixture" -(moderate to robust, grassy hay-like note)
Dunhill "Nightcap"
Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls
Dunhill Flake
Dunhill Standard Mixture
Erin Go Bragh - Irish Whiskey
Frog Morton on the Bayou
Gawith & Hoggarth - Brown Flake *unscented (virginia, malawi burley)
Gawith and Hoggarth "Brown Irish X unsliced" -(robust but not very complex)
Gawith Hoggarth's 'Kentucky Nougat' (Black Cav./Gold Virg. wiv toffee/cocoa toppings) Really nice aromatic.
GL Pease "Cumberland" -(moderate to robust, requires aging)
GL Pease JackKnife
Havana (w/leaf)
Hearth & Home Signature "Virginia Spice" -(a little grassy with cigar and vanilla notes)
Hearth and Home "Louisiana Red" (Virginia & Perique)
HPCS Trout Stream - sweet and mild. Cavendish Blend with Butterscotch top note. I am really enjoying this one.
Lane 1-Q
Mac Baren - Vanilla Cream
Mac Baren 'Old Dark Fired'
Man O'War Phalanx
McClelland Old Dog
Milan Tobacconists "Centenary"
Milan Tobacconists "French Vanilla"
Muwat KFC
Orlik Golden Sliced
Peter Stokkebye - English Oriental
Peter Stokkebye - Luxury Navy Flake - (virginia, perique)
Peter Stokkebye - Sweet Vanilla
Peter Stokkebye 84 Turkish - more Virginia than Oriental, still smooth tobacco flavor.
PS Luxury Bulls Eye Flake
Rattray's - Red Rapparee (virginia, oriental, black cav and latakia)
Rattray's 'Dark Fragrant' (Black Cav./Perique)
Red Virg. (w/leaf)
Rocky Patel "2008 Autumn Reserve"
Rocky Patel "Vintage '90" cigar -(Light to Moderate flavor, best cigar I've found so far)
Samuel Gawith Balkan Flake
Samuel Gawith Brown Rope No. 4 Rum
Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake
Samuel Gawith Navy Flake
Scotty's Bulk Blends ; Honey & Chocolate
Seattle Pipe Club "Mississippi River" (compliments to boomerdude)
semi oriental from leafonly
Smooth Virg./Aged Burley mix (from wholeleaf)
Smyrna
SPC Mississippi River
St. James Flake Pipe Tobacco
Standard Tob. Bengal Slices
Sutliff "Voodoo Queen" -(moderate flavor, requires significant aging)
Sutliff Chocolate Mousse
Sutliff Private stock "Charlemagne"
Sutliff Private Stock "Molto Dolce" -(aromatic flavored tobacco, best enjoyed fresh, changes with age)
Sutliff's "Charlemagne"
The Smoker "St. James" (difficult to obtain)
Titiana "Vanilla" cigar
Tsuge "Ryujin" (for it's heavy Latakia and Arcadian Black flavors)
Two Friends Valle
yenidje from leafonly
I hope the list helps but let me know if you think this post is excessive and I'll happily delete it...