6v is not the answer HIGH DRAIN CELLS is the answer!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

asidrave

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 21, 2009
1,358
151
New Jersey
these batteries are also high discharge

18650

DealExtreme: $7.97 TrustFire Protected 18650 Lithium Battery (2400mAh 2-Pack Gray)

14500

DealExtreme: $4.73 TrustFire Protected 14500 3.7V 900mAh Lithium Batteries (2-Pack Blue)

i have these 18650's also and they do produce a bit more vapor than these

DealExtreme: $14.40 UltraFire Protected 18650 3.7V 3000mAh Lithium Batteries (2-Pack)

i have both types of 18650's and i can tell the difference

im gonna order the 14500's from the second link and hopefully they also work better
 

Quick1

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 11, 2010
2,684
280
USA
I think those batteries are maybe 2C?

The discharge rate is the (max) current the batteries are designed to handle. 1C is the current that will drain the battery in 1 hour. For example if you have a 900mAh battery it will go from charged to drained in 1 hour supplying a current of 900mA. If it is rated at 2C it can (should be able to) supply a current of 1800mA for 1/2 hour without damage or blowing up.

The red batteries are high discharge batteries and rated at 10C. You should be able to drain one of those at 10 x the listed mAh in 6 minutes! without damage or explosion.

I think... at least that's my understanding.
 
Last edited:

DaMulta

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 18, 2009
2,300
11
45
T-Town Oklahoma
these batteries are also high discharge

18650

DealExtreme: $7.97 TrustFire Protected 18650 Lithium Battery (2400mAh 2-Pack Gray)

14500

DealExtreme: $4.73 TrustFire Protected 14500 3.7V 900mAh Lithium Batteries (2-Pack Blue)

i have these 18650's also and they do produce a bit more vapor than these

DealExtreme: $14.40 UltraFire Protected 18650 3.7V 3000mAh Lithium Batteries (2-Pack)

i have both types of 18650's and i can tell the difference

im gonna order the 14500's from the second link and hopefully they also work better

No, those are not high discharge rate batteries. I sent out a message with a company to see if they will give the C rating for the batteries.
 

Quick1

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 11, 2010
2,684
280
USA
What I'm having difficulty with is this. It's my understanding that a device will draw whatever current it operates at, or is able to draw if the supply is limited to less than that.

With a protected battery the pcb (should) disconnect the battery if the device trys to draw a current more than the limit. With unprotected batteries the discharge rate is not limited and the device will draw whatever current it operates at (determined by voltage and resistance).

So... as long as the battery doesn't explode, I would not expect a difference in performance between unprotected batteries. High discharge or not. With protected batteries the difference would be binary. Either they work and perform equally or the pcb disconnects.
 

DaMulta

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 18, 2009
2,300
11
45
T-Town Oklahoma
I think you can still strain the battery making the voltage drop without tripping the PCB safely. There is a limit on how hard you can stress them in the end tho.

I video that showed what they were doing under-load with a meter would be better than comparing vapor. I don't know where my atty load tester I made is. Other wise I would go test that right now.
 

DaMulta

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 18, 2009
2,300
11
45
T-Town Oklahoma

Elf

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 11, 2009
84
4
California
Very interesting video, thank you for posting. I can tell you from experience in other applications that high-drain batteries can indeed make a world of difference.

I do want to point out though for clarification that I believe the reference in the video to LiPo technology is incorrect. The standard 18650 batteries are Li-Ion batteries (short for lithium-ion), whereas LiPo batteries (short for Lithium-Polymer) are a different technology. I do not know of any LiPo batteries that look like regular cells such as this.

LiPo batteries are used in specialty applications such as RC hobbies, as well as (for instance) the new Apple laptops (internal non-user-replaceable battery models). LiPo batteries typically sport a much higher discharge rate than Li-Ion (I have some that are rated for a whopping 30C *continuous* drain), and are shapable in production. They are also much more volatile than even the Li-Ion batteries, so its a good thing we dont use them for PV devices.

The results of using high-discharge rate batteries, as pointed out in the video, look very impressive. Since I have really been enjoying the dual 3v cells, I think I might have to try the high discharge cells myself. :)
 

USinchains

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 15, 2009
995
440
49
The Terrordrome, FL
www.myspace.com
I think he might have been referring to LiFePO4 batteries and pronouncing the acronym as LiPo or lifepo. True, the gray Trustfire 18650 is Li-ion.
Very interesting video, thank you for posting. I can tell you from experience in other applications that high-drain batteries can indeed make a world of difference.
I do want to point out though for clarification that I believe the reference in the video to LiPo technology is incorrect. The standard 18650 batteries are Li-Ion batteries (short for lithium-ion), whereas LiPo batteries (short for Lithium-Polymer) are a different technology. I do not know of any LiPo batteries that look like regular cells such as this.

LiPo batteries are used in specialty applications such as RC hobbies, as well as (for instance) the new Apple laptops (internal non-user-replaceable battery models). LiPo batteries typically sport a much higher discharge rate than Li-Ion (I have some that are rated for a whopping 30C *continuous* drain), and are shapable in production. They are also much more volatile than even the Li-Ion batteries, so its a good thing we dont use them for PV devices.

The results of using high-discharge rate batteries, as pointed out in the video, look very impressive. Since I have really been enjoying the dual 3v cells, I think I might have to try the high discharge cells myself. :)
 

Elf

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 11, 2009
84
4
California
No he is right :p I called the Li-ion battery Li-Po

O well the point got across:rolleyes:

I do call the lifep04 a Life-Po without the 4 at times I admit.

The point got across indeed! My apologies if my comments came across sounding critical. To be clear - you produced a great video and my comment was not meant as criticism of any kind. Being rather familiar with LiPo batteries however, I thought it might be important to clarify the difference for any people who otherwise might unknowingly do something extremely dangerous in the quest for a better battery..(like trying to hook their PV up to a *real* LiPo!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread