OK Gthomp and Dante, time to buck up here. I need another juice vendor.
Honestly, I haven't tried a whole ton of the different juice vendors, and most of the ones I've tried I wouldn't recommend, so I might not be the best person to ask. I had a go to vendor I used for a long time, bought the vast majority of my juice from them. They had several juices I really liked, including the ONLY menthol I ever liked, but then the quality went straight to hell. Some months ago it got to the point that every time I ordered from them it seemed like they had changed the recipe (again!), which at best ranged from not as good as I had gotten used to, to downright nasty. I'd rather not mention the name. The past few months I've been on my own search for juice.
AVE is one I'd recommend. Boba's Bounty is a must try (although it needs AT LEAST a full week steeping, and more is better, sorry).
Pink Spot also gets a thumbs up, but they're one of the more pricy out there. I pretty much only buy Swagger now because of that, and I treat it like liquid gold. If I spill a drop on the floor I lick it up (just kidding.... or am I?).
And of course HHV, but you already knew that.
I wish I could recommend NiteLiteVapor. They have quite the cult following. Their Bounty Hunter came in third I think in the juice of the year last year. People just rave about them. Unfortunately, I've never managed to get hold of any. They only take orders once or twice a month and only accept a certain number of orders when they do. And now their CC processor has dropped them, and they're scrambling to find a way to take orders at all. I really want to try them, but such is life.
There's quite a few I see mentioned and highly recommended that I sometimes feel like I should try, but that are mostly famous for deserty/fruity flavors. Most of them have a tobacco line, but I don't see anyone really plugging that part of their line, and reading the description on the website usually sounds like "oh yeah, we also carry this tobacco flavored stuff". I like my tobacco flavors. I do like a change of pace sometimes, and I've tried some of the "other stuff" that's pretty good, but I've yet to find a non-tobacco that I can vape for more than a few minutes at a time.