I made a change in the Benedict Cumbermint (which is probably the same as Cucumber Benedict) from the original as posted by EdibleMalfunction on Reddit.
Benedict Cumberbatch by Edible Malfunction on Reddit
- FA Arctic Winter (Menthol) 1% ( I used 10% Menthol Solution at 1%)
- CAP Cucumber 6%
- TFA Koolada 0.5% (I used .5% WS-23)
- FA Lime Tahity (Cold-Pressed) 1.5%
I just tried it in my tester and it is refreshing. I will have to try a tank to see if I could happily vape it or not. The jury is out but it is not disgusting.

Lime with cucumber is a natural!
Cool as a DewCumber by Horsegame on ELR
- Cucumber Mint (FW) 3%
- Honeydew Melon (JF) 5%
- Pear (FA) 1.5%
- WS-23 30% .75%
This is nice in my tester and definitely has possibilities. I also changed the original recipe a bit. His called for 2% Koolada and I went with .75% WS-23. He also has some peppermint in his recipe and I don't like peppermint in a vape, so left it out. If you like peppermint, he used .25%. I like the addition of the melon and the pear.
Sweet Summer Chilled by TheExiledTheory on ELR
- Cactus (INAWERA) .25%
- Honeydew Melon (JF) 2%
- Kiwi (FA) 4%
- Lemon Juicy (JF) .15% (I thought it needed more lemon so used 1% FE Lemon)
- Pear (FA) .50%
- WS-23 .75%
This is very nice and refreshing. After I vape a tank I will report further. So far, so good! The melon and the kiwi go well together, and the pear gives it a little extra something.
Fizzy Backwoods Lemonade (based on Backwoods Lemonade by EdibleMalfunction on ATF
- 10% Menthol 1%
- Forest Mix (Forest Fruit) (FA) 3%
- Lemon Sicily (FA) .75%
- Lemonade (LA) 6%
- Pink Champagne (FW) 2%
- WS-23 30% .75%
As
@IDJoel has said about Forest Fruit, it has a darker berry flavor with blackberry, boysenberry, maybe black currant, along with blueberry, some raspberry, and some strawberry. It gives the lemonade a more robust flavor. Personally, I like my original Fizzy Pink Lemonade (based on Vurve's Best Damned Pink Lemonade) better. It is lighter in flavor, more summery to me, and takes to the fizzy properties of the Pink Champagne better. Many people love the Backwoods Lemonade (also based on Vurve's Pink but with Forest Fruit and no additional berries, so it might be better to a lot of you.
Ruby Red by Wayne on ATF
- Cactus (INAWERA) .5%
- Dragonfruit (TPA) .5%
- Grapefruit (CAP) 7%
- Super Sweet (CAP) .25%
- White Grapefruit (INAWERA) .50%
This is good but I felt I could benefit from some coolant and some fizz, so I did this:
Fizzy Ruby Red
- Cactus (INAWERA) .25%
- Dragonfruit (TPA) .50%
- Grapefruit (CAP) 7%
- Soda Base (SC) (Real Flavors) 2% (better at adding the perception of effervescent to grapefruit flavors than the champagnes, which tend to react oddly with grapefruit)
- SugarDaddy Sweetener
- White Grapefruit (INAWERA) .50%
- WS-23 30% .75%
This is very good, IMO. It is cool and refreshing, had some fizz for those that like it. This is a keeper for me.