I'm not trying to hit anything magic for sure TB. Just some flavors that will work well, hopefully similar to something people are fond of. So far, it's a crap shoot. The rum flavoring wasnt bad, surely not lip smacking but it does follow a trend I see with the SnusX and and maybe all snus. Some flavors dont work well. Period.
Menthol , Spearmint and Peppermint so far do well. The Rum was ok, short lived, then dropped to a very light earthy taste. Easy to remember as it was a mild version on the Wintergreen test I did. You've seen the comments on commercial wintergreen snus. General I think some say is bitter and nasty as soon as the flavor starts to fade. The wintergreen test was like that from the git go yet I have and enjoy Thunder Wintergreen.
Apple did exactly the same thing. Earthy dirt taste, with no apple at all. A friend sent me some commercial apple flavor snus and claimed it had no apple flavor to her. Well, all I got was that familiar earthy dirt too.
I tried a very good apple flavoring I have and it tasted identical to the commercial apple snus she sent. It almost like you can add all you want, the snus "eats it" and makes it taste worse than an untouched portion.
Orange is aged enough for a test today.
I'm not seeing a lot of tester resuts posted. Failed tests show as much as good ones. No shame in it and its valuable and useful data.
As of now, people wanting cheaper snus, pre-Pact Act Tax storage volume will be ok if they like whats been posted that at a minimum of "works pretty well". Taste is probably the most subjective thing there is as you are well aware. If they don't like menthol, the mints, or I'll say an Ettan regular and a sweet portion from your "sweetness" tossed in, they are gonna be hard pressed to make it work until more test results are posted here.
I looked at various snus lists and they do appear limited in flavors. We might have found what they did, some flavors just dont work. Replicating one that is your favorite may not be easy to reproduce something even close. They have done this for many years and the flavor list is limited. As you said, what they have in flavors didnt come cheap.
Even SnusX offers few flavors.
I'm ok with them as I like menthol and the mints. More testing later.