Superiority of cartos over bottom wick tanks

Status
Not open for further replies.

Crash Moses

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 30, 2012
1,468
3,889
56
Lansing, Michigan
Fantastic blog.

I found you the perfect tank for Bobo.

62a4c2c5-f61f-3089.jpg

I like this one better.

 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
How about these tanks, Bad and Ocelot?

Sidewinder 7ml Pyrex Tank

VVV-7ml-tank4.jpgTriple_V_pyrex_1.JPGclear&frosted-tank-1.jpgFamily2.jpg

I don't have the Sidewinder, as I have never been a fan of side/top juice fill screw holes in tanks. It's purely a preference thing. Although I work in the medical field and am completely comfortable using a needle & syringe, using one is not my preference for filling my cartotanks with juice. I much prefer using a tank tool and sliding the carto down to fill it. Takes me the same amount of time.

I got a couple of Ray's first pyrex cartotanks when he began selling them just over a year ago, and did a review of them http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/tank-reviews/312709-valley-view-tanks-7ml-pyrex-tank-review.html.

Ray used the silicone grommets initially on all of his tanks. To fill these, you had to insert a needle into the silicone to add juice. After awhile this became tedious and the needle punctures eventually made the grommets look ratty. Eventually Ray offered the metal endcaps, and I replaced all the grommets with metal endcaps. This was a major improvement.

You can see one of my original grommet tanks in the first pic, and the same tank with the replacement metal caps in the second pic. Ray also offered frosted glass at one point (not sure if he still does); the third pic shows a clear and frosted tank.

These look nice on larger mods like a Silver Bullet, but can look rather top-heavy on a slimmer mod like my black BB. A couple of these tanks took a fall from a locker room bench onto a tile floor at work and shattered. I posted about this on ECF and Ray sent me a free tank to trial. (As always, thanks Ray.) He explained that he had recently switched his glass supplier to a new and different one. I did use the new tank. But since I rarely use the larger Silver Bullet anymore and am using smaller/slimmer mods now I rarely use the newer tank. It currently has some green Pluid in it which I pull out every once in awhile for something different to vape.
 
Last edited:

Susaz

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 8, 2009
4,857
10,701
Buenos Aires, Argentina
Discovered this today.

Probably old news to you experienced vapers, but I am still learning! At first I didn't like the cartos that came with my Provari. I wasn't getting good flavor and good clouds from them. So the one that I filled before, I left sitting for over a week. This morning I screwed it on the the Provari and tried it again, and to my surprise it was fantastic. I guess it needed time for the juice to be fully absorbed into the foam material inside the carto. It's actually a better vape/taste than the bottom-wicked tanks I've been using (Protank/Davide). Really good vape.

My new protocol is to begin filling a carto ahead of time, and leave it sitting next to the bottle I used to fill it for a few days. That way I know it will fully saturate, and I won't forget what flavor it contains.

I also ordered a glass "carto tank"... I assume the differences when this arrives will be that 1) the cartos will need holes in them, 2) juice will last a lot longer before refill. Looking forward to the next experience.

Any advice on this process appreciated.

It's so newbie to talk about superiority. Taste is subjective, you use what you like. When the first bad batch of cartos hit you, you'll think twice.

Always remember, the more filling/wicking material you have, the more propensity to burnt taste you'll have.
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
It's so newbie to talk about superiority. Taste is subjective, you use what you like. When the first bad batch of cartos hit you, you'll think twice.

Always remember, the more filling/wicking material you have, the more propensity to burnt taste you'll have.
The flip side of this coin is, the more filling/wicking material you have (cartomizers) surrounding the heating coil, the more flavor that you'll have. ;)
 

Susaz

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 8, 2009
4,857
10,701
Buenos Aires, Argentina
The flip side of this coin is, the more filling/wicking material you have (cartomizers) surrounding the heating coil, the more flavor that you'll have. ;)

Hummmm, no. Attys have very little wicking, and dripping is said to have the most flavor. Carto tank fans I respect but superior? No. Remember Bogegate...
 

Susaz

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 8, 2009
4,857
10,701
Buenos Aires, Argentina
Hey! I'm not about arguing with you... I'm just saying to each its own. I hold poor memories of cartos, flooded, dry, funny tasting. I prefer bottom coils each time, every time. Not to mention that you can't wash them and put a new flavor, that's if you want to repeatedly boil them... And carto tanks that slip and are messy to refill... No, I want to banish that chapter on vaping completely from my head.
 

Susaz

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 8, 2009
4,857
10,701
Buenos Aires, Argentina
But not easy to carry around either. With an 18650 battery installed Bobo weighs over half a pound.

That would be great for my wobbly living room table. My cats and my husband are going to crack my Protank or mess my SVD. I have to keep it upright in a coffee cup. And with the term on, it's a boom when it falls down...
 

Zogman100

Senior Member
Verified Member
Aug 1, 2013
71
110
Omaha, NE

soba1

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 27, 2013
2,257
1,949
65
Van Nuys Ca., USA
Hey! I'm not about arguing with you... I'm just saying to each its own. I hold poor memories of cartos, flooded, dry, funny tasting. I prefer bottom coils each time, every time. Not to mention that you can't wash them and put a new flavor, that's if you want to repeatedly boil them... And carto tanks that slip and are messy to refill... No, I want to banish that chapter on vaping completely from my head.

That is the one downside about cartos. Not wash and wear.....................
 

NICnurse

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 18, 2010
509
775
Kansas City, MO
It's so newbie to talk about superiority. Taste is subjective, you use what you like. When the first bad batch of cartos hit you, you'll think twice.

Always remember, the more filling/wicking material you have, the more propensity to burnt taste you'll have.

Sorry, maybe it is just how I am interpreting this, but I see response as insulting and rude! The OP is new to vaping. Cartos are working great for them. Can we be supportive and helpful rather than snarky? If you don't like cartos, move along and don't reply--it is very simple. Throwing around veteran status to diminish the experiences of a new vaper is deplorable. This is supposed to be a supportive community to help others.
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
Susaz said:
It's so newbie to talk about superiority. Taste is subjective, you use what you like. When the first bad batch of cartos hit you, you'll think twice.

Always remember, the more filling/wicking material you have, the more propensity to burnt taste you'll have.

Sorry, maybe it is just how I am interpreting this, but I see response as insulting and rude! The OP is new to vaping. Cartos are working great for them. Can we be supportive and helpful rather than snarky? If you don't like cartos, move along and don't reply--it is very simple. Throwing around veteran status to diminish the experiences of a new vaper is deplorable. This is supposed to be a supportive community to help others.
:thumb: This.

That's the only reason I posted my response to the above. Everyone will have a different experience with different battery devices and juice delivery devices, not to mention different juice flavors. You won't know which one(s) that you'll prefer unless you give each an equal opportunity and fair shot. Just because one person has had a bad experience with one or another does not mean everyone else will. We're fortunate that we have MANY CHOICES at our disposal.
 

retired1

Administrator
Admin
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 5, 2013
51,348
46,139
Texas

Susaz

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 8, 2009
4,857
10,701
Buenos Aires, Argentina
Sorry, maybe it is just how I am interpreting this, but I see response as insulting and rude! The OP is new to vaping. Cartos are working great for them. Can we be supportive and helpful rather than snarky? If you don't like cartos, move along and don't reply--it is very simple. Throwing around veteran status to diminish the experiences of a new vaper is deplorable. This is supposed to be a supportive community to help others.

Read the title of the thread. THAT's rude. So noob. Superiority is a punch to my guts, makes me feel that after 4 years of vaping I, and people like me, are ...... because we don't vape carto tanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread