The “Cola” Method Taken to Another Level That Works

Status
Not open for further replies.

surbitonPete

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 25, 2009
2,915
5
North Yorkshire UK
Pete--You are in the UK--If you are looking for a Commercial Vendor--How about trying some of this:

OKSmokey Shop Electronic Cigarettes Nicotine Cartridge Liquid Refill

Madisvapor reported trying it:

The write up reported by her was as follows for the product:
Received the cleanser today.
Opened the top and took a smell - smells exactly like a nail varnish

Came with a leaflet including instructions. So in short:

WARNING
Highly flammable
May cause drowsiness / dizziness
Keep away frm ignition
Wear eye protection?

Instructions (in short too)
Use a ceramic surface as a work surface (i.e plate)
Paper tissues to absorb spills
Drop 10-12drops into the battery end of the atomizer, with the battery part on top.
Stand mouth down on tissue paper and allow 2-3 mins to penetrate into coils
Shake the chamber (vapurizer) to expel as much cleanser as possible.
Repeat all steps again.
Allow vapourizer to dry by leaving for at least 1 hour in a ventilated area.
Vapourizer is now ready to use.
Note that it is now completely free of liquid and needs to be dripped on vapourizer before use.

I have taken all these steps on to my dead RN4081 and EVO atomizers and still waiting for them to dry completely. So will try later.

So does anyone have an idea of what this cleanser could be? It smells like nail varnish, and is highly flammable.


Cheap to give a try. I did order this awhile back but it never hit my door here. She said it did not bring the atomizer back to life which I am not surprised as the coil connection was snapped, but that does not mean it may not have cleaned the coil and would work on one that still has a viable coil---have a look.----Sun

Yes sun I remember that post....we all thought it sounded like it must be the same as nail varnish remover but I never did try that because there didn't seem to be much excitement over it working, it's one of the very few things I haven't tried....lol
 

Sun Vaporer

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Jan 2, 2009
10,146
27
Florida
I have no intention whatsoever of selling it myself. I think it would be good for it to be available from our usual suppliers.

I know that in Sun's tests it took many hours to work thoroughly, although those attys were bad cases. However, perhaps a more dilute fluid would still be efficient enough. I suggest 5% for maintenance cleaning then 20% or 75% as a choice also, so perhaps 3 products. Of course, I would buy the 75% and dilute it myself, but others may prefer starting with the milder version rather than risk spillin it at 75%. I believe 35% can be posted; not sure about 75%.

ps: a reminder: cola is 2.5%

I see that Pete reports no change at 5% and would agree that a gradual approach upward in concentration is the next step in experimenting to see what the minumium concentration is that works. An experiment lining up 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, --Etc- may be in order to visually see the optimal mantenince concentration for cleaning on a regular bases???----Sun
 

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
I'll have to do some math, then, damnit...I hate math.

Keep in mind that it's not the % or concentration of the active ingredient as much as it is the pH of the product that will make the difference.

This is a fairly complex chemical equation that involves concentration, molarity, etc...but based on what I'm seeing (just from looking around, not doing the actual math) the pH of a 75% solution of Phosphoric Acid may be in the 2.5 range.

If this is the case, RC cola is actually MORE acidic than this stuff (with a pH of 2.3). That's not to say that this stuff won't work better because of purity of the acid but keep in mind that it's not the concentration of an acid as much as it is the pH that determines its ability to rip sh.t up. :D

I'll do some more looking and try to avoid math.
 
Good ideas, Pete and Sun.

But remember that the acid can weaken the deposit so it falls off after start vaping again. That complicates matters a bit but it can still be possible to determine the minimum to work effectively on a bad atomiser in say 8 hours.

Perhaps also, what concentration begins removing paint, or skin (eek) ...
 
Last edited:

Sun Vaporer

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Jan 2, 2009
10,146
27
Florida
I'll have to do some math, then, damnit...I hate math.

Keep in mind that it's not the % or concentration of the active ingredient as much as it is the pH of the product that will make the difference.

This is a fairly complex chemical equation that involves concentration, molarity, etc...but based on what I'm seeing (just from looking around, not doing the actual math) the pH of a 75% solution of Phosphoric Acid may be in the 2.5 range.

If this is the case, RC cola is actually MORE acidic than this stuff (with a pH of 2.3). That's not to say that this stuff won't work better because of purity of the acid but keep in mind that it's not the concentration of an acid as much as it is the pH that determines its ability to rip sh.t up. :D

I'll do some more looking and try to avoid math.

Terraphon--You are the one who knows how to do the calculations and I know how much a pain it the .... it is, but your help is invaluable ans appreciated--Thanks --Sun
 

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
Last edited:

StratOvation

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 10, 2009
373
17
Michigan, USA
I just stumbled accross this thread today so I'm not up to date on all the issues and really dont wanna read thru endless posts to answer a simple question...

Has anyone been able to determine what the residues are that are fouling your atomizers? Is it a solid ( like the Atom. got too hot and burnt the liquid?) A viscous liquid? ( like a goopy glop of flavoring byproduct? )

Maybe a little info as to what your trying to remove and I may be able to help find a remedy.

I've only been vaping for a short time and have kept my atomizers cleaned religously, so I haven't seen the same issues you all are facing.
 

Gravity_Tester

Full Member
Verified Member
Mar 10, 2009
22
6
Mesa
StarSan is a phosphoric acid based cleaner/sanitizer. Not sure of the concentration, but I know that when the concentrate is mixed at about 1/4 cup to a gallon of water, it's not rough on your hands and does a fantastic job sanitizing brewing equipment. (Sorry-bit of a beer nut) You can also use BLC-it's used to remove beerstone from kegging equipment and beer lines... StarSan can be had fairly cheap as well-either online or at your local brew shop. Hell-if you stop into a brew shop, the guys running the place probably have all kinds of tips and tricks to clean nastiness out of hard to reach places, and you'll probably get to sample some homebrewed beer as well...
 
Hi GTester - interesting tip, thanks.

Was just reading some info on a brewing site (BT - Troubleshooter: Vol. 4, No. 1) and it's worth posting a part; good advice on diluting a strong acid:

"Highly concentrated phosphoric acid is corrosive and dangerous (though not quite as problematic as nitric or sulfuric acid). I once spilled a drop of the 75% solution on my skin and found that it took a minute or so for it to start burning. Getting it into the eye, however, could result in instantaneous damage. For that reason I urge you to wear safety glasses or goggles, as well as rubber gloves, when handling the concentrated solution. Always work near a supply of running water, in case a spill requires a quick washdown. And finally, remember the motto of Joe Hale (my high school chemistry teacher): Do what you oughter, pour acid into water! Pouring water into acid can cause bubbling, hissing, and splashing."

ps: Terraphon, i got that wrong; cola pH is 2.75

edit (add): I doubt any point in a lower concentration than 35% (or 37.5%) as cola is around 20% equivalent (assuming that is about right, seems high). Hopefully 35% will work ok, although that would probably still be harsh on skin contact.
 
Last edited:

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
I just stumbled accross this thread today so I'm not up to date on all the issues and really dont wanna read thru endless posts to answer a simple question...

Has anyone been able to determine what the residues are that are fouling your atomizers? Is it a solid ( like the Atom. got too hot and burnt the liquid?) A viscous liquid? ( like a goopy glop of flavoring byproduct? )

Maybe a little info as to what your trying to remove and I may be able to help find a remedy.

I've only been vaping for a short time and have kept my atomizers cleaned religously, so I haven't seen the same issues you all are facing.

Actually, you SHOULD read the thread. You should also read the thread about dead pen-style atomizers. This would give you an idea where we're at and what we're working on.

There's no way for us to encapsulate a pretty little answer into one post but I can tell you that we're working on removing carbon buildup from the atomizer coil which, if left to build up over time, can actually physically break the coil / wiring inside by forcing the atomizer to move.

We've put WEEKS of research, testing, labor and discussion in to this issue (not to mention the money that we've invested in buying product, shipping things back and forth, testing chemical solutions, etc...) and that, in and of itself, makes the threads deserving of a good read-through.
 

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
Hi GTester - interesting tip, thanks.

Was just reading some info on a brewing site (BT - Troubleshooter: Vol. 4, No. 1) and it's worth posting a part; good advice on diluting a strong acid:

"Highly concentrated phosphoric acid is corrosive and dangerous (though not quite as problematic as nitric or sulfuric acid). I once spilled a drop of the 75% solution on my skin and found that it took a minute or so for it to start burning. Getting it into the eye, however, could result in instantaneous damage. For that reason I urge you to wear safety glasses or goggles, as well as rubber gloves, when handling the concentrated solution. Always work near a supply of running water, in case a spill requires a quick washdown. And finally, remember the motto of Joe Hale (my high school chemistry teacher): Do what you oughter, pour acid into water! Pouring water into acid can cause bubbling, hissing, and splashing."

ps: Terraphon, i got that wrong; cola pH is 2.75

hehe...I saw your PM. I'll go up and edit my post :D
 

StratOvation

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 10, 2009
373
17
Michigan, USA
Terra,

I certainly was not implying that the thread was not "worth my time" or doesn't contain valuable information based on alot of effort expended by the members.

It's simply not a problem that I've had to deal with yet.

But I do work with several industrial/pharma chemists that are typically anxious to offer helpful advice to a friend.

I'll definitely read through this thread as time permits. Just thought if everyone was dealing with a known residue I could pose a few questions at work tomorrow and get some helpful suggestions.

Mike
 
Hi Mike,

For quite a long time we believed that the deposits on the heater coil were largely carbon as that's what it most looks like and the fact that the juice contains mostly organic compounds. But phophoric acid seems to dissolve/react with virtually all the deposit, leaving no visible trace. My undestanding is that carbon would be unaffected by a pH1.6 acid (or any acid?); and my latest thinking is that the deposits are mostly the dry residue of flavorings and (mostly) inorganic minerals from undistilled water. It would be great to get some confirmation or otherwise on that.
 

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
That's part of the problem...We're not 100% sure what the residue is. We BELIEVE that it is carbon buildup from the decomposition of PG / VG (moreso from VG) but we're not sure.

It ACTS like carbon and it LOOKS like carbon and it's seen in places and circumstances that would lend to the creation of carbon but we have no incontrovertible proof that it IS carbon. (We're 99% sure it's carbon).

Now we're just playing with ways to remove it that won't also result in removing our lungs.
 

Terraphon

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2009
2,027
36
Phoenix, AZ, USA
Hi Mike,

For quite a long time we believed that the deposits on the heater coil were largely carbon as that's what it most looks like and the fact that the juice contains mostly organic compounds. But phophoric acid seems to dissolve/react with virtually all the deposit, leaving no visible trace. My undestanding is that carbon would be unaffected by a pH1.6 acid (or any acid?); and my latest thinking is that the deposits are mostly the dry residue of flavorings and (mostly) inorganic minerals from undistilled water. It would be great to get some confirmation or otherwise on that.

Wait...we're not sure it's carbon anymore?

I missed that part, damnit (I still think it's carbonized organics)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread