New studies find carcinogens in vg and pg at high temps, even in tootle puffers

Status
Not open for further replies.

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
So you actually started to taste something bad around 500F?
At 505F I could start tasting what I describe as a "burnt" hit. Not a dry hit, as the coil was saturated.

What was curious, and unexpected, was when doing the the stovetop boiling point tests, it started stinking bad at 505f also. I recognized the smell as being the same as what I tasted when getting "burnt" hits.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
According to New Study, Vaping Does NOT Cause Cancer and is Safer than Smoking Tobacco

Just for those who would like to read on another study that vaping DOES NOT cause Cancer
Thats pretty cool. I dont know why they had to throw in that blurb about shops selling to non-smokers, never knew shops were supposed to check!

The study used a VV style vape pen, at its highest setting, and didnt find anything. The biological stuff got over my head pretty quick, but its the final assessment that counts.
 

SteveS45

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Jan 27, 2016
8,177
16,842
63
Long Island, New York
Thats pretty cool. I dont know why they had to throw in that blurb about shops selling to non-smokers, never knew shops were supposed to check!

The study used a VV style vape pen, at its highest setting, and didnt find anything. The biological stuff got over my head pretty quick, but its the final assessment that counts.

I only posted it to relieve some of the fear factor that this thread has put into vapers. Not going to debate or discuss the content read it and make your own decisions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awsum140

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
So, for those of you running TC mods who are interested in reducing you vape temperatures, I stumbled across something interesting.

I have been playing with 30AWG Tungsten wire here recently. Long story short, I made two different coils, one 7 wraps slightly over 3mm ID and 0.11 ohms, and one 12 wraps 3mm ID and 0.17 ohms.

Same exact mod/TFR/preheat, same model of atty, same juice. The second one allowed me to get a comparable (if not stronger) vape at a lower temperature. I was getting a good vape at 415f on the 0.11 ohm coil, I got an equal or better vape off the 0.17 ohm coil at 360f.

I dont think it was so much the type of wire. I think it was because of the higher metal mass covering more of the surface area of the wick. The second one put more BTUs into the coil quicker generating more vapor at a lower temperature.

Just something to consider if you are trying to reduce your vape temp on a TC mod. More coil mass can help.
 

kiba

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 21, 2012
4,283
7,451
40
Alexandria, Va, USA
www.facebook.com
So, for those of you running TC mods who are interested in reducing you vape temperatures, I stumbled across something interesting.

I have been playing with 30AWG Tungsten wire here recently. Long story short, I made two different coils, one 7 wraps slightly over 3mm ID and 0.11 ohms, and one 12 wraps 3mm ID and 0.17 ohms.

Same exact mod/TFR/preheat, same model of atty, same juice. The second one allowed me to get a comparable (if not stronger) vape at a lower temperature. I was getting a good vape at 415f on the 0.11 ohm coil, I got an equal or better vape off the 0.17 ohm coil at 360f.

I dont think it was so much the type of wire. I think it was because of the higher metal mass covering more of the surface area of the wick. The second one put more BTUs into the coil quicker generating more vapor at a lower temperature.

Just something to consider if you are trying to reduce your vape temp on a TC mod. More coil mass can help.
I've found the same thing with claptons, only I don't like building my own and 316L isn't that great for TC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikepetro

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,623
1
84,752
So-Cal
So, for those of you running TC mods who are interested in reducing you vape temperatures, I stumbled across something interesting.

I have been playing with 30AWG Tungsten wire here recently. Long story short, I made two different coils, one 7 wraps slightly over 3mm ID and 0.11 ohms, and one 12 wraps 3mm ID and 0.17 ohms.

Same exact mod/TFR/preheat, same model of atty, same juice. The second one allowed me to get a comparable (if not stronger) vape at a lower temperature. I was getting a good vape at 415f on the 0.11 ohm coil, I got an equal or better vape off the 0.17 ohm coil at 360f.

I dont think it was so much the type of wire. I think it was because of the higher metal mass covering more of the surface area of the wick. The second one put more BTUs into the coil quicker generating more vapor at a lower temperature.

Just something to consider if you are trying to reduce your vape temp on a TC mod. More coil mass can help.

With a Melting Point of around 6200F, I imagine a Tungsten coil is harder to break during Dry Burn. LOL.

Any known Health Concerns regarding Tungsten (W) or a Tungsten Carbide (WC) ?
 

Mazinny

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 25, 2013
4,263
22,713
NY
So, for those of you running TC mods who are interested in reducing you vape temperatures, I stumbled across something interesting.

I have been playing with 30AWG Tungsten wire here recently. Long story short, I made two different coils, one 7 wraps slightly over 3mm ID and 0.11 ohms, and one 12 wraps 3mm ID and 0.17 ohms.

Same exact mod/TFR/preheat, same model of atty, same juice. The second one allowed me to get a comparable (if not stronger) vape at a lower temperature. I was getting a good vape at 415f on the 0.11 ohm coil, I got an equal or better vape off the 0.17 ohm coil at 360f.

I dont think it was so much the type of wire. I think it was because of the higher metal mass covering more of the surface area of the wick. The second one put more BTUs into the coil quicker generating more vapor at a lower temperature.

Just something to consider if you are trying to reduce your vape temp on a TC mod. More coil mass can help.
Wouldn't that concept apply to kanthal ( read non TC ) as well ? More wire mass at the same power level, therefore lower coil temperatures. I vape at about 12-14 watts ( 26g kanthal ), but i have a 0.5 second "pre heat" at 18 watts to lessen the ramp up time.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
With a Melting Point of around 6200F, I imagine a Tungsten coil is harder to break during Dry Burn. LOL.

Any known Health Concerns regarding Tungsten (W) or a Tungsten Carbide (WC) ?
The stuff holds it shape extremely well.

I read everything I could on the 99.x% tungsten (not the carbide). Everything I saw said it was pretty inert below XX temp, dont remember the exact temp but it was way way above what anyone would vape at. Although the oxides produced by those high temps would flake off, so I wouldnt dry burn it above 600f or so, ie dry burn in temp mode.

In playing with it, I did do a full on dry burn and observed a white powder develop on the surface, and it easily flaked off. I wouldnt vape on a coil after that.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
Wouldn't that concept apply to kanthal ( read non TC ) as well ? More wire mass at the same power level, therefore lower coil temperatures. I vape at about 12-14 watts ( 26g kanthal ), but i have a 0.5 second "pre heat" at 18 watts to lessen the ramp up time.
If the power level remains the same, I would guess the temp would be lower (on the first hit off a cold atty). I would have to measure to be sure.

One thing, is that my higher mass coil used a lot more power during preheat, the 0.17 ohm coil went up to 90w+ during preheat until the temp throttled it back to around 20ish watts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eskie

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,623
1
84,752
So-Cal
...

In playing with it, I did do a full on dry burn and observed a white powder develop on the surface, and it easily flaked off. I wouldnt vape on a coil after that.

Anything Flaking Off a dry burned coil would kinda Big Time Red Flag in my book.
 

Mazinny

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 25, 2013
4,263
22,713
NY
If the power level remains the same, I would guess the temp would be lower (on the first hit off a cold atty). I would have to measure to be sure.

One thing, is that my higher mass coil used a lot more power during preheat, the 0.17 ohm coil went up to 90w+ during preheat until the temp throttled it back to around 20ish watts.
Wouldn't it make sense that the temp would be lower on all the hits, not just the first one. The difference would be less, but there would still be a difference regardless, no ? I mean 14 watts applied to 8 wraps as opposed to 6 wraps of the same gauge wire would logically result in lower temperatures ( to some extent ) in all hits, not just the first one, no ?

I'm not saying that TC won't do a better job, but there are ways to keep the temperature lower with non-TC as well, but we just don't know how much lower, right ?
 

Imfallen_Angel

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 10, 2016
1,711
2,763
Ottawa area, Canada
So, for those of you running TC mods who are interested in reducing you vape temperatures, I stumbled across something interesting.

I have been playing with 30AWG Tungsten wire here recently. Long story short, I made two different coils, one 7 wraps slightly over 3mm ID and 0.11 ohms, and one 12 wraps 3mm ID and 0.17 ohms.

Same exact mod/TFR/preheat, same model of atty, same juice. The second one allowed me to get a comparable (if not stronger) vape at a lower temperature. I was getting a good vape at 415f on the 0.11 ohm coil, I got an equal or better vape off the 0.17 ohm coil at 360f.

I dont think it was so much the type of wire. I think it was because of the higher metal mass covering more of the surface area of the wick. The second one put more BTUs into the coil quicker generating more vapor at a lower temperature.

Just something to consider if you are trying to reduce your vape temp on a TC mod. More coil mass can help.

First, I can't believe this thread is still going, I though we had covered this to death already.

TC is about resistance change and the temperature set in itself is not the actual temperature but a setting of when to do they cut off... when the coil gets hotter, the variance is metered and once it hits the setting, the mod starts pulsing.

This is why that how the coil is built changes everything.
  • Here's an example: You could have a coil that's 12 pressed wraps a certain gauge and set at 35W / 380F, and another coil that's exactly the same, but this time it's spaced, the wick is better done, so the coil is getting cooled a lot more, and so the ramp up being much longer at 35W / 380F, you'd feel like it's not as warmth, so you'd increase the temp instead of chain vaping long enough for the coil to heat up enough to reach that setting.

    So the question is, if the coil is the same, why would you need to increase the Temp.? Easy, the coil is being cooled better by being distributed across more wick, to it's not getting as hot as the pressed one, plus the wicking done better would cool it more, so the variance in resistance isn't reached as easily, so more power is required.
  • Here's another: Using different liquids and flavours, some are more fluid, some have a higher density, so they require more heat/power to evaporate as they have either a higher or lower cooling ratio, so you could have a tank with one liquid, then you refill with another, and have to increase or lower the temp to continue to have the same level of warmth.

    So the question here is, if the temp setting was an absolute, the warmth level wouldn't change because of liquid use.
Also, when you play to adjust the TCR value of your build if you aren't happy with your vaping experience, this would disbalance everything should it be an absolute (the temp settings). But we change them to get the experience (warmth level) that we want.

So the only "real" temp. value to be concerned with is the warmth level that one likes... and unless you're tasting burnt, odds are that you're only hitting the vaporizing temp. of the liquid. And with pure VG having a flash point of 380F, PG being lower, then the odds of you ever getting truly above 380F is only through using too much wattage too fast and you'll burn something. Anything above a true 380F would probably serve to heat the air around it and provide the warmer aspect of it, but again, at that point, the actual difference between the flash point and the warmth achieved would be a minor differential. Between all this and the air cooling effect, the liquid never reaches the "worrisome" temps.

If anything, should one have the settings really way too high, it's an instant dry-hit as the sudden pulse of heat would instantly vaporize all the liquid close enough, and then actual creates a barrier that would push the liquid away from it (due to radiating that much heat), so no more wicking, no more cooling, and a tasteful burnt taste.

So as you're not stating if the coils are pressed or spaced, that the temp setting might be lower with one coil, but what about wattage fed? I know that some mods let you change the temp setting and adjust the wattage according the "low, normal, hard "hit"". But yes, more mass will usually result in more vapor produced, it's a question of balance between many factors.

Personally, I've yet to understand the whole uber-low ohm thing, as with adjusting to power and temp, I've yet to see much of a real difference between a 0.2 (or lower) to up to a 1ohm coil (or dual coil setup). I'd rather have a balanced setup that's wicking well, heats up fast enough and provides a good experience. I know that for cloud chasers it's about as much vapor produce per milli-second, but for the average person, that's not going to matter all that much.
 

Imfallen_Angel

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 10, 2016
1,711
2,763
Ottawa area, Canada
If the power level remains the same, I would guess the temp would be lower (on the first hit off a cold atty). I would have to measure to be sure.

One thing, is that my higher mass coil used a lot more power during preheat, the 0.17 ohm coil went up to 90w+ during preheat until the temp throttled it back to around 20ish watts.

Ah.. I see that you answered my question while I was typing my post. So yup, this confirms what I was saying in it.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
Anything Flaking Off a dry burned coil would kinda Big Time Red Flag in my book.

This was one place I read about it, other sources confirmed the same thing.

The oxidation of tungsten metal becomes appreciable at about 600°C. A thin, black adherent layer is first formed and at higher temperatures is eventually overlain by a bright yellow scale.
(What I saw as a white powder might have been yellow, I didnt study it, just trashed it)

I dont think anyone is going to approach 1000f in the course of normal vaping, but a full on dry burn could do it. Same thing with TI if I am not mistaken. OK to vape with but dont dry burn.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
Wouldn't it make sense that the temp would be lower on all the hits, not just the first one. The difference would be less, but there would still be a difference regardless, no ? I mean 14 watts applied to 8 wraps as opposed to 6 wraps of the same gauge wire would logically result in lower temperatures ( to some extent ) in all hits, not just the first one, no ?

I'm not saying that TC won't do a better job, but there are ways to keep the temperature lower with non-TC as well, but we just don't know how much lower, right ?
On the surface, I would say yes that makes sense. However, I would want to back that up with measurements before I hung my hat on it. For example, its entirely possible that more heat would be retained within the wick of the higher mass coil, in between chain hits. More metal mass, better heat retention. Maybe???
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread