Rayon Wick - Better Flow, Flavor, Longevity, and Nic Hit!! - Pt.2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sloth Tonight

CF Moderator
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 25, 2014
7,879
51,681
NY
There's no trial and error unless you want to play around with your own recipes. There's many great recipes online, so at that point, you can view shopping for recipes like shopping for ready-made eliquid. The only trial and error in that approach is the same as buying a new eliquid in general, seeing if you like it or not. The actual process of making juice is easy with a recipe in hand.
To expand on this, just imagine, dear Herrick, that you find a great eliquid that's just so good but you know it would be better with just a little more of this or that. So here's where DIY kicks so much ayuss. You find a recipe that you really like but you think to yourself "if only it had a tad more vanilla," well since it's DIY you can add more vanilla.
^That's basically all I do anyway. Find a good recipe, then each time I go to remix a batch I think if I want to add or subtract any of the flavorings to make it better to my own palette. A good example for me is DIYORDIE's Pistachio RY4 which is very good IMO but overtime I've changed it by using a different vanilla, a different pistachio, and slightly different percentages. I like it better than his version. But the beauty is you go try his recipe and then you can make your own adjustments like I did.

DIY is a lot of fun, and not intimidating at all if you view it through that lens.
 

Alter

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 2, 2013
2,711
6,942
BC Canada
I'm not sure I'm ready for DIY though but it's something that I'd love to eventually try. I'm just worried about the trial & error aspect.

I ummed and awwed for well over 6 months reading and researching the DIY aspect in juice. All the stuff I read made juice making into rocket science with complex mixes, clone mixes, this I didn't like and threw away along with all the flavorings one has to have to DIY properly....its all bull chit. I started by finding some loranns drams in a bargain store, changed a few commercial juices then realized this was great. Made a order of base, nic and a few flavors then started mixing. It was the tobacco vape that I thought would be the hardest to nail but Hangsen tobacco concentrates nailed it for me so I really never looked much further. I still make only 2 or 3 ingredient mixes, keep it simple and vape happy. I still think back then kick myself for selling myself short by not dwelling into DIY sooner than I did.

edit...I should add it was a single Qtip cotton swab in a protank coil that caused me to put silica away...forever
 

Fozzy71

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 7, 2016
3,370
11,737
54
8 Mile + 2.5
DIY is a lot of fun, and not intimidating at all if you view it through that lens.
It really is fun. and soo much cheaper than paying for store bought juice you may or may not like. If I mix 120ml of something and don't like it I am out 2 or 3 bucks and may be able to salvage it by adding a bit more of this or that, or by just dumping it into my kitchen sink dump liter and letting the other juices in there overpower what I don't like about it. I like it so much I think I mixed 10 x 100ml bottles so far this month. I enjoy mixing but I have grown a bit bored with the small bottle testing process recently so I recently started testing in 100ml sizes and just hope for the best.
 

DavidOck

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 3, 2013
21,239
178,485
Halfway to Paradise, WA
Yeah I'm going to start looking into less gunky stuff. I'm not sure I'm ready for DIY though but it's something that I'd love to eventually try. I'm just worried about the trial & error aspect. I've had enough problems with vaping since I started last September. Hey it's been a whole year of vaping for Herrick!

Congarats.jpg
on the year! Hope you have many more to come as an EX-smoker!!

As the Sloth slowly typed, DIY is a snap that way. Lets you fine tune any recipe to YOUR tastes (and strength, and PG/VG ratio), and winds up being a heck of a lot cheaper than ready-mix.

Lots of places to find clone recipes, and one of those for a juice you like is a good starting point, makes entry easy :)
 

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
Silica wicks very fast. Some materials can wick faster but silica still wicks fast enough for a great vape. Anything vaped too hot can't be healthy tho.

Ok, no scientific proof that silica in and of itself is harmful, that may be true but the use of it in our vaping application can be.

Indeed, silica wicks fairly fast but due to it's ceramic composition it is completely non absorbant. This means that silica holds much less juice per sq.in. than cotton or rayon so during a pull it can go from being saturated to very dry very quickly. That gives the user less time to avoid an overtemp condition (above 450°f) or a dry hit. Shorter pulls and higher flow attys with larger juice channels can help with that but as others have mentioned overtemping your vape is unhealthy and can be undetectable.

Then there's a hidden monster, the use of non aborbant high temp resistant wicking in a less than perfect coil build. Unless your coil wraps are very symmetrical ie. same diameter wraps and a very straight coil non absorbant wicking or wicking that does not swell when moistened can experience gaps between wick and wire. The portion of the coil that is not touching the wick will get hotter than the areas that are and will overheat, even when using temp control. Again, the overheated vapor coming from that area mixed with lower temp vapor being produced by the rest of the coil can be undetectable.

From my experience with using silica and ReadyXwick ceramic wicking mediums it is more difficult to detect an oncoming overtemp situation than when using cotton or rayon. Perhaps because with absorbant wicking it happens more gradually or maybe because the flavor falls off.
In addition using absorbant wicking that holds more juice per sq.in. greatly reduces the chance of ever reaching an overtemp condition when compared to ceramic.

Then there's the glass. Ceramic wick products like silica and ReadyXwick shed glass particles when drawn tightly through a coil. Next time you wick a coil with silica tap your atty deck on a piece of black construction paper and have a look through a magnifying glass. Not good and I'm not confident that any amount of rinsing with water would remove it all. That's the primary reason I stopped using ceramic wicking mediums, even before the health risks of vaping above 450°f were known or documented.

Vaping is a very personal thing and we all like what we like, sometimes for the same reasons, sometimes not. Each of us has to determine our own balance between safety and convenience. I'll admit, I liked being able to dryburn my coil without rewicking using ceramics but for me my health is more important.

Cig







Show me solid proof silica wick is bad and I'll throw all of mine away...
 

Hoggy

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 6, 2013
394
1,078
WI, USA
Nobody is trying to prove anything to you. I'm certainly not going to try. There is ongoing research into the chemical effects of high temp vaping, the results of which seem most easily replicated using older style vape gear. Silica has incredibly high scorch resistance meaning that without TC, the likelihood of achieving those high temps at the wire are, at least anecdotally, increased. Pile on that silica is utterly inferior to cheaper, more easily sourced wicking options, and I just don't understand why anyone would bother.

But again, like everyone's said, you want to use it go right ahead. Worked fine for me when I had no other choice too.

Silica doesn't have as poor performance as we once thought, and experienced, in those older style Protank 2/Evod/T3 types. It's certainly not as good as rayon, especially when using rewicking w/silica techniques where the coil diameter needs to be wide enough to fit that first folded-over part via the threading-the needle technique - so it's not quite as snug as the strangle-the-wick-freehand-or-with-paperclip technique we may have used.

But that's why as I try to use my remaining silica in certain cases, that I usually try to go for the 4-FastTech-strand coil diameter of 3mm, to try and make up for the slightly looser fit and poorer wicking ability.

My trouble with just flat throwing it out, is that due to my hoarding tendencies, I got stuck with over 130 ft of the stuff. I can't remember the price of the 30-foot length anymore, but I think the 100-foot length was at least $17 or so. Add that to the fact that I don't have income now along while being in a severely nerve-wracking 8+ year disability case -- so I in no way can afford to be throwing things away that may still have any possible use, seen or unforseen.

As far as the possibility of producing possibly bad byproducts, I think many of us that have no intention in stopping vaping have already accepted the fact that it's not likely 100% safe anyways. ..... For instance, take the high/max VG ratio that seems to be all the rage these days for some reason.. VG produces bad by-products at VERY low temps that are easily reached in normal, even very low-watt/low-temp, vaping -- not to mention gunks your coils much faster, on top of the higher risk that it might set off your apartment building's should-be-illegal loud-... fire alarm. :) And then there's also the issue of cotton-lung, which I assume would also translate to rayon-lung.
(EDIT: Seriously? That word is even bleeped out? On a website that should be containing adults only?!? That can even be heard on broadcast TV?!? Wow - talk about Puritanical ways.. :confused::blink: )

So bring on the 'silica-lung'. Bring on the 'cotton/rayon-lung'. Bring on them tasty diketones! :p:D It's still all safer than smoking!
 
Last edited:

atroph

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 23, 2014
830
1,656
Chesapeake, VA
Not buying it... We should be more concerned with the High wattage vaping.
Wattage is not the correct argument. It has been shown that you can vape at well over 100w with no ill affects. The key is a balance of the output wattage and the cooling ability of proper juice flow and the wick that carries the juice to maintain a proper temperature. Proper temperature is the key element as it keeps the juice from breaking down and releasing the bad things.

You can get a bad vape at 8w just like you can at 100w. You run any atty dry due to poor wicking performance and the system breaks down and starts scorching the juice.

With temp controlled devices on the market the watts and volts talk should be pushed to the wayside because they are just inputs to the system that produces thermal results. Controlling the thermal results is what matters.

Sent from my 2PZC5 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Brobdingnagian

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 18, 2011
485
1,106
Tampa Bay Area, FL
K, been using the rayon for several days and getting to know what it responds well to. It's really hard to make this stuff perform poorly unless you really, really over-stuff your coils, which I found was well past the point I needed and in the opposite direction from where my case of "post-vape sizzle" came from. Once I saw this post, it became clear what I was screwing up:

♤♤♤♤♤♤♤♤♤

The reason you see this is - when rayon started atomizers were completely old and restrictive. We're taking evods.

As times have changed, mega juice flow and air are the normal. You can get away with less trimming of the tails. It's all relative to the atties juice flow and power levels. As well as coil size.

With that said in the beginning I also used 32 gauge and had no problems getting rayon in whatsoever. Hold the coil with your fingers or nails at the end.. Just use a mini screw driver to evenly space and realign the coils afterwards. Or use the double insertion method.

Amount of wick and tails is all relative to your vape style.

At 30w in newer rtas it really almost doesn't matter how you do it. The lower the power the more you can get away with a looser wick.

Very important stuff here. I overstuffed my coils and didn't notice them being overstuffed because it flat out tasted better than cotton anyways. Just enough to get the squeaky feeling turned out to be sufficient, no leaks.

If I'm using a fused clapton or similar beefy wire in an RTA, I've found packing it full enough to make the coil move is simply way too much.

Jeremy, you may want to revisit TC and I'd suggest DNA, Evolv, chips/boards. There is a major safety gain by using TC, for example I can vape and all stainless FEV3 bone dry and never get a burned or dry hit, the vapor just stops. Additionally, there is evidence that aldehydes increase, dramatically, above 450F and are primarily generated by VG. If I remember correctly, you vape high VG liquids. It's up to you and your own vaping style and preferences but I would feel remiss if I didn't mention this.

Yeah, TC is pretty consistent on quality boards. The Smoant Battlestar isn't a perfect device by any means, but it definitely ramps up almost instantly and fits in my pocket decently with the EXO's big tank on it. Most said that the TC felt 20-30 degrees warm on the SS default setting, so TCR is recommended.

Hello All. What is the best way to clean a coil without removing the rayon?

Coil Master makes a vape cleaning brush that has metal bristles on it. That might work. Get that gunk outta there and re-wick. You don't want to vape that.

But the coil is all black and crumbly-looking.

Pulse burn at low power in a well-ventilated area for gunk (Especially NETs since the gunk is ashtray-esque) or bathroom with fan running, stop when the gunk starts to burn on its own. It'll often keep burning but you may need to repeat this to get it all off. A lot of people advise against rinsing the coil off using the tap, but I do it anyways.

quit vaping net/gunky juice. i have 8 - 10 tanks in rotation and vape 100ml+ of diy juice (mostly now sweetener, some a little now stevia) per tank before I rewick and dry burn

I use the Now Stevia in Glycerite whenever I need something to get sweeter. I find it gunks coils a lot more slowly than any sweetened retail juice I've tried, maybe about at the same rate as some custards. I only ever get a "taste" of the sweetener if I take the wick way too close to a dry hit....not an easy feat, even more difficult with TC unless something's not right or I've tried to use some stupid flattened caterpillar track wires that weren't hammered evenly.

DIYORDIE's Pistachio RY4

Made that one without butterscotch, used some extra caramel, and "accidentally" vaped it all before I added a NET I planned on putting in it.

Then there's the glass. Ceramic wick products like silica and ReadyXwick shed glass particles when drawn tightly through a coil. Next time you wick a coil with silica tap your atty deck on a piece of black construction paper and have a look through a magnifying glass. Not good and I'm not confident that any amount of rinsing with water would remove it all. That's the primary reason I stopped using ceramic wicking mediums, even before the health risks of vaping above 450°f were known or documented.

Vaping is a very personal thing and we all like what we like, sometimes for the same reasons, sometimes not. Each of us has to determine our own balance between safety and convenience. I'll admit, I liked being able to dryburn my coil without rewicking using ceramics but for me my health is more important.

Cig

Absolutely this. The little aluminum-glass pieces flake off, float around, and stick to everything. Not only that, but I had one of those wicks in a Protank coil head a long time ago and it literally crumbled apart when I finally went to change the coil out. I remember having to wash up very often, because if I got some of the XC/RxW freaky fiber flakes on my skin and did nothing I'd itch from them... too much like fiberglass.

The manufacturer themselves did research on the fibers (including a single rat study), and it still bothers me that I used the stuff in the past:

"Although Nextel fibers are classified as ceramic fibers, they are manufactured in continuous lengths and have diameters(approximately 7 to 13 microns) which are not considered to be respirable by humans. Since they are not considered to be respirable,inhalation exposure to Nextel 312, 440, 550,610, 650 or 720 fibers is not expected to pose a carcinogenic risk to humans. They may, however, cause mechanical irritation of the nose and throat. In certain operations, Nextel 312, 440, 550, 610, 650 and 720 Ceramic Fibers may break to form a dust, particularly if the sizing has been removed or the fibers have been exposed to high temperatures."...

..."In this study, Nextel 312 Ceramic Fiber dust caused lung inflammation with no evidence of more serious effects such as granulomas or fibrosis. From this study it was concluded that the potential for Nextel 312 Ceramic Fiber dust to cause pulmonary fibrosis or other significant lung injury is minimal."​

-3M Ceramic Textiles and Composites
Health & Safety Bulletin 3M Nextel 312, 440, 550, 610, 650 & 720
The conditions to make this material brittle are literally being created in the heat-treating process to remove the toxins contained in the sizing... the batch I bought before the process was "improved" to remove a couple more percent of the toxic sizing, were updated to receive an even longer heat treating, which I would expect to mean a more brittle fiber, leading to potentially even more dust.

My gut is telling me to stay far away and to keep the last 3" I have left sealed up in the MacGuyver box.

While I will probably only ever vape Cellucotton unless I try medical-grade rayon in the future, it seems to hold together like a beast when wet. It is thermally conductive to the point it's almost as if the entire wick is drawing heat away from the coil, and it is highly difficult to singe.

I may revisit cotton in a while just to remember why I stopped using it in the first place, but rayon has even solved the condensation issues in some of my tanks.

If the vape is a little more saturated and cooler, and the coil isn't being allowed to get too warm via the insane wicking action providing plenty of juice flow, TC in the mix is just going to provide another layer of insurance against possible decomposition byproducts. :thumb:

In comparison, cotton was quite dry and too close to being too hot, and dreadfully wasteful in respect to the delicious (and oftentimes expensive) juices and flavors we enjoy getting stuck in the wick, rather than making it all the way to our coils.

Either way, those are just my thoughts on it.

Off I go to downmix some strawberry cactus stuff I mixed up for the hurricane that needs 2.5x dilution nicotine-wise. :eek:

Edit: I've forgotten to add a quote from several pages back about a user saying they didn't like the taste of rayon & that they were going back to cotton. Wicked correctly, it is tasteless. I could only taste the rayon when I put about twice the amount I needed in the coil.
 

Hoggy

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 6, 2013
394
1,078
WI, USA
The excerpt you posted about silica make it seem quite benign.. And then you can compare that to cotton-lung (which may or may not translate to rayon), which doesn't seem as benign according to this:
Long term respiratory health effects in textile workers

Point is, there could be unknown dangers whether the wicking material is silica, cotton, or rayon.

So either way we're all screwed and are all going to die. :shock: :)

ETA: Yeah, if you only have 3 inches of the stuff, I definitely would keep that in you 'rainy-day' box. I got stuck with 130 FEET of the stuff. :-x
 
Last edited:

Alter

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 2, 2013
2,711
6,942
BC Canada
The main reason that the rayon has to be literally overstuffed is that it doesn't expand but settle upon itself so that dry coil is tight as heck but once juice is added it loosens up some from settling. The cotton expands thus having it much looser in the coil so it doesn't choke juice flow.
The huge bulky rayon tails are easily corralled into more manageable size by running tweezers or anything thin through them, removing the bulk then cutting the scrapings off(pulling them might remove fibers from in the coil).
Rayon more is better in the coil but less rules in the tails, the opposite of how cotton is handled. If there is any sort of breakin taste with rayon then you've wicked it wrong.
 

Fozzy71

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 7, 2016
3,370
11,737
54
8 Mile + 2.5
Yeah, TC is pretty consistent on quality boards. The Smoant Battlestar isn't a perfect device by any means, but it definitely ramps up almost instantly

I don't have a smoant yet (though they are high on my to buy list) but if you want quick ramp up (max 80w) try a voopoo drag. I am really impressed with this little box.

I use the Now Stevia in Glycerite

I only just started mixing with this (was sick of my pyure going 'bad' even stored in the fridge) so I am not sure if I have even vaped any of the juices I mixed with it yet but it is good to hear your results. What percent do you use it at? I have been using it at 0.5%. Do you know it's specific gravity or VG%? Based on the ingredients I suspect it is almost entirely VG so I set it to 95% VG in my calculator then calculate the SG based on that for mixing by weight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TrollDragon

Sloth Tonight

CF Moderator
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 25, 2014
7,879
51,681
NY
Thanks to the people who encouraged me to start DIY e-liquid. I watched a few videos including a great one by New Amsterdam Vape and it looks like the most difficult thing is choosing from all the different recipes. I might start this within the next couple weeks.
Awesome! Yep, that really is the most difficult aspect. Prepare to enjoy your juice far more than before and to save untold amounts of $ in the process :)
 

Herrick

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 21, 2016
543
1,010
44
Very important stuff here. I overstuffed my coils and didn't notice them being overstuffed because it flat out tasted better than cotton anyways. Just enough to get the squeaky feeling turned out to be sufficient, no leaks.

My initial difficulty with rayon wasn't coil density but tail density. I was making the tails way too thin which resulted in leaks and flooding. I've been leak-free once I stopped thinning the tails too much. I think I misunderstood what people meant by thinning. Now I trim the tails a bit to remove excess fluff then I comb it down into the wicking channels/holes/whatever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread