New studies find carcinogens in vg and pg at high temps, even in tootle puffers

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rossum

Eleutheromaniac
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2013
16,081
105,222
SE PA
Sigh.......
At least that was early in the thread. I dont think people have the same view anymore.
My perspective:
I think you've firmly determined that some carbonyls are produced when coil temperatures get into and exceed the 450°F range. But have we established that these levels actually exceed those found in tobacco smoke? Have we established that these levels actually present a significant health risk? Let's not forget that carbonyls are far from the only (or the most potent) carcinogens in tobacco smoke. Let's not forget that most of us voluntarily indulge in various "carcinogens" on a regular basis in the form of grilled and processed meats.
 

Rossum

Eleutheromaniac
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2013
16,081
105,222
SE PA
From that article..."Nicotine doesn’t cause smoking-related diseases, such as cancers and heart disease, but it is addictive."
What lots of people now call "addictive" used to be referred to as "habit-forming". There's little doubt that nicotine is habit-forming for many people. But the term "addictive" was only used when the habit included obvious harm, or disruption of a person's life, or more than minor physical withdrawal symptoms. None of this seems to apply to nicotine by itself, although some of it might apply to tobacco.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,687
65
Newport News, Virginia, United States
But have we established that these levels actually exceed those found in tobacco smoke?

In my testing of actual vaping I did not detect levels exceeding cigarettes, nor have I ever claimed it.

I think the only mention in this thread about levels EXCEEDING tobacco smoke were by Dr Kurt on the CE4 device
upload_2018-2-1_9-48-53.png



And by John with respect Acetaldehyde at temps consistently at/around 500f and above.
upload_2017-3-5_20-42-33-png.639193



Have we established that these levels actually present a significant health risk?

The only metric I know to use would be the OSHA workday limits. I dont know what the breakpoint is to be considered harmful, and I am not qualified to make any claims regarding that.

My position is, that if you can reduce the amount of nasties by managing the temperature of your vape, and still get a satisfying vape, then why not? It is clear that as temp increases, above ~440f, so do the nasties, at some point they skyrocket, and this occurs before you can taste it.

Just because a human can tolerate 15grains (made up #) of arsenic without it being harmful doent mean we shouldnt try to minimize arsenic exposure nonetheless.
 

stols001

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 30, 2017
29,338
108,118
It is true that with everything we are exposed to these days, minimizing risks where known is a good thing.

I tend to be a little more risk tolerant than many, but I find the older I get, the more risk-averse I become. I think it has to do with a lot of things including a) real world experience b) knowledge that as I age, I have become more fragile... I mean really, even a cold is harder to get over (although I do feel a bit like I've stepped back in time) as well as some risks I have taken in the past that I KNOW have probably reduced my life-expectancy by a fair amount, as well as my quality of life (we're talking major, life style things.)

I used to think "Live fast, die pretty" was a valuable motto in the day. I have changed it to "Live as long as you can, leaving behind a wizened, ugly corpse with arthritis and dentures," to be more realistic, although my doc informs me via some test that I will get arthritis in my mid-90s. LOL. To be fair, the women in my family tend to DIE old, but IDK about "mid nineties" although both my grandmothers lived into their nineties and my mom is 70. She has some arthritis, I don't, but I blame yoga for that one.

Seriously though, everything's a tradeoff. I got so thin my last few years smoking, I have actually LAID off the yoga on purpose because I couldn't keep body fat to save my life.... I figure with another 10 lbs on board, it may be easier to go back to it and not skeletalize myself. The dentures I already have, but that was a "special" situation.

Also, I find as I age, I only grow happier, and I certainly wasn't expecting that outcome, so why risk my precious "good times" any more than I must?

My first therapist told me I'd get happier the older I got. She also told me I'd quit smoking someday. She was kind of my spiritual mom, but I did not believe her in the slightest. I now kind of do... :)

With that said, most forms of vaping are going to be infinitely more safe than cigarettes, and I will repeat, again, for those intimidated by the idea of TC, there are THINGS still to be done to minimize risk. I'm never going to give up on my Nautilus coils, and they can't do TC. I do use distilled water AND PEG400 to thin my vape, and not only is it noticeably cooler (and I rotate my setups when chainvaping) the vape is actually improved, which I did not expect. Knowing your atomizer, your tank, your e-liquid and safest practices have all IMPROVED my non-TC vaping, even without using TC (which I use when it's applicable/indicated) and not only that, they didn't just cool my tanks, they improved my vape.

There is valuable information on this thread even for non-TC vapers should they choose to heed it. Even WITHOUT those best practices, I felt health improvements right away, and I feel them even more. TC can be finicky, hard to set up, and intimidating at first, but I see absolutely no reason that ONE person cannot find at least ONE piece of information on this thread to improve their vape, and I actually read this thread from the beginning (as a new vaper, freaking out, going OH I MUST TC TO LIVE). That's not actually accurate, but what IS accurate is that there are valuable takeaways from this thread for ANYONE.

Just try not to get too freaked out about it in the beginning, is my advice. It did get me to RTAs more quickly, another thing I am grateful for.

Also, there is only so much precision you need in life in order to make conclusions from data. You'd be amazed at some of the stuff folks and cultures have been able to discover (including genetics, which I believe was started by a Franciscan monk gardener, IIRC, without sophisticated measuring tools.)

Good luck to all and I think this thread has been one of the more useful ones on ECF (for me).

:Anna
 

gerrymi

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 12, 2013
3,917
14,560
The 'Burgh, PA.
I actively seek out smokers

Being a vaper for 4+ years...I still view friends/acquaintances/strangers in 2 distinct groups...(same as I did when I was a smoker):

NON-SMOKERS...(on the whole)...kinda boring...I always wear my seatbelt and go to church on Sundays...people...

SMOKERS...(on the whole)...devil-may-care, interesting and intriguing people...(but who now (to me) smell a little bad)...

..
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,687
65
Newport News, Virginia, United States
*turns down TC to 200C* So as i understand it right maxpossible- safest temperature is 200 degrees? Just turned it down and vape feels the same.

My testing showed nothing negative below 225C*, so I think you are more than good at 200.
 

Katdarling

I'm still here on ECF... sort of. ;)
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 25, 2011
32,572
167,592
Utopia
I realised that i'm not that addictive to nicotine as such. I'm addicted to the physical act of smoking. I just love smoking.

What lots of people now call "addictive" used to be referred to as "habit-forming". There's little doubt that nicotine is habit-forming for many people. But the term "addictive" was only used when the habit included obvious harm, or disruption of a person's life, or more than minor physical withdrawal symptoms. None of this seems to apply to nicotine by itself, although some of it might apply to tobacco.

Risking ridiculous redundancy...


 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,687
65
Newport News, Virginia, United States
I want to thank @440BB and @Mazinny for the loan of their Provaris. I know they are precious to those who own them. (I wont stir the whole Provari/Vamo thing up)

I also want to thank all of the others who contributed attys and coils for testing.

"Gregory" (sorry I dont remember you ECF handle) but I have a Nautilus here with your first name and an address. Did you want it returned? I cant imagine why else I snipped your return address off the envelope.

Is there anyone else who loaned me hardware that I need to return?
@Mazinny should be getting his Provari back today.

As a thank you to both of these guys for their generous loan I included a DNA75 with their package. I got them at a crackhead price and bought far too many in a moment of cheapskate shineyitus. They are a decent mod though and I couldnt pass up the deal. Then I realized I would never use them, as in why the hell did I buy them in the first place? So I PIFd them to these guys who I hope can get some use out of them.
 

Fiestylillady

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 14, 2017
297
631
USA
At 200c I barely get a vape. (Not arguing the science/data). But does my tc not with or am I going something wrong? I know there is heat because the cotton burns I think because of my constant or long pulses. What watt are you all setting at 200c? Or am I going above this in wattage mode because I'm getting more am getting satisfying vape? What are the more affordable and reliable tc mods? (Tried tc so far on mesh and now blitzen both on alien) any help is appreciated.
 

Fredman1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Mar 27, 2017
4,052
22,788
66
New Zealand
Yeah I have a love/hate thing going with TC. It works well for the most part, but has its times when it slows down. For some reason it just mellows down to a beyond par vape. My different devices all takes turns to do that. I then put it back to power mode and all is well again.
I've noticed it when the battery is lowish and after a refill(wick is a bit over saturated), but other times its for no apparent reason.
Yeah it seems to me TC can be finnicky and temperamental...
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001

ScottP

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
6,392
18,809
Houston, TX
Yeah I have a love/hate thing going with TC. It works well for the most part, but has its times when it slows down. For some reason it just mellows down to a beyond par vape. My different devices all takes turns to do that. I then put it back to power mode and all is well again.
I've noticed it when the battery is lowish and after a refill(wick is a bit over saturated), but other times its for no apparent reason.
Yeah it seems to me TC can be finnicky and temperamental...

What device? The only time I have ever seen that is when the coil gets gunked up and needs cleaning.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,687
65
Newport News, Virginia, United States
At 200c I barely get a vape. (Not arguing the science/data). But does my tc not with or am I going something wrong? I know there is heat because the cotton burns I think because of my constant or long pulses. What watt are you all setting at 200c? Or am I going above this in wattage mode because I'm getting more am getting satisfying vape? What are the more affordable and reliable tc mods? (Tried tc so far on mesh and now blitzen both on alien) any help is appreciated.

Is the wick well saturated?
200 is a little low, try 225
What chip set is in the mod?
What type of wire are you using?
Try setting the watts real high, like double what you use in wattage mode, but keep your temp between 200 and 225.

Pics of your atty build might help.
More details of your mod setup would help.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,687
65
Newport News, Virginia, United States
Yeah I have a love/hate thing going with TC. It works well for the most part, but has its times when it slows down. For some reason it just mellows down to a beyond par vape. My different devices all takes turns to do that. I then put it back to power mode and all is well again.
I've noticed it when the battery is lowish and after a refill(wick is a bit over saturated), but other times its for no apparent reason.
Yeah it seems to me TC can be finnicky and temperamental...
When the battery is low you may be getting a large voltage drop. Make sure you use good name brand batteries. @Mooch does excellent battery reviews in his blog.

Many of us have noticed that 3166ss can drop in resistance after it has been used a while. Reset the cold resistance on your mod by unscrewing the atty, pressing the fire button, then screw the cold atty back in and let it read the resistance again. That may well get you back on track.

Fancy coils like fused Claptons can do this for me. It is usually either because they are gunked or because the resistance changed.

And as noted above, as your coil get gunked you will see lower vapor, clean the coil, or (less desirable) bump the temp up a little to compensate.

One last trick is get it where it is vaping well for you, then turn on the resistance lock.
 

Fredman1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Mar 27, 2017
4,052
22,788
66
New Zealand
Thanks guys. I use
JAC DNA 75 and Ehpro 101 mods. I'm overly careful with batteries and only use the good name ones.
I'll play around with what you said and see how I go. I'm learning heaps about TC as I go. Will definitely persist with it, because its just a matter of learning and understanding it.


*Edit to add* Come to think of it, every time I get frustrated with TC, I learn something....that's called progress, right? :D
 
Last edited:

Fiestylillady

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 14, 2017
297
631
USA
When the battery is low you may be getting a large voltage drop. Make sure you use good name brand batteries. @Mooch does excellent battery reviews in his blog.

Many of us have noticed that 3166ss can drop in resistance after it has been used a while. Reset the cold resistance on your mod by unscrewing the atty, pressing the fire button, then screw the cold atty back in and let it read the resistance again. That may well get you back on track.

Fancy coils like fused Claptons can do this for me. It is usually either because they are gunked or because the resistance changed.

And as noted above, as your coil get gunked you will see lower vapor, clean the coil, or (less desirable) bump the temp up a little to compensate.

One last trick is get it where it is vaping well for you, then turn on the resistance lock.
Is the wick well saturated?
200 is a little low, try 225
What chip set is in the mod?
What type of wire are you using?
Try setting the watts real high, like double what you use in wattage mode, but keep your temp between 200 and 225.

Pics of your atty build might help.
More details of your mod setup would help.
Is the wick well saturated?
200 is a little low, try 225
What chip set is in the mod?
What type of wire are you using?
Try setting the watts real high, like double what you use in wattage mode, but keep your temp between 200 and 225.

Pics of your atty build might help.
More details of your mod setup would help.
Is the wick well saturated?
200 is a little low, try 225
What chip set is in the mod?
What type of wire are you using?
Try setting the watts real high, like double what you use in wattage mode, but keep your temp between 200 and 225.

Pics of your atty build might help.
More details of your mod setup would help.
 

Attachments

  • 20180206_111847.jpg
    20180206_111847.jpg
    2.5 MB · Views: 32
  • 20180206_111936.jpg
    20180206_111936.jpg
    2.3 MB · Views: 29
  • 20180206_111941.jpg
    20180206_111941.jpg
    3 MB · Views: 30
  • 20180206_111950.jpg
    20180206_111950.jpg
    3.2 MB · Views: 29
  • 20180206_111959.jpg
    20180206_111959.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 30
  • 20180206_112021.jpg
    20180206_112021.jpg
    3.1 MB · Views: 31
  • 20180206_112302.jpg
    20180206_112302.jpg
    3.2 MB · Views: 32
  • 20180206_112334.jpg
    20180206_112334.jpg
    3 MB · Views: 32
  • 20180206_112320.jpg
    20180206_112320.jpg
    3.2 MB · Views: 29
  • Like
Reactions: stols001
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread