New studies find carcinogens in vg and pg at high temps, even in tootle puffers

Status
Not open for further replies.

pufZeppelin

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 6, 2013
7,610
24,603
Florida, SW

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
Those temperature will result in chard cotton so you might as well roll it up and smoke it. Sure in the tests they might me achieving those temperatures to make the study prove what they want.

Again what I did shows the external temperature of the coil where the vapor is actually coming from that I am inhaling.

I can vape in tc at 500°f without charring wicks, far above the 470°f where carcinogens are being produced.
Do you really think your vapor is only coming off the outside of your coil? Watch some slow-mo utube vids. Vapor is shooting everywhere, even out the ends of the coils. I'll bet it gets pretty darn hot inside our coils.
 

SteveS45

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Jan 27, 2016
8,177
16,842
63
Long Island, New York
I can vape in tc at 500°f without charring wicks, far above the 470°f where carcinogens are being produced.
Do you really think your vapor is only coming off the outside of your coil? Watch some slow-mo utube vids. Vapor is shooting everywhere, even out the ends of the coils. I'll bet it gets pretty darn hot inside our coils.

Another who will quit because they believe the totally skewed results of these studies. Going to be no problems at all and no products out of stock if this keeps up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Wolf

vapdivrr

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 8, 2012
9,966
19,933
61
sarasota,fl
This was a Russian 91%, built up like a carto on steroids. It was vertical NI200 coil, and back in those days many of us (credit to @DJ ) were using Hemp as a filler. I know it was fully saturated, and I know it wasnt a dry hit situation. You can see the vapor trailing off to the right as I had a fan blowing on it.

Now after snapping these pics, I put the tank back on and vaped it, as is without changing anything. That build was a very satisfying hit.

20140702_103732_zps4kue1zii.jpg


IR000002_zps2a9a9e4b.jpg
So those readings were after you closed it back up? Or firing it open with the fan? Personally I think it would of been cooler if it were wicked unlike a cart (but perhaps that wasn't your intention ) because of the airflow not cooling the way it was intended in a normal kayfun or Russian set up. Also over saturation could possibly create slightly more heat as well, don't know this for sure but sometimes if I open my JC to much it produces a slightly harsher vape. Did you also do this with a traditional Russian build?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 

Katya

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 23, 2010
34,804
120,147
SoCal
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tiburonfirst

Katya

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 23, 2010
34,804
120,147
SoCal
I'd give Plain Old SS316/316L a go if you have Never Tried it.

Clean Taste. Fast Ramp Ups/Downs. Inexpensive. And you can get it about Anywhere you can buy Vape Wire.

Not so fast. :D

SS316--too much nickel. Is that a bad thing? Who knows?

SS316L--won't give accurate temp readings on preset SS modes, which are tuned for ss316. That a problem? No idea.

SS430--better but the wire is springy and requires a tcr setting and a lot of thinking. :facepalm:

How am I doing so far? :lol:

The more you know.....
 

vapdivrr

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 8, 2012
9,966
19,933
61
sarasota,fl
I see some attempts with thermal infrared devices to measure coils and wonder what you guys think about what I did with an instant read thermometer? I'm really not sure if this is accurate or not, but I did try it a few times and I had seemed to get consistent readings . I simply opened up a kayfun shortly after a vape and placed the tip of the thermometer onto the center of the coil and fired the coil for a couple seconds. I watched the readings go from room temp to (at least in my particular coil) to Temps between 200 and 230 degrees. I rewet wick and tried this a few times and got readings about the same every time. The coil didn't short and my thermometer goes to 300 degrees. So is this not reading coil temp? Or am I perhaps not using the correct tool?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
Another who will quit because they believe the totally skewed results of these studies. Going to be no problems at all and no products out of stock if this keeps up.

Nope, I'll settle for vaping as safe as I know how until test results are released that reflect an actual real world vaping scenario.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
So those readings were after you closed it back up? Or firing it open with the fan? Personally I think it would of been cooler if it were wicked unlike a cart (but perhaps that wasn't your intention ) because of the airflow not cooling the way it was intended in a normal kayfun or Russian set up. Also over saturation could possibly create slightly more heat as well, don't know this for sure but sometimes if I open my JC to much it produces a slightly harsher vape. Did you also do this with a traditional Russian build?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
No, the pics were only with no cap, couldnt figure out how to get inside to get a measurement with the cap on. I am sure that this was not representative of how we vape, as the chamber was open and the airflow was not right. At the time I was just trying to validate TC though, wasnt really questioning other stuff.

No, never took pics of a standard R91 horizontal build. I was pretty stuck on the vertical builds because they gave me such a good vape. Did the same thing in Taifuns when I moved on from the R91.

Remember back in the ceramic wick on genny days, I am wondering if I can do a rig like that with a thermocouple inside. The trouble with thermocouples is placement such that you dont short out the coils to one another.
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
I see some attempts with thermal infrared devices to measure coils and wonder what you guys think about what I did with an instant read thermometer? I'm really not sure if this is accurate or not, but I did try it a few times and I had seemed to get consistent readings . I simply opened up a kayfun shortly after a vape and placed the tip of the thermometer onto the center of the coil and fired the coil for a couple seconds. I watched the readings go from room temp to (at least in my particular coil) to Temps between 200 and 230 degrees. I rewet wick and tried this a few times and got readings about the same every time. The coil didn't short and my thermometer goes to 300 degrees. So is this not reading coil temp? Or am I perhaps not using the correct tool?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Sounds reasonable. Dont know though. Could the tip have given some sort of heat-sink effect?

We need a way to measure whats going on inside there with the cap on and normal vape airflow.
 

vapdivrr

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 8, 2012
9,966
19,933
61
sarasota,fl
Sounds reasonable. Dont know though. Could the tip have given some sort of heat-sink effect?

We need a way to measure whats going on inside there with the cap on and normal vape airflow.
Yes did it with no AF , so if anything I would think it could be a bit cooler. I know it's not a proper test at all, but I tend to think it's at least within 20 degrees or something. And obviously the longer you fire it, the hotter it gets, but I tried simulating it as close to my vaping style as possible.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 

vapdivrr

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 8, 2012
9,966
19,933
61
sarasota,fl
No, the pics were only with no cap, couldnt figure out how to get inside to get a measurement with the cap on. I am sure that this was not representative of how we vape, as the chamber was open and the airflow was not right. At the time I was just trying to validate TC though, wasnt really questioning other stuff.

No, never took pics of a standard R91 horizontal build. I was pretty stuck on the vertical builds because they gave me such a good vape. Did the same thing in Taifuns when I moved on from the R91.

Remember back in the ceramic wick on genny days, I am wondering if I can do a rig like that with a thermocouple inside. The trouble with thermocouples is placement such that you dont short out the coils to one another.
Oh yes, loved the ceramic and gennys! And not sure why I stopped the hemp either? Oh maybe it was all that boiling, picking, and boiling again thing? Does that hemp come ready to vape now?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 

mikepetro

Vape Geek
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 22, 2013
10,224
81,686
67
Newport News, Virginia, United States
Oh yes, loved the ceramic and gennys! And not sure why I stopped the hemp either? Oh maybe it was all that boiling, picking, and boiling again thing? Does that hemp come ready to vape now?

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
Heck if I know, I moved on to Rayon. But yeah, the hemp was a lot of work, it did work well though, and didnt burn easy.
 

David Wolf

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Dec 11, 2014
2,847
6,780
Charlotte, NC
Not so fast. :D

SS316--too much nickel. Is that a bad thing? Who knows?

SS316L--won't give accurate temp readings on preset SS modes, which are tuned for ss316. That a problem? No idea.

SS430--better but the wire is springy and requires a tcr setting and a lot of thinking. :facepalm:

How am I doing so far? :lol:

The more you know.....
You left out the chromium in SS which if dry fired who knows chromium oxides and chromium 6 which is bad? We can read that in the next studies :D
 

optsmk

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 4, 2009
1,022
729
Pleasanton, Ca.
You live in CA, like me, try to go a day with out a prop 65 warning ;)
Speaking of prop 65 warnings. I was at Stanford a year or so ago and I was walking to the parking lot. In front of me was a man with his wife and child. The wife read the prop 65 warning and she read the word word cancer in it. The little boy who must have been around 5 or 6 years old, started balling his eyes out screaming he didn't want to get cancer. Now it's possible that maybe one of his grandparents or other family member died a horrible death from cancer and that's what set him off. But at the time, I couldn't stop wondering what some parents tell their kids about cancer. Did someone close the them die of cancer, or are the parents just that stupid to teach such a young child to freak out when he hears the word cancer? I mean he freaked out. And even the mother would not go back down the elevator to the parking lot. She sent her husband down to get the car and come back to pick them up. I suppose some people just thrive on living in fear. I dunno.
 

David Wolf

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Dec 11, 2014
2,847
6,780
Charlotte, NC
I'm not giving up Vaping....but if studies really find out it's safer to use TC, I'm going Stainless... the only thing I will really miss is my Nautilus Mini unless they come out with SS coils.
I'll check in with you after the studies show dry burning stainless can release chromium oxides and that bad boy chromium 6 :rolleyes:
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,628
1
84,757
So-Cal
Not so fast. :D

SS316--too much nickel. Is that a bad thing? Who knows?

Who knows indeed. I'm not 100% sure Pure Nickel is as Bad as some say? Nickel bound up in Iron and Chromium? Don't know that either?

SS316L--won't give accurate temp readings on preset SS modes, which are tuned for ss316. That a problem? No idea.

316L can be about same as 316, only Lower Carbon. Hence the "L" nomenclature. I just put the Coil in and it seems to work Fine. But then Again, I vape at Temps where I had a Hard time reaching 410F. So I'm not exactly Pushing the Edge of the Envelope.

SS430--better but the wire is springy and requires a tcr setting and a lot of thinking. :facepalm:

Have Never used a 430 "Stainless". But I know if you are looking for a Nickel Free "Stainless", 430 is very common.

http://www.matweb.com/search/DataSheet.aspx?MatGUID=1306bb472ffc40dea7b5acab1ee2f5a0

How am I doing so far? :lol:

The more you know.....

Not Bad. Not Bad at All.

Now if you can Only tell me How Much Tax there will be on e-Cigarette/e-Liquids on April 1st?

:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread