Status
Not open for further replies.

druckle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2013
1,149
2,193
Scottsdale, Arizona, USA
I'm happily vaping on my three month old Ti coil. So... What's new around here to try out? :)
I lost track of how old my titanium coils are. They all work like the day I built them and no reason to change. I'm soooo lazy. I guess that's not a bad thing though. If humans weren't lazy we wouldn't have invented tools to make things easier.

Duane
 

JimScotty0

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 10, 2014
961
1,258
Garden Grove, CA, USA
www.facebook.com
If I recall the 'swan song' of NiFe52 was the (on paper) 'triple hit':
  • higher wire resistance - can use larger diameter wire
  • higher TCR - more accurate TC vape
  • safe to dry burn
While the above is all well and good I've been mostly happy and satisfied with the Unkamen SS430. Yesterday I did my 1st ever dryburn/clean of one of my SS430 coils. As I've gotten fairly good at wick+coil replacement the time saved was not all that much but I was happy I was able to do it. I'm also happy that the +1.0 ohm coils I've made with the SS430 can be fired on everything from my old 15W VV/VW mods to TC mods and anything in between. You'd be amazed how much battery life I get out of my 1.8ohm build being driven by a mere 16W in TC mode. ;)
I believe this has been posted before, but this is from the Kanthal site about NiFe52:
http://kanthal.com/en/products/mate...heating-wire-and-resistance-wire/nifethal-52/
 
  • Like
Reactions: dwcraig1

dwcraig1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 17, 2012
9,013
49,304
Imperial Beach, California
  • Like
Reactions: cigatron

TheotherSteveS

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 14, 2015
5,232
6,814
Birmingham, England
With an alloy where the Curie Temperature is sensitive to chemistry variations it's always going to be difficult to know what we are really getting for properties without precise chemistry analysis on each batch.

I think a pure elemental wire like titanium which is not very sensitive to chemistry variation is a lot more practical for wide vaping application.

I'm sure Ralph will get to the bottom of the issue but in the meantime I'll just be a watcher for NiFe

Duane
Hi duane
I agree but the Curie temp is pretty high right? Other than that the interesting things are resistivity, Tcr and heat capacity I guess. Also oxidative properties etc are also important from a safety perspective.
 

druckle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2013
1,149
2,193
Scottsdale, Arizona, USA
Hi duane
I agree but the Curie temp is pretty high right? Other than that the interesting things are resistivity, Tcr and heat capacity I guess. Also oxidative properties etc are also important from a safety perspective.
Yes, the other properties you mentioned are important but are much less sensitive to chemistry variation than Curie Temperature which relates strongly to TCR, thermal expansion characteristics etc.

I'm hoping that Ralph/Unkamen will find that they really didn't send him NiFe52 but some other NiFe alloy. It would be a real downer to find that the '52 alloy was terribly sensitive to specific batch chemistry.

For those who have tried the German equivalent to NiFe 52 what is the experience with TCR? Values?

Is there experience which indicates that the theoretical benefits of NiFe52 translate to practical day to day vaping benefits? What is the anecdotal experience?

Duane
 

druckle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2013
1,149
2,193
Scottsdale, Arizona, USA
From post [HASHTAG]#2337[/HASHTAG]
It came out to .480Ω where Wire Wizard puts it at just under 0.3Ω.
Work hardening can significantly change resistance of Nickel Iron alloys. I'm not sure if Steam Engine is referencing TCR data for annealed material. That's something we should know together with whether the coils we're building have annealed or work hardened material.

This whole thing is getting pretty technical when all we want is a decent and safe vape. :( I guess that's the price of beneficial new technology.

Duane
 

TheotherSteveS

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 14, 2015
5,232
6,814
Birmingham, England
Yes, the other properties you mentioned are important but are much less sensitive to chemistry variation than Curie Temperature which relates strongly to TCR, thermal expansion characteristics etc.

I'm hoping that Ralph/Unkamen will find that they really didn't send him NiFe52 but some other NiFe alloy. It would be a real downer to find that the '52 alloy was terribly sensitive to specific batch chemistry.

For those who have tried the German equivalent to NiFe 52 what is the experience with TCR? Values?

Is there experience which indicates that the theoretical benefits of NiFe52 translate to practical day to day vaping benefits? What is the anecdotal experience?

Duane
absolutely..

SoI have been using the german NiFe52. The theoretical resistivity from steam engine has precisely predicted the resistance of the few coils I have wrapped. I have also been using it on the dicodes using a tcr of 41 (should be 40.6 i think) and the vape is excellent. I have also been using microcoils, dry pulsed and compressed as if they were kanthal with absolutely no issues so far! I am the biggest fan of Ti as many will know but I think the NiFe might displace it!
 
Last edited:

druckle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2013
1,149
2,193
Scottsdale, Arizona, USA
absoluteky..

SoI have been using the german nife52. The theoretical resistivity from steam enbgine has precisely predicted the resistance of the few coils I have wroapped. I have also been using it on the dicodes using a tcr 0f 41 and the vape is excellent. I have also been using microcoils, dry pulesed and compressed as if they wer kanthal with absolutely no issues so far! I am the biggest fan of Ti as many will know but I think the NiFe might displace it!

Good to know.

For anyone who wants to explore NiFe 52 (or equivalent alloys by another name) it would probably be safer to order from Germany until the whole Unkamen NiFe 52 puzzle is resolved.

Duane
 

dwcraig1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 17, 2012
9,013
49,304
Imperial Beach, California
Good to know.

For anyone who wants to explore NiFe 52 (or equivalent alloys by another name) it would probably be safer to order from Germany until the whole Unkamen NiFe 52 puzzle is resolved.

Duane
There should be more info on Monday evening, Ralph might have some and some others will be getting their orders of the NiFe in question. I agree with "better to order from Germany for now part"
 

jazzvaper

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 14, 2014
1,435
2,795
USA
absolutely..

SoI have been using the german NiFe52. The theoretical resistivity from steam engine has precisely predicted the resistance of the few coils I have wrapped. I have also been using it on the dicodes using a tcr of 41 (should be 40.6 i think) and the vape is excellent. I have also been using microcoils, dry pulsed and compressed as if they were kanthal with absolutely no issues so far! I am the biggest fan of Ti as many will know but I think the NiFe might displace it!

As posted above I have been wrapping 6 spaced NiFe 52 (Zivipf from Germany) on my GEM and SquapeRs (0.32 ohms) with more than decent results: dry-burning at 7 watts.

Very hesitant to build NiFe 52 for my two Kayfun 4's coz I have been 'expert' at Ni 200 on them for a long time. Rebuilt one with Ni 200 coming in at 0.15...a perfect vape on either the VS 200 or the Lavabox 200.

Built the second K4 as Ni 200 but wasn't careful. Not satisfying, wraps touching. So decided to build a contact (or micro-coil) on 2.5 Kuro with NiFe 52. I built 7 wraps which I now know was a mistake (at 0.43), dry-burned and slightly compressed. Should have wrapped 6.

Outstanding vape! Am certain vape will be perfect with 6 wraps coming in at the same ~ 0.30-0.32.

Will leave the Titanium Titans in their TiO2 dust. [emoji41]

ETA: Raised the Room Temp on my SX M from 20 C to 22 C with the NeFi 52 on the SquapeRs. Much more pleasurable.
 
Last edited:

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
I'm happily vaping on my three month old Ti coil. So... What's new around here to try out? :)
That's what I'm talkn' bout. 3 month old Ti coils rock!! If the one I'm vapn' on right now isn't 3 months old it's darn close. Thanks for your help with Ti early on Tony, your recommended low wattage dryburn technique is still workn' great for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread