Am I the only person who has a problem with ppl making juice in their homes?

Status
Not open for further replies.

AndriaD

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
21,253
50,807
64
LawrencevilleGA
angryvaper.crypticsites.com
I don't know whether you ever smoked or not but I appreciate how you made you point so well by using the same words every addict uses when they are confronted with their addiction.

I ____________because I choose to, not because I have to. I can quit at anytime.
You can substitute drink, {other stuff}, do {Other stuff}, ......, smoke, etc.

That's exactly right. I have quit every other addictive substance I've ever used, because I wanted/needed to do so. But as much as I wanted to quit smoking... I simply could not do it, and had resigned myself to a death like my father's, attached to a respirator in an ICU.

Then came e-cigs. And I will BE DAMNED if they ever get my rebuildables or my mods -- APVS or mechs. Because they finally -- FINALLY! -- made it possible for me to quit smoking. I know where to get "other stuff" and if nicotine becomes one of those black market items, then that's how I will buy it. I will not PERMIT any stupid laws or regulations to cause me to stop vaping AS I CHOOSE TO VAPE.

Andria
 

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
48
All over the place
AEMSA's defines WTA :

A full-spectrum mixture of all alkaloids extracted from whole tobacco. WTA can contain,
in addition to nicotine, anabasine, cotinine, myosmine, anatabine, and/or nornicotine, in
varying compositions, largely dependent on the tobacco species

...and the forbidden AEMSA substances are :

Section 2.05 The following will not be added or used in the creation of e-liquids
(a) Including but not limited to:

(i) Diacetyl
(ii) WTA (whole tobacco alkaloids)
(iii) Medicinal - or prescription medicinal
(iv) Illegal or controlled substances
(v) Caffeine
(vi) Vitamins or Dietary supplements (other than for preservative purposes)
(vii) Acetyl Propionyl (2,3-‐Pentanedione)
(viii) Artifical Food Coloring

1) AEMSA members will not add any artificial coloring or dyes during the e-liquid manufacturing process. Non vendor
manufactured flavorings containing artificial food coloring will identify food coloring information to include coloring
number in advertising and product descriptions


I have no idea why WTA is not allowed, I can only guess it is dangerous to breath those chemicals... maybe because as Doc Kistler mentionned, natural extracts can cause rotten lung disease.. I assume AEMSA is following present govt. regulations as in Diacetyl & Acetyl Propionyl.
Self regulation will impose some limitations.

I hope you find an alternative to WTA that will satisfy you.


Those alkaloids are tobacco alkaloids, just as nicotine -- they are minor and nicotine is major (about ~95% major to their ~5%). Won't go down this road much longer as this is getting weird. But know that if you vape nicotine liquid, you are vaping roughly 95% of the make-up of WTA. WTA is nicotine with the other tobacco alkaloids not isolated out of it, which is one reason why people that vape nic often feel much different than they did before when taking in tobacco -- they are missing the chorus (and no these aren't added chemicals, carcinogens or something nefarious). Not a bogyeman lung-rotter, just misunderstood (much like how those on the outside, and many on the inside, misunderstand the tobacco-alkaloid nicotine).
 
Last edited:

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
48
All over the place
What is the reason for WTA not being allowed by AEMSA ? There has to be a valid reason.

No, not really. I have nothing against AEMSA, but I also don't think they are infallible. You would need to ask them or ask someone that feels they are simply above doing things without valid reasons. But, since the only WTA vendor that was around when AEMSA started was producing these liquids out of a clean lab, this topic ain't really for this thread. Yeah, quite far from home-made. Hell, that vendor actually will give customers a tour of the lab and some of the procedures -- provided the customer will don lab attire.
 
Last edited:

AndriaD

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
21,253
50,807
64
LawrencevilleGA
angryvaper.crypticsites.com
Those alkaloids are tobacco alkaloids, just as nicotine -- they are minor and nicotine is major (about ~95% major to their ~5%). Won't go down this road much longer as this is getting weird. Know that you vape nicotine liquid, you are vaping roughly 95% of the make-up of WTA. WTA is nicotine with the other tobacco alkaloids not isolated out of it, which is one reason why people that vape nic often feel much different than they did before when taking in tobacco. Not a bogyeman lung-rotter, just misunderstood (much like how those on the outside, and many on the inside, misunderstand nicotine).

And as noted previously, I don't even get a great deal of the WTA, since I have to add other stuff just to bring the PG/VG to levels I can tolerate. But the WTA means the difference between "OMG the cravings are KILLING ME!" and "What cravings?" It also alleviates the mood disorders which afflict me even without throwing smoking cessation into the mix.

Since I started vaping, I've come to understand that by most standards, I'm not terribly dependent on nicotine -- I smoked ultra-light cigarettes for the last 20 yrs of my 39 yr habit, so I wasn't getting a lot of nicotine even from cigarettes, which is why I had to start vaping at 6mg -- more than that made me nauseous. I now vape at about 10mg, and that's comfortable for me, but still considerably lower than a lot of folks, particularly those who've been smoke-free such a short time. But those ultra-light cigarettes I smoked apparently still had the full complement of those other alkaloids, and for me, doing without those is pretty much a deal-breaker -- I don't know if I could have remained smoke-free without them; I do know it would be a GREAT deal more difficult.

Considering, as you say, that nicotine is 95% of the 'WTA spectrum' it really makes ZERO sense to disallow it from AEMSA qualification.

Andria
 

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
48
All over the place

Read it probably over one hundred times. Don't see what that has to do with AEMSA though and how those risks are worthy of exclusion -- when a simple test could've squashed it considering AEMSA must have test results of thousands of liquids from all their members. But, if those "ifs" are valid to them and more iffy than nicotine by itself, then that's their answer. If.
 
Last edited:

AndriaD

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2014
21,253
50,807
64
LawrencevilleGA
angryvaper.crypticsites.com
Read it probably over one hundred times. Don't see what that has to do with AMESA though and how those risks are worthy of exclusion -- when a simple test could've squashed it considering AMESA must have test results of thousands of liquids from all their members. But, if those "ifs" are valid to them and more iffy than nicotine by itself, then that's their answer. If.

I'd have to agree. I also agree with one thing rolygate stated, that if a person is doing alright with just nicotine, then there is no need to add the WTA and possibly increase one's risk. My first time around, before I got sick, I was doing well for the entire 3 1/2 months, no cravings at all, so I was disinclined to look into the WTA addition even though I felt it would probably alleviate the emotional dysfunctions that I did suffer, at the 3wk and 3mo points.

But, as observed in my sig-banner, quitting the 2nd time around was harder, and 1 1/2 wks into it, I started experiencing the most ungodly cravings; they just wouldn't let up, no matter how much I vaped -- and I was vaping the 10mg, not the 6mg I started with the first time. I had already acquired some WTA-Virginia, to add when I neared the 3wk and 3mo points, to try and avoid those awful depressive phases, so I went ahead and added it a bit ahead of schedule -- the day I added it, in the morning, when it got to be late that night, I suddenly realized that I had not had a craving all day. So I've kept it in the mix, though I lessened it after I was past the 3wk point; when I get closer to the 3 month point, I'll slightly increase it again, then when I get to the 3 1/2 mo point, I'll begin slowly tapering it down until I'm using just nicotine -- while keeping the WTA handy in case of cravings, because I already know that increasing my nic level just makes me ill, so that's not an option.

There might be more of a risk in using WTA than in using just nicotine, but as even rolygate observes, it is still considerably less risky than smoking; since WTA keeps me from even craving that almost-certainly-lethal habit, I'm willing to take the risk -- but I'm certainly not willing to put SNUS in my mouth!! EEEUUUWWWW!!!!! :p

Andria
 

Coldrake

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 5, 2013
1,208
2,500
The beautiful Puget Sound
I have no idea why WTA is not allowed, I can only guess it is dangerous to breath those chemicals... maybe because as Doc Kistler mentionned, natural extracts can cause rotten lung disease.
You're putting words in his mouth that he never said. Kistler never said natural extracts can cause "rotten lung disease".
 

Krashman Von Stinkputin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 31, 2013
447
871
Missouri
Those alkaloids are tobacco alkaloids, just as nicotine -- they are minor and nicotine is major (about ~95% major to their ~5%). Won't go down this road much longer as this is getting weird. But know that if you vape nicotine liquid, you are vaping roughly 95% of the make-up of WTA. WTA is nicotine with the other tobacco alkaloids not isolated out of it, which is one reason why people that vape nic often feel much different than they did before when taking in tobacco -- they are missing the chorus (and no these aren't added chemicals, carcinogens or something nefarious). Not a bogyeman lung-rotter, just misunderstood (much like how those on the outside, and many on the inside, misunderstand the tobacco-alkaloid nicotine).

Been starting to research DIY, so will be digging more into the AEMSA standards,

But on this subject do NET juices contain WTA and therefore not AEMSA compliant?

As a side note, was surprised to see "caffeine" on that list as that has been a prominent alternate additive option to juices at some of my local BMs, not to mention the entire high caffeine energy drink industry of the last several years being so prominent.
What are the fears regarding this?
 

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
48
All over the place
Been starting to research DIY, so will be digging more into the AEMSA standards,

But on this subject do NET juices contain WTA and therefore not AEMSA compliant?

As a side note, was surprised to see "caffeine" on that list as that has been a prominent alternate additive option to juices at some of my local BMs, not to mention the entire high caffeine energy drink industry of the last several years being so prominent.
What are the fears regarding this?

Technically yes, they may, but in reality, no they don't. The total alkaloids present in a tobacco soak liquid (NET) generally represent no more than about 2 mg/mL of the final product (small incidental extraction of alkaloids), so even if that were containing minor alkaloids, they would make up about ~5% of that 2 mg/mL. And that is still only "if" they are in there to begin with. ~5% of 2 mg per mL is going to be a stretch for any kind of effect of WTA.

p.s. I can totally see why AEMSA would not include NETs. Below is the link to Dr.Fs's other study (and you can see what and who was tested).

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...cco-nicotine-flavor-chemists-perspective.html

Edit: just realized I was spelling AEMSA incorrectly. Oops.

Edit #2: I see that AEMSA actually doesn't have a policy against NETs (based on MOV being a certified memeber). There goes my theory. (Not a knock on MOV or AEMSA at all though, just don't quite get it.)
 
Last edited:

rondasherrill

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 19, 2012
2,247
1,941
Valhalla
As a side note, was surprised to see "caffeine" on that list as that has been a prominent alternate additive option to juices at some of my local BMs, not to mention the entire high caffeine energy drink industry of the last several years being so prominent.
What are the fears regarding this?

I've gotten a caffeinated e-liquid before, and from what I noticed, they have to be shaken a lot, or the caffeine powder settles out easily. Not only that but in my limited experience it's total garbage anyway, since the caffeine particulate burns away on the coil, so it not in the vapor in any measurable concentration anyway.
 

Tangaroav

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 16, 2014
1,022
961
QC & FL
You're putting words in his mouth that he never said. Kistler never said natural extracts can cause "rotten lung disease".

My bad, he said natural extract flavors contains biological compounds and that could rot in your lungs. He recommends to stay away from organic compounds.

Now to be clear, he also said that the risks associated with those are probably less than smoking.
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
Not true.

stevergmu just posted a vendor that extracts its own nicotine right here in the USA. Thanks Steve I will be giving them a try. I also have contacted Halo and JC to ask if their nicotine is sourced in house or purchased overseas.
i seen that too.
however when some one says sourced,that doesn't necessarily mean extracted or manufactured here.
it could mean that or,it could mean it was purchased from a reputable company in the USA that has the proper
authentication procedures in place to prove it is what it say's it is.
:2c:
regards
mike
 

ItTechy

Information Tragedy dOOd
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 4, 2009
3,585
8,790
The State of Confusion
I had a heated debate this week with a local vendor who makes his juice that he sells in his "lab" which is just his living room. I tried to explain to him that his living room is NOT a sterile lab....and that the possiblilties for contamination are rampant. Air born pathogens, dust, dirt etc can easily get into this juice and then be inhaled (vaped)

I further explained that the need to sterile work space with stainless steel counters, sterile containers etc are a MUST.

I find it rather disgusting, although not surprising, that so many "juice makers" are popping up everywhere making juice in their homes and selling to unwitting newbies and even experienced vapers alike. Now with all this talk of Diacetyl (see Suicide Bunny for example) being found in our juices....and no disclosure from these guys...it's alarming to say the least.

We all quite smoking because we didn't want to die...slowly and painfully. Without any type of regulation we are at the mercy of these juice makers and their word about their products.

I personally will only buy juice from trusted vendors with test results to show that their juices are clean. I also always ask to see their labs. Any vendor who refuses to show me their lab and test results are discarded immediately.


am I alone here?

After reading through so many posts and opinions here is my two :2c: worth:

As far as DIY: This should mean exactly what it says; I mix my own juice, in a lab environment, however what I produce is strictly for my own personal use, period.

This is no different that any of us buying raw ingredients for our food, lets say. Now don't go bringing up the FDA and food standards, etc.. of course we have them. (regulations and standards for food)..

But it is not like it is in a restaurant, is it?

I was in a B&M Saturday morning in my town, and the people there were mixing up some juice like it was at a local coffee shop, or ice cream parlor; Bottles open, unlabeled, mix some of this with that, a bit more of this...TADA "smoke juice"....ah I don't think so!

I VERY RARELY buy mixed e-liquids, unless I know the source adheres to "clean lab standards", of which is all still the honor system currently.

I do feel that there has to be some standards if you will to make labs adhere to levels of cleanliness, and using safe ingredients, as after all we are consuming (vaping) these concoctions.

Just as one poster pointed out that where are many juice labs getting their nic base, and is it from the U.S. or overseas?

We need standards, we don't need more taxes and regulations that will only profit BP, BT, and the like.

Personally I could care less what anyone thinks about me being a DIY. I save a lot of money and having a degree in chemistry among others, I pretty much have a good idea of what I am doing.

I do not sell, or gift any of my e-liquids to anyone, so this is a personal freedom I have as an American I enjoy and feel I should not be threatened by big government and private corporate interests only trying to get rich off of my work!

I do not feel the same way regarding companies that produce anything for human consumption, be it eating, medicine, vaping, etc.

Where I was this weekend (at the B&M) many would not hesitate to buy their juices there, I would, why?

Simple; When you go out to eat the health department scores an establishment on various things regarding just about every aspect from preparing the food to who prepares it, and how long it has been in the refrigerator, etc.

We need the same standards in the vaping juice suppliers, and it can be done without getting big businesses into it, but it will take a concerted effort from suppliers to form these standards and to have everyone abide by them....

Not an easy task by any means....

Darned if do, darned if we don't....

Happy Monday!:vapor:
 
Last edited:

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
i seen that too.
however when some one says sourced,that doesn't necessarily mean extracted or manufactured here.
it could mean that or,it could mean it was purchased from a reputable company in the USA that has the proper
authentication procedures in place to prove it is what it say's it is.
:2c:
regards
mike

I know Halo has said a number of times absolutely no ingredient comes from China. Don't know about India, though..
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
5-6 years ago, CASAA formed about the time that the FDA illegally held a shipment of nic liquid. It was decided that what they did was illegal . Be careful what is wished for. Back then, China imported liquid was 99% of what was available.

It would be great to have some kind of approval system . But I'd like to see it come from within. I don't think good reputable suppliers would be against having their liquid tested periodically.

I just really don't like seeing Chinese imports being bashed because it was a Chinese doctor that created this, and also supplied most or all of the Liquid and no one batted an eye.
i agree with you totally.
if one has a supplier selling food grade and pharmaceutical grade materials the proper documentation and
certification should already be in place.
there should be no need for a juice maker to be testing this and that as its already been done theoretically.
they only need to account for accurate measuring,good packaging and, cleanliness.
proper record keeping and scheduled testing to insure their own procedures are being followed.

i believe current commercial regulations already in place are sufficient for any juice maker.
most if not all the bigger and more well known makers are already there or beyond.
this talk of lab sterile facilities is pure nonsense.some processes require it as in the making of micro circuits
or working with biological materials and hazardous substances.
in most cases when something has to be made in lab sterile conditions its because they are not
so much worried about whats getting into the product,their worried about some or all of the
products ingredients getting out in an uncontrolled fashion.

i also agree just because it comes from China that doesn't mean its not made to
world class standards.as a percentage i don't believe they have any more foul ups
than we do.
:2c:
regards
mike
 

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
48
All over the place
I know Halo has said a number of times absolutely no ingredient comes from China. Don't know about India, though..

No offence to Halo as I do and always will have an affinity for them, but wording like that is how things can be deceiving. Like a vendor can say, "our eliquids are made here in America" when technically speaking, yes, the "eliquid" was, but none of the ingredients necessarily had to be.

To iTechy, I don't think anyone here said anything regarding your right or you ability to make fine eliquids out of your home, but I said that if you make those flavored liquids out of your home under the guise of staying totally away from avoidable risks (like DA/AP), you are no more likely able to do than buying premade liquid since you will be using the same ingredients and from the same flavoring suppliers based on their verification -- which is how we got into the mess with DA/AP.

And as far as B&Ms not being like restaurants, well, I don't believe you've only gone to or seen restaurants that are considered fine dining with immaculate conditions, but I pass up restaurants everyday that have some of the absolute nastiest conditions to be preparing food and I don't see any warning on any of their doors (at least not out here), but I also don't see a lot of people trying to dine there. Maybe the health department is aware of these nasty establishments, but they're up and running. So what gives? And we aren't even talking about businesses where you have to be 18 or older to consume their product. Yes, I have seen Kitchen Nightmares, the show and in real life. And though it's been stated to the point of ad nauseum, people get sick or worse everyday from the what's being served in our food service industry, but aside from stories of bad practices in vape B&Ms, I don't know of much more than those stories of unprofessional mixing habits -- if someone has more than stories, and actual incidences of deaths or medical emergencies due to mishaps at B&Ms, though the two are wildly different, the vape B&Ms actually would seem to be faring fine in comparison to the restaurant industry in terms of health incidences.

I agree that some sort of standards for mixing are a good thing and it would be nice if we had them across the board, but short of making it a government-down regulation, keeping it out of tobacco and pharmaceutical companies' interest will be next to impossible.
 
Last edited:

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
The guys making basement brew who can't test for dangerous substances or levels of dangerous substances shouldn't be in business...

if they are buying supplies from a reputable distributor what possibly could be the problem.
measure once,recheck your measurement,add your ingredients, stir.
use clean equipment and clean work space.
only deliberate contamination would cause harm.
i wouldn't think they would use kerosene to be thinning the mix. having said that,
if they are going to sell it then,they have to comply to commercial grade standards.

on the other hand lets not forget how many spaghetti sauces and cookies where started
in some ones kitchen.
:2c:
regards
mike
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
They can impound PRC nic for all I care; domestic extraction already exists...
the point is the FDA can more easily control and regulate domestic manufacturers.
ban overseas imports,control and regulate the domestics.

and oh,by the way you wont be purchasing any nic base as you wont be able
to obtain the proper permits.

other than that everything is honky dorry.
:2c:
regards
mike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread