Wouldn't have been possible if I hadn't found Capella's "Chocolate Coconut Almond" flavoring. He refused to give up on that Almond Joy idea.
Well, don't tell your Dad this, but...I ordered a 4oz. bottle of TFA Chocolate Coconut Almond flavoring hoping for the same Almond Joy type results. However, I haven't arrived at the desired taste yet, after several tries at different combinations of flavorings with it, to hopefully get there. I've tried adding more TFA Coconut and/or TFA Coconut Extra with no success. Also tried adding some more TFA Chocolate and TFA Bittersweet Chocolate. Next try will be with some TFA Coconut Candy, which is sweeter than either of the others.
I will say though, the flavoring is pretty good with just a very small amount of TFA Maraschino Cherry in with it, since that Cherry is very strong.
IF I hit upon what actually tastes like an Almond Joy though...I'll be sure you're the first one I let know about it!