New studies find carcinogens in vg and pg at high temps, even in tootle puffers

Status
Not open for further replies.

NU_FTW

Ultra Member
Dec 6, 2016
1,205
2,962
42
Oh gawd, remember when this used to be our guide:

VapingPowerChart2-1.jpg
my lord I haven't seen this chart since I first started vaping
 

Cosmic_Glaze

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 26, 2016
948
3,828
If choose to use SS and have a mod with adjusyable tcr I would recommend using 430SS. 316 can be fussy on some mods
Do you have a link for a good place for us to get 430SS? And the tcr # setting.. does it work well at 138 tcr or do you adjust it? I've been playing around with SS316l and I agree can be hit or miss some times...
The other question I have is if you are adjusting the tcr settings to read diff than the suggested value from SE are you still getting correct temp readings or are you just tweeking the numbers to get a good vape.. I have seen many peoples posts online that adjust the tcr to get a vape that they like from the wire,...but is that temp control?? I would think not if it is not in the correct tcr setting. I could be wrong, but if you are not in the correct setting for the wire, your temp control would be off. Am I understanding that correctly?
 

NU_FTW

Ultra Member
Dec 6, 2016
1,205
2,962
42
Do you have a link for a good place for us to get 430SS? And the tcr # setting.. does it work well at 138 tcr or do you adjust it? I've been playing around with SS316l and I agree can be hit or miss some times...
The other question I have is if you are adjusting the tcr settings to read diff than the suggested value from SE are you still getting correct temp readings or are you just tweeking the numbers to get a good vape.. I have seen many peoples posts online that adjust the tcr to get a vape that they like from the wire,...but is that temp control?? I would think not if it is not in the correct tcr setting. I could be wrong, but if you are not in the correct setting for the wire, your temp control would be off. Am I understanding that correctly?
only easy test to tell if your device temp tcr is accurate is cotton burn test. There are flir and ir means to check temp too adjust tcr accordingly
 

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
I did. I understand it now, but I still don't get how I can tell if my mods over 470 since I can't use tc because my tank doesn't have tc coils,
You can keep reading the thread but views vary greatly on that subject. Tc vapers will tell you that without TC you can't tell what temp you are vaping at. That's true but that doesn't mean you are vaping at too high of a temp with kanthal. I believe the safest way to vape is with tc set to 450° or less on a properly set up tc rig but we all have rationalizations for what we do.
 

Imfallen_Angel

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 10, 2016
1,711
2,763
Ottawa area, Canada
Do you have a link for a good place for us to get 430SS? And the tcr # setting.. does it work well at 138 tcr or do you adjust it? I've been playing around with SS316l and I agree can be hit or miss some times...
The other question I have is if you are adjusting the tcr settings to read diff than the suggested value from SE are you still getting correct temp readings or are you just tweeking the numbers to get a good vape.. I have seen many peoples posts online that adjust the tcr to get a vape that they like from the wire,...but is that temp control?? I would think not if it is not in the correct tcr setting. I could be wrong, but if you are not in the correct setting for the wire, your temp control would be off. Am I understanding that correctly?
just fyi..

I had lots of trouble with my SS316l for a while, trying it in my single coil decks, I just couldn't get it working right.

Dual decks turned out to not be an issue at all, my mods that weren't doing TC correctly with SS in my single decks were all working flawlessly.

More testing on my single coil deck and I eventually figured out that the problem all along. It was simply that I wasn't using enough wire...so as per my previous posts, my advice is to simply put in as large a coil that will fit it your deck.

Simply put: SS's variance is very small, so you need enough metal to register properly.

NI200's variance is huge compared, and why you can get away with much smaller NI coils in builds, some being even too small for some decks. (gauge of wire being a factor)
 

MacTechVpr

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 24, 2013
5,725
14,411
Hollywood (Beach), FL
...

From a regulatory position, you could argue all these confounding variables make it impossible to assure safety, so forget all those variables, keep it to an approved design set. That already applies to other products sold in the US which are subject to regulation, so it's not without precedence.

Yep, the political bureaucrat's irrational inverse reasoning…if it won't be controlled, regulate it + tax it.

Unless we end up with no regulation (and I find that one tough to believe in) it will, if sane, objective decisions are made end up somewhere in between. Variety will decline, and feature sets become as much about safety as vaping satisfaction.

Regardless, as I cite often as example…just like the 55 MPH speed limit, people will always resort to what is reasonable and do what they will.

Every controlling paradigm eventually yields to human ingenuity. What remains is the force and aggression of government, unchallenged. It persists, if we allow it, to promote the indefensible.

Good luck. :)
 

cigatron

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 14, 2014
3,213
13,374
clinton ar
Do you have a link for a good place for us to get 430SS? And the tcr # setting.. does it work well at 138 tcr or do you adjust it? I've been playing around with SS316l and I agree can be hit or miss some times...
The other question I have is if you are adjusting the tcr settings to read diff than the suggested value from SE are you still getting correct temp readings or are you just tweeking the numbers to get a good vape.. I have seen many peoples posts online that adjust the tcr to get a vape that they like from the wire,...but is that temp control?? I would think not if it is not in the correct tcr setting. I could be wrong, but if you are not in the correct setting for the wire, your temp control would be off. Am I understanding that correctly?

28 gauge Stainless Steel Wire - 430 Grade Nickel Free - 200 feet - 100% Guarantee - Creating Unkamen

I have not used this 430ss. I'm still working on a spool I got from a friend. It came from zivipf in Germany.

138 tcr should work with 430ss. See chart.
TCR-500x281.jpg


When you get a new spool of wire, any wire, it's a good idea to test it's tcr using the 420°f dry cotton browning test. Once I find the actual tcr for a new spool I mark the tcr on the spool.
 

Cosmic_Glaze

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 26, 2016
948
3,828
only easy test to tell if your device temp tcr is accurate is cotton burn test. There are flir and ir means to check temp too adjust tcr accordingly
I've playing around with it on my Pico with RDAs. In SS mode I get a good vape at 420f.. if I set it to the correct tcr 88 420f it stinks.. 470 not good but very cool vapor but flavor is weak.
Tcr of 92 (316) not a good vape(420-470) and not the same as the default SS. Can't find out what the default setting is I thought it was 316l.
I guess it's time to cook some cotton Bacon.
28 gauge Stainless Steel Wire - 430 Grade Nickel Free - 200 feet - 100% Guarantee - Creating Unkamen

I have not used this 430ss. I'm still working on a spool I got from a friend. It came from zivipf in Germany.

138 tcr should work with 430ss. See chart.
View attachment 640267

When you get a new spool of wire, any wire, it's a good idea to test it's tcr using the 420°f dry cotton browning test. Once I find the actual tcr for a new spool I mark the tcr on the spool.
Nice tip. Thanks.
 

NU_FTW

Ultra Member
Dec 6, 2016
1,205
2,962
42
I've playing around with it on my Pico with RDAs. In SS mode I get a good vape at 420f.. if I set it to the correct tcr 88 420f it stinks.. 470 not good but very cool vapor but flavor is weak.
Tcr of 92 (316) not a good vape(420-470) and not the same as the default SS. Can't find out what the default setting is I thought it was 316l.
I guess it's time to cook some cotton Bacon.

Nice tip. Thanks.
I had to adjust my tcr to 100 ish from the 88 se had recommended each spool will vary. Best to calibrate first then test vape at diff temps
 

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
I fooled around with TCR for a while with the Koopor Plus 200W before giving up and going back to power mode. I didn't get the memo on Ni200 and tried to dry burn and anneal! Not a fun experience. I went to SS316 that works well for most in power mode and tried the TCR at 88-92 and got terrible hot and crackly vapes. Running TCR up and down in small increments through a wide range didn't work. There's no wattage set mode in TC for the Koopor Plus 200W. They send you to the hard, normal, soft, max, min modes to adjust the vape intensiy for TC mode.

I have several other TC mods now. Maybe it's time to try it again,
 

NU_FTW

Ultra Member
Dec 6, 2016
1,205
2,962
42
I fooled around with TCR for a while with the Koopor Plus 200W before giving up and going back to power mode. I didn't get the memo on Ni200 and tried to dry burn and anneal! Not a fun experience. I went to SS316 that works well for most in power mode and tried the TCR at 88-92 and got terrible hot and crackly vapes. Running TCR up and down in small increments through a wide range didn't work. There's no wattage set mode in TC for the Koopor Plus 200W. They send you to the hard, normal, soft, max, min modes to adjust the vape intensiy for TC mode.

I have several other TC mods now. Maybe it's time to try it again,
single or dual coil? It's been said here ss316l can be finicky in single coil (I wouldn't know only dc here) ss430 has been recommended which I want to try but haven't found trustworthy source for 26 awg
 

Johnnyvapor18

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
87
25
30
Hasn't this study been dubunked? Saying that if you were to hit the vape while it was that hot that it wouldn't taste good and you wouldn't even be able to hit it or like it. Now this 470 degrees this is all new , but I've been sub ohm vaping that high for years and itntaste just fine. That's just my opinion but I thought this got debunked all ready.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mowgli

Cosmic_Glaze

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 26, 2016
948
3,828
I had to adjust my tcr to 100 ish from the 88 se had recommended each spool will vary. Best to calibrate first then test vape at diff temps
Ok after testing and burning some Bacon.. 100 tcr on the Pico is good for SS316L and provides at 420f-440. Don't know what the default settings for SS are still but gonna stick with tcr 100. That test was done on a single coil RDA.

Now I know that it works cause I have an RDA and RTAs, but what about those that are Vaping on pre built tank coils? They can not do these tests and have to rely on mod maker to be accurate for them. Many have proven time and time again that they are not accurate...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread