Deeming Regulations have been released!!!!

Bronze

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 19, 2012
40,240
187,930
Then you'll have to disagree with his guest, Ashley who works with BT lobbyists and us on HR2058/Cole-Bishop.

I'm sure these folks don't get paid to lobby the wrong pieces of legislation.
I don't trust BT as far as I can throw them. Sorry. You go ahead and believe what you will. BT fights for themselves not us. When the day of reckoning comes they'll make sure they are taken care of and drop the vaping interests like a bad habit. Let's see where they spend their lobbying/litigation money (or if they spend it) and how they spend it...right to the very end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Kadly

Spazmelda

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 18, 2011
4,809
4,513
Ohio
Again, there is a disconnect between the literal interpretation of what the FDA said it can do, and what it actually CAN do.

The ref is written such that they can remove 18650s, surgical cotton, welding wire, and a bunch of other things from the market if they don't receive a PMTA.

They can't.

Not as in " they shouldn't", or "that's just crazy", they CAN'T.

The minute they try to regulate 18650s they also have to regulate q-tips, tampons, and plastic bottles.

The regulation is written so that they can regulate everything used for vaping, but, at the end of the day, they only thing they'll be able to say anything about is packaged products with nicotine and/or labeled for vaping nicotine.

Haha, if it wasn't expensive to apply (I'm assuming it cost money to apply as well as to do the research, not quite clear on that) I'd start submitting a bunch of PMTA applications for q-tips, paper towels, rayon, wet wipes, screwdrivers, wire clippers, etc...
 

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
I always thought the smart approach would be to limit nicotine strength.
Make it illegal to buy or sell over a certain limit.

Ultimately leading to the Demise if DIY users.............No thanks.:grr:
I strictly purchase in 100mg/ml strength for simplicity of use.
.3ml in 10ml mix = 3mg/ml
.9ml in 30ml mix = 3mg/ml

The Product can be safely handled and provides for easy storage with minimal environmental impact - less containers per usage for disposal.
:)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Steamix

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 21, 2013
1,586
3,212
Vapistan
Totally agree.......Case in point:
Ever see those Vuse(sp??) commercial where they say 'One less cigarette smoked is a victory'? Where do you think they got this line? Altho, no one can prove it, it has been said on this forum countless times since my being here(2010) and way before these commercials ever started. Makes one wonder just how many 'spies' have read the forums and continue to glean info for their uses, or to use against us.
Read one just last night, member claiming to be a 3 year vaper-er,(altho new to ecf) saying they were having problems with equipment they were using. The more they explained their problem led one to believe they were fishing more for info than actual help. Why do I bring this up? Just wanting everyone to be aware that unfortunately not everyone who graces any ecig forum is always here for the reasons the majority of us are.

mods: if this is not acceptable pls delete. Not trying to cause any problems, just impart info.

Astro turfing ? Astro turfing my behind !

Vaping's been grass roots from the very beginning.

How long has vaping been around till you saw the first prime time commercial for it ?
Regulated box mods trace their origins to mech mods.
Mech mods crafted by vapers.
I daresay that the innovation and evolution is driven by the vapers themselves.
Industry just follows suit.
Remember where you saw the first Clapton coil ?
Was it a vendors website or a youtuber's channel ?

And if vaping gets a dunk, it'll just become grass root again. Growing like a mycelium.

Advertising or rather banning it ranks very high in their list. Tryin to keep the remaining smokers ignorant is top priority in their books. Cuz someone who isn't aware of viable alternatives, isn't going to look for one.

Penning in the sheep ...
 

Sugar_and_Spice

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 11, 2010
13,663
35,225
between here and there
Astro turfing ? Astro turfing my behind !

Vaping's been grass roots from the very beginning.

How long has vaping been around till you saw the first prime time commercial for it ?
Regulated box mods trace their origins to mech mods.
Mech mods crafted by vapers.
I daresay that the innovation and evolution is driven by the vapers themselves.
Industry just follows suit.
Remember where you saw the first Clapton coil ?
Was it a vendors website or a youtuber's channel ?

And if vaping gets a dunk, it'll just become grass root again. Growing like a mycelium.

Advertising or rather banning it ranks very high in their list. Tryin to keep the remaining smokers ignorant is top priority in their books. Cuz someone who isn't aware of viable alternatives, isn't going to look for one.

Penning in the sheep ...
????I think you missed my point.
 

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
How much are the application fees?
We've been focusing on the PMTAs and I haven't heard much about application fees.

To get an Idea of Cost, read through this:
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/TobaccoProducts/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/UCM277665.pdf

There is No APPLICATION per say, only a Monstrous list of Documentation required for submission for Application(Permission) to Market a Product.
Then Add in the Per Hour FDA charge up to or Exceeding 5000 hours. :facepalm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Kadly

Rossum

Eleutheromaniac
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2013
16,081
105,232
SE PA
Kind of points toward government's irrelevance then as well. Government has nothing to do so needs to create criminals and bogey men to show itself attempting to do something. "Look, we got important stuff to do." Meanwhile, they go into their offices and nap knowing there is really nothing to do. Take into account the Hegelian Dialectic & it seems fairly summed to me. We ought to start Chicken Littles out as Chicken Littles, spades as spades. Then, just laugh as they tell you the sky is falling but only they have the best plan on how to save us all, children first.
You've cracked the code. They want us to live in fear. In fear of foreign enemies. In fear of terrorists. In fear of violent criminals. In fear of climate change. In fear of "dishonest" businesses who wish to poison the children with second-hand smoke (or vapor). Such fears lead people give up their freedoms, to delegate ever more power and give more ever wealth government, in the (mostly false) belief that government will "protect" them. It's practically the same strategy used by organized religion for thousands of years.

"Excuse me but no, I'm not interested in your solution for your problem that you created in order to sell me, your solution. I no longer consent to playing your silly game. Thanks, have a good one."
Bravo!
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
I didn't say "application fees". PMTA = premarket tobacco product applications
But we were talking about why Big Tobacco would support the Cole-Bishop amendment.
If the Cole-Bishop amendment passes nothing has to go through the PMTA process.

That's why I didn't understand what applications you were referring to.
:)
 

Sugar_and_Spice

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 11, 2010
13,663
35,225
between here and there
Astro turfing ? Astro turfing my behind !

Vaping's been grass roots from the very beginning.

How long has vaping been around till you saw the first prime time commercial for it ?
Regulated box mods trace their origins to mech mods.
Mech mods crafted by vapers.
I daresay that the innovation and evolution is driven by the vapers themselves.
Industry just follows suit.
Remember where you saw the first Clapton coil ?
Was it a vendors website or a youtuber's channel ?

And if vaping gets a dunk, it'll just become grass root again. Growing like a mycelium.

Advertising or rather banning it ranks very high in their list. Tryin to keep the remaining smokers ignorant is top priority in their books. Cuz someone who isn't aware of viable alternatives, isn't going to look for one.

Penning in the sheep ...
I totally agree with everything you just wrote....just don't know why you used my posting as a vaulting point since they are basically saying the same thing??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Kadly

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
But we were talking about why Big Tobacco would support the Cole-Bishop amendment.
If the Cole-Bishop amendment passes nothing has to go through the PMTA process.

That's why I didn't understand what applications you were referring to.
:)

Even IF Cole-Bishop passes, it still Stops Market advancement! However there are Benefits in the Amendment that play into Best Interest of BT.
It Unquestionably Solidifies their products in Market and they have the Best chance of even getting SE Applications Approved.(also most finances:oops:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: nicnik

Steamix

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 21, 2013
1,586
3,212
Vapistan
Not really.

I take it as a given that they're reading along.

Just as our vaping fellas from the 'fine city' know that certain parties take an undue interest in their postings.

Meaning any creative impetus from the vaping community runs the risk of getting hijacked or squashed.
Above post was just meant to outline the creative energy that came from the vapers themselves.
So no wonder they'll be milking the 'enemy' for 'intelligence'. Could save them a ton of bread in R & D .
Scared of what vaping ingenuity might come up with next, they are.
Who knows? Water vaper from potato concentrate ? :D

BT got caught with their pants down on the vaping thing. Surely they won't let that happen again.

I've got nothing to hide. I'm interested in living longer and healthier while enjoying an alternative that gives me the chance to do that. Most natural motivation for any human being there is.

I have no plans biting the dust in favour of your bottom line.

Cuz you see, the people around me, they 'profit' in a different way when I'm with them a little longer.
One more hug. One more kiss. One more smile.

Nothing that your accumulated 'profits' could pay for ...
 

KODIAK (TM)

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 31, 2014
1,898
4,983
Dead Moose, AK
I don't trust BT as far as I can throw them. Sorry. You go ahead and believe what you will. BT fights for themselves not us. When the day of reckoning comes they'll make sure they are taken care of and drop the vaping interests like a bad habit. Let's see where they spend their lobbying/litigation money (or if they spend it) and how they spend it...right to the very end.

Whoa now friend. I have the same sentiments regarding BT. :)
I just brought this whole thing up because someone up the line stated Big Tobacco had a hand in writing these regs. Far from the truth.

It's certainly a head-scratcher to be sure.

Even IF Cole-Bishop passes, it still Stops Market advancement!
Seems to be the only way to kill the flood of subtanks. :)

Wonder what the Youtube hardware reviewers will do.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
I dunno. Isn't that like saying the only way BT can dominate the smoked tobacco industry is if open systems (pipes and hand-rolled cigars) are not allowed, or whole leaf tobacco is not allowed?
While I will admit that open tobacco systems allow for better flavor options.
I'm not sure the flavor is THAT much better to widely overcome the convenience factor.

But when it comes to vaping, the gap between flavors is much wider.
Altria doesn't have Unicorn Milk or Tribeca.

And many people feel the wide range of choices is more important than convenience.

On the other hand, the FDA can still wipe out flavors if Cole-Bishop gets through.
So I guess I'm gonna have to think on all this a bit more.

This whole thing about Altria supporting Cole-Bishop really has me scratching my head.

If any open systems are available at all, then Altria flavor offerings aren't going to cut it.
But maybe they'll just start reselling Unicorn Milk or something.

Or maybe just buy someone out so they have a good lineup of flavors?
I wish I knew what I was missing here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rossum

MyMagicMist

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2014
1,159
2,465
53
You've cracked the code. They want us to live in fear. In fear of foreign enemies. In fear of terrorists. In fear of violent criminals. In fear of climate change. In fear of "dishonest" businesses who wish to poison the children with second-hand smoke (or vapor). Such fears lead people give up their freedoms, to delegate ever more power and give more ever wealth government, in the (mostly false) belief that government will "protect" them. It's practically the same strategy used by organized religion for thousands of years.


Bravo!

Ultimately leading to the Demise if DIY users.............No thanks.:grr:
I strictly purchase in 100mg/ml strength for simplicity of use.
.3ml in 10ml mix = 3mg/ml
1.2ml in 30ml mix = 3mg/ml

The Product can be safely handled and provides for easy storage with minimal environmental impact - less containers per usage for disposal.
:)

Same strategy also used by organized crime, by aristocrats, by any falsely claiming any authority over anyone else. They use enforcers to force us to obey policy, look at the police, policy enforcer. If they can cause enough fear and people start policing themselves, it gets termed self censorship. Where censorship lives so do tyrants.

Kind of surprised that so far the citizens/serfs are not taking up the Roman tradition of painting towns red. Although, I maybe ought not be surprised considering. Seems 9 out of 10 times the house wins. Don't think anyone has tended the count to know which time we face currently.
 

Bob Chill

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 22, 2013
1,773
5,360
Sans Nom, USA
While I will admit that open tobacco systems allow for better flavor options.
I'm not sure the flavor is THAT much better to widely overcome the convenience factor.

But when it comes to vaping, the gap between flavors is much wider.
Altria doesn't have Unicorn Milk or Tribeca.

And many people feel the wide range of choices is more important than convenience.

On the other hand, the FDA can still wipe out flavors if Cole-Bishop gets through.
So I guess I'm gonna have to think on all this a bit more.

This whole thing about Altria supporting Cole-Bishop really has me scratching my head.

If any open systems are available at all, then Altria flavor offerings aren't going to cut it.
But maybe they'll just start reselling Unicorn Milk or something.

Or maybe just buy someone out so they have a good lineup of flavors?
I wish I knew what I was missing here.

One thing Halo will have a hard time getting is the distribution channel that BT has. You are exactly right. BT won't develop their own unique line if the GF date is changed. They will buy their way into the market. The industry has already figured out what is popular.

BT won't be interested in niche or boutique anything. A good analogy is Miller Lite vs AlphaHoppy's Super Barley Pale Dark Stoutaporter. Miller Lite is cheap and in every single store that sells beer in the US. AlpaHoppy is in niche boutiques. Does Miller care? Nope, they got their cheap beer on every shelf and millions of drinkers to buy it.

IF open systems are allowed, BT will dominate the cheap and "palatable" juice market. Expensive niche juice will be there for those who can afford it and desire it. But it won't compete with BTs convenience store sales.

Once taxes are figured out, I highly doubt nic juice will be available online. It will need a state tax stamp just like alcohol and cigs.
 

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
Whoa now friend. I have the same sentiments regarding BT. :)
I just brought this whole thing up because someone up the line stated Big Tobacco had a hand in writing these regs. Far from the truth.

It's certainly a head-scratcher to be sure.

Actually inference may be to Writting the Original Regs establishing 2007 Deeming, which it is well documented - they were extremely involved with. That is the very core<PMTA/SU/SE> of these revisited Deeming Regulation updates.

*BT, along with the FDA, Built a BOX only they Fit into.
:cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lessifer

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,619
1
84,742
So-Cal
Was wondering if a US manufacturer of eliquids, was manufacturing said eliquid in the US for a customer in lets say Britain, and this eliquid was of course tpd compliant, and not to be sold in the US, would this surpass said deeming regulations?

I'm not 100% sure of this. So someone Correct me if I'm Wrong.

But I believe that the FDA Rule Set Only applies to Sales and Distribution Inside the USA.
 

Eskie

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2016
16,087
77,744
NY
I'm not 100% sure of this. So someone Correct me if I'm Wrong.

But I believe that the FDA Rule Set Only applies to Sales and Distribution Inside the USA.

They only have jurisdiction within the US. There are plenty of meds not approved for sale by the FDA in the US that are unavailable in other countries, with or without a prescription.

Wonder what the Youtube hardware reviewers will do.

So long as the reviewer is not selling or distributing the product, or receiving compensation to review the product from the seller, they can do and say whatever they like. First Amendment rights are not waived by any regulation or pending bill. The FDA only has standing in enforcing regulation of advertising and marketing of the tobacco (or any other product under their perview) to by the seller/marketer, just as the FTC can regulate advertising for other consumer products to prevent false claims.
 

Users who are viewing this thread