Fredman1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Mar 27, 2017
4,052
22,790
68
New Zealand
I've used both wires extensively and there's no doubt that the same build on Ni80 ramps up faster than KA1.

Try this experiment - try a 5 wrap round wire build of 24G Kanthal and a 5 wrap round wire build of 24G Nichrome and you'll know straight away. It's not even a subtle difference.

That's one reason why mech users like it - you can have a bulky coil with Ni80 that ramps up nice and fast.

I've had a look at the wire wizard calculator on Steam Engine and can see the numbers and read the definition of heat capacity, but it's not clear how that applies to ramp up time.
Yeah mate I have done the experiment...I posted about it above. That's what set off this whole thing for me. I built two identical coils..one Ni 80 and the other Kanthal. To me they ramp up the same, but according to Steam Enjin the Kanthal is faster....fractionally.
Heat capacity as I understand it, is how the ramp up speed of a wire is measured.

Ni 80 takes more wraps to get the same resistance as Kanthal...but even if I project Ni80 to the same amount of wraps as Kanthal (using SE), the Kanthal is still faster on ramp up....fractionally.

This is a screen shot from Steam Enjin about heat capacity
Screenshot_20211130-130204~2.png

This is further down. I'm not to flash in the English department...you will make more from it..?
Screenshot_20211130-130414~2.png
 
Last edited:

AngeNZ

ShutterBug
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
  • Mar 24, 2018
    11,556
    89,945
    New Zealand
    Yeah I read that. Again, not according to Steam Enjin. Check it out. Nichrome 80 has a higher heat capacity than Kanthal.
    That actually makes sense to me. If Kanthal has a higher resistance than Ni 80 it has more "electric" friction, thus it'll heat faster.
    I know it's the general consensus, and always been said that Ni 80 is faster than Kanthal, but Steam Enjin's figures shows that it's not.
    Riddle...isn't it;)

    I've used both wires extensively and there's no doubt that the same build on Ni80 ramps up faster than KA1.

    Try this experiment - try a 5 wrap round wire build of 24G Kanthal and a 5 wrap round wire build of 24G Nichrome and you'll know straight away. It's not even a subtle difference.

    That's one reason why mech users like it - you can have a bulky coil with Ni80 that ramps up nice and fast.

    I've had a look at the wire wizard calculator on Steam Engine and can see the numbers and read the definition of heat capacity, but it's not clear how that applies to ramp up time.

    Yeah mate I have done the experiment...I posted about it above. That's what set off this whole thing for me. I built two identical coils..one Ni 80 and the other Kanthal. To me they ramp up the same, but according to Steam Enjin the Kanthal is faster....fractionally.
    Heat capacity is how the ramp up speed of a wire is measured.

    Ni 80 takes more wraps to get the same resistance as Kanthal...but even if I project Ni80 to the same amount of wraps as Kanthal (using SE), the Kanthal is still faster on ramp up....fractionally.

    My understanding is that you are both right.

    Using a 5 wrap 2.5mm id 24g coil:
    Ni80:
    0.321 Ω
    Heat flux per Watt 10.31 mW/mm²
    Heat capacity 46.01 mJ/K
    Mass 102.93 mg
    Density 8.31 g/ccm

    Ka1:
    0.427 Ω
    Heat flux per Watt 10.31 mW/mm²
    Heat capacity 40.45 mJ/K
    Mass 87.94 mg
    Density 7.10 g/ccm

    On Steam Engine, kanthal does have a slightly lower heat capacity of compared to an identical ni80 coil. That tells me the kanthal will be cooler to vape than the ni80. But I don't know if that correlates to ramp up.

    But like @Pigs I've experienced a huge difference in ramp time between ni80 and other wires. My guess is the differences in Density and Mass are also playing a part - when we're talking about ramp up.

    To see a difference @Fredman1 you may need to go for some longer identical coils. Completely forget about having the same resistance.

    I'd use two coils with say 8 wraps each, so that there's a bit more of a delay for them to ramp up.
     

    Pigs

    Vaping
    ECF Veteran
    Jun 7, 2019
    7,425
    53,314
    Sydney Australia
    Yeah mate I have done the experiment...I posted about it above. That's what set off this whole thing for me. I built two identical coils..one Ni 80 and the other Kanthal. To me they ramp up the same, but according to Steam Enjin the Kanthal is faster....fractionally.
    Heat capacity is how the ramp up speed of a wire is measured.

    Ni 80 takes more wraps to get the same resistance as Kanthal...but even if I project Ni80 to the same amount of wraps as Kanthal (using SE), the Kanthal is still faster on ramp up....fractionally.

    This is a screen shot from Steam Enjin about heat capacity
    View attachment 963883
    This is further down. I'm not to flash in the English department...you will make more from it..?
    View attachment 963885
    Interesting stuff Fred :thumb:.
    I'd hoped that Ange would chip in here - she understands the scientific side a lot better than me. The idea of using larger massed coils (more wraps) for a new experiment seems a good one.

    I'm thinking I might send an email to Steam Engine and see if they can explain the correlation between heat capacity and ramp-up in layman's terms. Will post something if they get back to me.
     

    Fredman1

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Mar 27, 2017
    4,052
    22,790
    68
    New Zealand
    Hitting the hay here.

    @Fredman1 Built the Kumo and it's a fantastic RTA. I'll post pics and review in the morning :wub:
    I knew you'll like it Charlieman. It's one hellova tank...for sure :thumbs:
    Can't wait to try the Cabeo.
     
    Last edited:

    Fredman1

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Mar 27, 2017
    4,052
    22,790
    68
    New Zealand
    I'd use two coils with say 8 wraps each, so that there's a bit more of a delay for them to ramp up.
    I'll do that. That would give a much better indication.
    Ah..Congratulations on your win Ange :thumbs:

    Interesting stuff Fred :thumb:.
    I'd hoped that Ange would chip in here - she understands the scientific side a lot better than me. The idea of using larger massed coils (more wraps) for a new experiment seems a good one.

    I'm thinking I might send an email to Steam Engine and see if they can explain the correlation between heat capacity and ramp-up in layman's terms. Will post something if they get back to me.
    That's would be interesting to hear their response mate.
     

    charlie1465

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Dec 30, 2014
    10,789
    72,866
    Roquebrune sur Argens, Var, France
    Good morning shinies :wub:

    Here's the "finally built" Kumo sitting on a Mixx.... fantastic RTA.
    20211130_070146~2.jpg


    Similar to the Brunhilde in that it is basically and RDA sitting on top of a tank. But the wicking system is truly innovative. It has a disc on the bottom of the 'chimney' which sits just shy of the bottom of the tank. The liquid is transported up and onto the cotton. So simple but soo efficient...you'll like this one T and it looks so much better than the Brunhilde....a real winner and so well machined. Aspire and Steampipes have knocked it out of the park with this one. So many spares and accessories too.

    Have a good day everyone :wub:
     

    Fredman1

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Mar 27, 2017
    4,052
    22,790
    68
    New Zealand
    Good morning shinies :wub:

    Here's the "finally built" Kumo sitting on a Mixx.... fantastic RTA.
    View attachment 963903

    Similar to the Brunhilde in that it is basically and RDA sitting on top of a tank. But the wicking system is truly innovative. It has a disc on the bottom of the 'chimney' which sits just shy of the bottom of the tank. The liquid is transported up and onto the cotton. So simple but soo efficient...you'll like this one T and it looks so much better than the Brunhilde....a real winner and so well machined. Aspire and Steampipes have knocked it out of the park with this one. So many spares and accessories too.

    Have a good day everyone :wub:
    Glad you like it mate. This is the wicking system of the future...i'm sure.
    Next challenge for the designers will be to make a bottom airflow with this wicking system ;)

    Where do you like the airflow?
    I'm like it with 3 holes...but only 3/4s open :D
     
    Last edited:

    charlie1465

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Dec 30, 2014
    10,789
    72,866
    Roquebrune sur Argens, Var, France
    Glad you like it mate. This is the wicking system of the future...i'm sure.
    Next challenge for the designers will be to make a bottom airflow with this wicking system ;)

    Where do you like the airflow?
    I'm like it with 3 holes...but only 3/4s open :D
    I need to have it wide open and then it's perfect!!

    I had a little bit of an issue while wicking. I deliberately wicked it quite loosely as I've had some issues with dry hits on the Brunhilde. I had the same at first with the Kumo until I really made sure the wick was 'stuffed' down on the deck. Now it's wicking really well but the airflow is a tad tighter. I've tried clearing the wick around the coil but no dice....any tips??
     

    chanelvaps

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Oct 3, 2013
    16,074
    85,478
    Burbank CAlifornia
    Hi S!
    Might be worth trying out Ni80. I started using it when I was vaping rdas on mechs.
    I loved the faster ramp up and preferred the taste to KA1.
    I also liked that compared to SS, I was drawing less current on a similar build with Nichrome (higher ohms/ft). Felt safer.
    Don't vape those setups so much now but I kind of got used to it. Still my fav wire.
    Hi T, I have not used Kanthal in a long time but only SS. I might just try some Ni80. It is certainly easier to find than SS.
     

    chanelvaps

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Oct 3, 2013
    16,074
    85,478
    Burbank CAlifornia
    Seriously??!! I had to go and check as I didn't remember entering any comps :lol:

    But I've won an Innokin Kroma 217 kit!! I am so stoked :thumbs::thumbs::thumbs:
    Its all those beautiful pics! The Gods are watching! They told Innokin.
     

    Fredman1

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Mar 27, 2017
    4,052
    22,790
    68
    New Zealand
    I need to have it wide open and then it's perfect!!

    I had a little bit of an issue while wicking. I deliberately wicked it quite loosely as I've had some issues with dry hits on the Brunhilde. I had the same at first with the Kumo until I really made sure the wick was 'stuffed' down on the deck. Now it's wicking really well but the airflow is a tad tighter. I've tried clearing the wick around the coil but no dice....any tips??
    The only thing you can do is to make sure the legs are well spread so there's no obstruction for the air to flow.
    Yeah I also cut a bit on the long side... so the cotton lays well on the deck. I haven't yet had a hint of a dry hit though.
     

    Users who are viewing this thread