FDA issues notice of intent to propose "deeming" regulation by April of 2013 for e-cigarettes and other tobacco products

Status
Not open for further replies.

HarmonyPB

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 19, 2011
2,620
1,678
38
Houston, Texas, USA
www.facebook.com

Vocalek

CASAA Activist
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Maybe you answered this in your post but you used too many big words for me to understand (I'm not being sarcastic, seriously, I'm simple minded). Why do you not like e-liquid called juice? I frequently call it juice and am curious.

Because since Day 1, one of the false accusations we have been fighting is "Public health experts expressed concern that electronic cigarettes could increase nicotine addiction and tobacco use in young people."
FDA and Public Health Experts Warn About Electronic Cigarettes

In the media, these claims have been amplified, with the spokesperson usually a Public Health official or a doctor who has probably never seen a real e-cigarette in his life, or ever talked to a smoker who tried the recommended products and treatments only to fail over and over and over again.

A "concern" that they "might be" grew into declarations:

E-cigarettes are typically designed to resemble conventional cigarettes, cigars and pipes. There are also products that look like pens and USB memory sticks. They are being marketed to young people and available in flavors such as chocolate and mint. This raises a concern for health experts that these products may increase addiction to nicotine in young people.

Pharmacy News

The logic goes that fruit flavored (or other pleasant-flavored) liquids will make kids want to try out e-cigarettes, and then they will be addicted to nicotine, and then want more nicotine so they will switch to smoking. There is not a shred of evidence that any of these things have happened. But these accusations appear in almost every news story we see.

So please, please, don't call it something that might make a young child think you were being literal and try to drink it. You wouldn't call anything else that is poisonous by a name like "juice" or "ice cream" or "candy" that might make little ones think "I want some too."

"They even call it 'juice'," could be something that the ANTZ (Anti-nicotine and tobacco zealots) add to their arsenal of lies against ecigs.
 

HarmonyPB

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 19, 2011
2,620
1,678
38
Houston, Texas, USA
www.facebook.com
Because since Day 1, one of the false accusations we have been fighting is "Public health experts expressed concern that electronic cigarettes could increase nicotine addiction and tobacco use in young people."
FDA and Public Health Experts Warn About Electronic Cigarettes

In the media, these claims have been amplified, with the spokesperson usually a Public Health official or a doctor who has probably never seen a real e-cigarette in his life, or ever talked to a smoker who tried the recommended products and treatments only to fail over and over and over again.

A "concern" that they "might be" grew into declarations:



Pharmacy News

The logic goes that fruit flavored (or other pleasant-flavored) liquids will make kids want to try out e-cigarettes, and then they will be addicted to nicotine, and then want more nicotine so they will switch to smoking. There is not a shred of evidence that any of these things have happened. But they appear in almost every news story we see.

So please, please, don't call it something that might make a young child think you were being literal and try to drink it. You wouldn't call anything else that is poisonous by a name like "juice" or "ice cream" or "candy" that might make little ones think "I want some too."

"They even call it 'juice'," could be something that the ANTZ (Anti-nicotine and tobacco zealots) add to their arsenal of lies against ecigs.

Oh! I get it now. Thanks! Luckily I never talk to children. I only discuss ecigs on the forums or with adults irl.
 

Maxwell_Edison

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 5, 2009
1,655
237
Ohio
beatlesnumber9.com

kristin

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
10,448
21,120
CASAA - Wisconsin
casaa.org
Because since Day 1, one of the false accusations we have been fighting is "Public health experts expressed concern that electronic cigarettes could increase nicotine addiction and tobacco use in young people."
FDA and Public Health Experts Warn About Electronic Cigarettes

In the media, these claims have been amplified, with the spokesperson usually a Public Health official or a doctor who has probably never seen a real e-cigarette in his life, or ever talked to a smoker who tried the recommended products and treatments only to fail over and over and over again.

A "concern" that they "might be" grew into declarations:



Pharmacy News

The logic goes that fruit flavored (or other pleasant-flavored) liquids will make kids want to try out e-cigarettes, and then they will be addicted to nicotine, and then want more nicotine so they will switch to smoking. There is not a shred of evidence that any of these things have happened. But these accusations appear in almost every news story we see.

So please, please, don't call it something that might make a young child think you were being literal and try to drink it. You wouldn't call anything else that is poisonous by a name like "juice" or "ice cream" or "candy" that might make little ones think "I want some too."

"They even call it 'juice'," could be something that the ANTZ (Anti-nicotine and tobacco zealots) add to their arsenal of lies against ecigs.
I would also add to Elaine's great points that "juice" sounds like very strange slang to non-users, so it could bring to mind illicit drug or alcohol use, ie. "get juiced up." (Same reason I don't like people using "take a hit" and nicotine "buzz" in public discussions.) Additionally, "tobacco juice" is the stuff tobacco chew users spit into cups and sometimes on to sidewalks - another negative connotation for non-users to associate with e-cigarettes.
 

Maxwell_Edison

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 5, 2009
1,655
237
Ohio
beatlesnumber9.com
"What about the children?" has been a red herring in many arguments on different topics, it's designed to appeal to stupid people's emotions. The fact is, young people view these as something older people use to quit smoking. They're not 'cool' and unfortunately young people are still attracted to real cigarettes. But like the THR anti-lie blog posts says, logical, rational, truthful arguments consisting of facts is not the approach to use when dealing with antivaping psychotics. If truth and facts were taken into account, we wouldn't be having this discussion right now. I'm sure this is all about money in the form of cigarette taxes and Pharma stop smoking aids that don't work. The byline in the FDA's header that they exist to protect the public health is laughable. That's why I support CASAA - they know how to deal with the lunatics. Mass lame-stream media is also corporately owned and thus against vaping, so public info and public support is not there for us. We need to mobilize with CASAA and create a team that will get the job done.
 

zippersnapper

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 18, 2012
3,179
4,866
Has anyone got some back up plans in case "the unthinkable" should happen and we can't buy nic juice, mods, cartomizers etc????


"You better know it"...

I can't afford to stock pile, and even if I could I'd eventually run out. Yeah, black market, or something, anything. Or maybe it's best to not worry till the time comes? idk what to do to be honest...

The "I cant afford to stockpile" statement is a big problem....
Worrying about it when it happens, is a tad bit too late I'm afraid..
 
Last edited:

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,628
1
84,757
So-Cal
Maybe you answered this in your post but you used too many big words for me to understand (I'm not being sarcastic, seriously, I'm simple minded). Why do you not like e-liquid called juice? I frequently call it juice and am curious.

Of course I also call my PV an ecig and regularly refer to cartos as carts. In my world, where I frequently deal with other simple minded people, if I use confusing terms like personal vaporizer I would just get confused looks. Ecigs are now wide spread enough that if I use that term then people generally know what I'm talking about. And I don't have to go through a 20 minute explanation of what a personal vaporizer is just to have the other person say, "Oh an ecig". Which would have to be followed by another 20 min. explanation of why it is NOT an ecig and why I despise that term. Which would just get me labeled as a snob and that person would be less likely to talk to me in the future. Lol! That wasn't really supposed to turn into a mini rant and is in no way directed at you Zoid. My fingers just kind of ran away with me.

You can ignore that last paragraph, I still want to know the answer to the initial question.


I think Vocalek summed part of my views quit well below…




So please, please, don't call it something that might make a young child think you were being literal and try to drink it. You wouldn't call anything else that is poisonous by a name like "juice" or "ice cream" or "candy" that might make little ones think "I want some too."

"They even call it 'juice'," could be something that the ANTZ (Anti-nicotine and tobacco zealots) add to their arsenal of lies against ecigs.

Aside from the Potential Hazard of accidental poisoning by calling e-Liquids “Juice”, it doesn’t seem to convey the concept to people Exactly what an e-Liquid / e-Cigarette is to me.

And that is a Harm Reduction Device that has given me the ability to Stop Smoking and Improve my Overall Health.

BTW – I have No Problem using the term “e-Cigarette”.
 

FloridaNoob

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 7, 2012
184
52
Holiday, Florida
I'm not to sure about that. Seems more like they want to keep the revolving cash cow merry go round' well greased...

Smoke, then try to quit using FDA approved NRT's-start smoking again because the NRT's don't work-Try to quit again, etc, etc,...

Why hasn't our government put Big Tobacco out of business by now? Shut them down, lock stock and barrel. Cigarettes are killing people, isn't that enough? I want a answer to that very simple question without "politics" being used as an excuse.

Like was said in another reply. Tax money......but not only just tax money but jobs. Think about something, and I hate saying this, too. BT actually employs a LOT of people, from the tobacco farms, the the manufacturing plants, to the distributors, to the stores selling them. Then on the flip side BP employs a lot of people dealing with the downsides of smoking. Think about what would happen if everyone stopped smoking and just went to vapping. You would be putting a lot of people out of work. It doesn't take as much to create our products compared to cigs, and BP would not have to make as many NRTs or other items. So ironically by making it a *sin* but not making it against the law they are making big revenue and keeping jobs.
 

zippersnapper

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 18, 2012
3,179
4,866
Like was said in another reply. Tax money......but not only just tax money but jobs. Think about something, and I hate saying this, too. BT actually employs a LOT of people, from the tobacco farms, the the manufacturing plants, to the distributors, to the stores selling them. Then on the flip side BP employs a lot of people dealing with the downsides of smoking. Think about what would happen if everyone stopped smoking and just went to vapping. You would be putting a lot of people out of work. It doesn't take as much to create our products compared to cigs, and BP would not have to make as many NRTs or other items. So ironically by making it a *sin* but not making it against the law they are making big revenue and keeping jobs.

Ohhhhh Agree 100%...Whats REALLY sad is it may put a serious dent in the revenue generated by hospitals, doctors, hospice care,oncology, and such. To many Jobs lost, major upset to the economy.

Ahhh yes "Major Upset/Unbalance " to the economy....Love your Country-Hate your Government...
 

Petrodus

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Oct 12, 2010
7,702
8,132
Midwest
Ohhhhh Agree 100%...Whats REALLY sad is it may put a serious dent in the revenue generated by hospitals, doctors, hospice care,oncology, and such. To many Jobs lost, major upset to the economy.

Ahhh yes "Major Upset/Unbalance " to the economy....Love your Country-Hate your Government...
1-ThumbsUp_zpsc134b2bb.gif
 

Jman8

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 15, 2013
6,419
12,928
Wisconsin
The "intellectual progressives" believe they know what is best
and they will decide what will and will not be allowed.

Anything that is not politically sanctioned should be forbidden...
not because of the harm to the individual but enjoyment without
government sanction is considered wrong.

:?:

Funny that 'they' have become what they despised most. That which sits in judgment of societal sins and promotes selflessness over self-fulfillment.
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,628
1
84,757
So-Cal
Funny that 'they' have become what they despised most. That which sits in judgment of societal sins and promotes selflessness over self-fulfillment.

Maybe it is about this at all.

Not about Right or Wrong. Or Good versus Evil.

Maybe it is just about Money. Or should I say. Who gets the Money and what form it comes in.
 

zippersnapper

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 18, 2012
3,179
4,866
Maybe it is about this at all.

Not about Right or Wrong. Or Good versus Evil.

Maybe it is just about Money. Or should I say. Who gets the Money and what form it comes in.


Should I dare say, what I feel???

I'm thinking a good old fashioned revolution is in order. How much can the American people put up with from our government?

We have politicians who give themselves raises at the same time making sure they have healthcare for free for the rest of their lives,
not to mention a fat pension.

Nobody can agree on anything, thus nothing gets done...My God I love my country, even with all its faults but to be honest I think with our deficit cliff, and everyhting else that is taking a nose dive, its time for a major house cleaning...of 1776 kind.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread