Logic, Pro-Tools or DP?...
Sonar and PT9 here...
Pro Tools 10, Maschine, Serato Scratch Live, and Serato DJ. I think my 2nd and 3rd choices (to replace PT) would be Ableton Live and Reason.
The reason I'm willing to put up with Apple's is that all of my music gear (including all the computers, drives, software, plugins, virtual synths, etc.) would cost less to replace than buying a decent console that even comes close to the PT mixer and just it's Channel Strip plugin.
Heck, just replacing the DDJ-SX (controller for Serato DJ) with equivalent hardware that doesn't use a computer would cost more than all the computers I've bought in the last decade.
The Provari is not nearly that one-sided of an argument.
Once you allow yourself to let go of your perceived logic and buy a Provari, you will then realize that in the end you got what you paid for. And kick yourself for waiting so long to get it.
I did not kick myself for waiting "so long" (6 months or so since I knew vaping was the answer) to buy it. Apart from the fact that I still think the Silver Bullet is prettier, I have no regrets. And I'd still want an Empire no matter how big my stable of PVs was, despite the fact that it's kind of the opposite of practical.
I'm glad I bought it, and my gear lust seems sated for the moment. But it's not like it was life-changing.